Fantastic food. Great service. Wonderful atmosphere. My only complaint is it's a little hard to tell where to order and sometimes you have to wait a bit before you're noticed.
Nuff Said. How many places on Urbanspoon do you see with a 100% rating? If you're only eating one meal in Afton, make it here. Halibut... clam chowder... okay I'm getting hungry.
My Favorite in Star Valley. Fresh seafood. Good number of choices. Friendly service.And not just great seafood. This is the place to come is you have a BBQ coming up that you want to go all out on the steaks! You will never be dissapointed turning here. My old man always get's the tentacles. I always thought he was gross until I tried some last visit. very good! But my reccomendation is the Cod Parmesean!!! To die for! ..come back.. eat some more and die again! lol
This is one of best quaint seafood resturaunts I have experienced. Food is great, the place is clean, the location suprising! But mostly the staff are not just friendly, they treat you like friends! Great value, at every level!
Even in a small town, you know a place is good when there's no empty tables available. And even with a wait to order our food, we were still served hot food pretty quickly.
We've eaten here a few times in the past and it always satisfies our seafood appetite. Today we tried a crab cake as an appetizer--not the best but not bad. We then had the coconut shrimp basket (pretty good) and the battered salmon plate (also pretty good). Although we didn't get it today, my favorite basket is the baked salmon.
If you're in Star Valley, there aren't a lot of dining choices so be sure to stop in and get some delicious seafood.
Landlocked? Not an obstacle.. I come from Australia where we pride ourselves on fresh seafood. Fish and chips is a staple Aussie family meal. Who knew I would eat the best battered fish I have ever tasted in a small country town in landlocked Wyoming? Simply perfect.
Michael Jamie Johnston
+4.5
Heavenly Food in God's Country. So mysterious and rewarding finding a seafood restaurant so far from the ocean. The maritime decorations are both pleasing and awe-inspiring. Finding our way in to this little treat located next to Dog-Eared Books was a huge surprise. The fish smells great upon arrival and a fish-haters menu is even included for crowd-pleasing. The staff was very client-oriented and pleasing. My only complaint is the dilapidated paint in the bathroom but it is Afton after all. A great treat for some very close friends and I. Even the baby loved sucking on the shrimp.
Have eaten here on many occasions. Seafood is always fresh, hot and delicious and the service personal. Hard to find fresh seafood in WY let alone Afton but this place is great!
Amazing. Great little 'hole in the wall'! You wouldn't expect to find such a great seafood restaurant in small town Wyoming. Serve fish and chip style baskets (cod, Halibut, Salmon, shrimp, etc) along with a few other items. They do make a mean ribeye also. Small menu, but the quality can not be beat!
I cannot say enough good things about this restaurant! The tartar sauce and cocktail sauce were obviously fresh and homemade. There was mint jalapeno jelly that was truly delicious! I had calamari and fries. The calamari was crispy fried and not chewy at all. The staff was very helpful and friendly. I'm pretty picky when it comes to seafood and left very pleased and full.
OMGosh!!! Talk about a pearl!!! What a find!!! I have had seafood all over the world and this is at the top!!! Right in the heart of the mountains of Star Valley in the town of Afton. The restaurant is pristine with huge windows and a view of the mountains. The cod and chips were incredible, the calamari basket was absolutely spot on!! And the Chowder was one of the best I’ve ever had!! If you’re in this neck of the woods, it’s a must!!! Way to go Rocky Mountain Seafood!!!
A gem in Afton excellent flavor and freshness cooked to perfection. Had the clam chowder and halibit tacos. Yummy!
Being from the Gulf Coast, It's been hard to find decent fish & chips and fried seafood in the Rockies, The Ahi tuna is so delicious always order a side up and Clam strips too, I always ask for the garlic cheese fries with our order.. Ask for the jalapeno jelly for dipping too.
TL;DR- I'm not completely sure I understand how this place exists but I'm thankful that it does.
Rocky Mountain Seafood completely lives up to the reviews. I just polished off the fish and chips and could swear that I heard a foghorn in the distance as I bit into the perfectly fresh, lightly battered cod. The fresh cut fries from local potatoes are equally delicious. Let me net it out for you... we're far away from either ocean but somehow this joint has a case full of fresh fish and seafood. I came in here as a son of the Chesapeake that grew up with the smell of the canneries in my lungs and expected to immediately turn tail for the Mexican joint (also great) up the street but it's great! I would've brought my waterman grandpa in here without hesitation if he were still with us. Try it, you'll love it!
Food was really good. My Rib-eye was a little over cooked but it still seasoned well and tasted amazing. The cut of Rib-eye is good quality and worth the price. The potatoes skins app we ordered was ok.
Very, very pleasantly surprised by the quality and selection of seafood at this establishment for dining in or for cooking at home. Nice selection of fresh fish/seafood at the counter including halibut, salmon, tuna, shrimp, calamari etc. While a lot of the dine in selection is fried there are also many broiled options. Amazing calamari rings or strips. Fried to perfection with light breading and NOT greasy. Coleslaw is some of the best that I have tasted anywhere. Highly recommended. Will be back!!!!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes