The best Restaurants in Aquebogue ranking of April 2025
7 restaurant menus in Aquebogue, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
"A terrific location on Meeting House Creek. Several rooms including outside dining area. It was windy so we took window seats with great view. We..."
Antoinette Merenda Carbone
"I've been here a few times. The service is always great. Food is decent but wouldn't say amazing(food is good but generic)and as expected for..."
Ashley Perez
"I have to say Great service, Amazing Food, Cold drinks, Never been disappointed and there's a beautiful view of the north shore on the outside..."
Helen Fox
"The whole experience was wonderful. The food was creative and delicious (kudos to the inventive chef). The waiter (Matt) was attentive and..."
Rafael Marrero
"I would consider On The Docks to be at a hidden gem in Aquebogue. The restaurant resides on a beautiful canal right on the water and has plenty of..."
James Wood
"Not only is the service great and friendly, but the food is phenomenal. The steak with the blue cheese was the best steak I've ever had in my life...."
Jessica Nelson
"Went to dinner for another special occasion. My wife asked for her steak to be med well and to butter fly her meat. Her steak came out rare, so we..."
Jim B
"The location is top notch! A pity it was a bit too cold for outside seating, but that did not stop us from enjoying the wonderful view. The food was..."
Carmen Russell
"We love the place, they’re friendly. Good meals and drinks. They have a variety of dishes well prepared. It’s open year round. In The summer..."
paty brady
"We had a delightful meal there last night 9/8/23 and We want to compliment all the staff for their excellent service with particular mention to our..."
"Been coming to this restaurant for my whole life and it’s always been great. I would definitely recommend the Modern Snack Bar to somebody who’s..."
James Wood
"Deliscious food and amazing drinks! For anyone who loves fried flounder, this is the place to go. I can't wait to go back and have another Mai Tai..."
Tanya Layburn
"The dining rooms are very tight, and the tables are tiny, so if you have loud or large people at your table or the one next to you, you can guarantee..."
Chooch Magooch
"Visiting this place is like taking a refreshing step back in time in regards to both the food AND hospitality. The roasted duck and crab cakes were..."
John Connelly
"Otto the owner of this fine establishment turned 80 today and we were lucky enough to meet him and experience his restaurant all in one day!..."
J
"We visited because a friend of ours remembered eating here when her family came to North fork as when she was a child. The food was excellent...."
Barney Simon
"One of the best prime ribs I have ever eaten. Cooked perfectly and tender. Will definitely have it again. Also love their potato..."
Barbara Zebroski
"My husband went specifically for the soft shell crab, which he said was "really good". I had the turkey dinner, yum. Also tried the "Happy Apple"..."
spotsfriend
"My recent visit to "The Modern Snack Bar" on the North Fork of Long Island was an absolute delight. The restaurant exuded warmth and charm, and..."
Simaan Gaffary
"We have been meaning to stop here forever. My husband and I and 2.5 yr old had a nice Saturday lunch.
It’s real rustic and like stepping back in..."
Kristen Slevin
"I love the Modern Snack Bar. My Dad lives near there and when I visit we go for lunch many times. Everything I have had there is delicious. The..."
david gray
"I’ve been coming here my entire life. It feels so good even to just walk through the door. There’s just so much nostalgia emanating from the..."
Sara Parrish
"One of my favorite places out east! Great pies and fried chicken. My husband loves their turkey dinner! Worth a..."
Mary Ann Devine
"This place never ever disappoints. The food is always fresh homemade and delicious. Reminds me of when I was young and my Mom took me to..."
Theresa Ottomano
"That good old timey feel! A great place for nothing fancy, American food but taste great. We have driven past this place many times over the years..."
Katherine
"The Modern is a North Fork staple that is no frills perfect. Everything is homemade and just awesome. When Peconic Bay scallops are in season, this..."
"I have no visual proof but trust me.. Go !! The cornbread, shrimp boil, SmashBurger, Blackened Fish Sandwich ( it was a group of us lolol)were all..."
Rodino Janowski
"We had a good little meal at the old Little Lucharitos. Same owner but different concept. Seafood boils and BBQ. It was real good. A small place but..."
Mike “Bar.snobs” DeMarino
"The only thing I wish I could change about my visit was my appetite, I would’ve eaten the whole menu if I could. Absolutely delicious! I had the..."
Lauren Hoetger
"The food and drinks were amazing. We ordered the BBQ chicken quesadilla, the BBQ duck quesadilla, and the shrimp quesadilla. All were delicious I..."
Kelli Holloway
"Worth the drive from anywhere on the island!
Great food, great service. Can't remember if there was a diaper changing station in bathroom. Location..."
Nicholle Fernandez
"Was driving past on my way out East and my wife and I stop for bbq. Tatyana was an exceptional server, brisket sandwich was amazing and drinks where..."
Stephen Reilly
"We just happened by this restaurant while on a Sunday drive. The seafood and BBQ combination is great for us. My husband ordered a lobster tail boil,..."
Russell Murphy
"I would recommend this place for fresh tacos. My son had 3 chicken tacos and said he could eat another 5 l, they were that good. I had a pulled pork..."
Jeffrey Lewis
"Shrimp boil with juju sauce and dungeonous crab with Cajun sauce; free corn potatoes and tomatoes. Buckets bags toss away cardboard tins. Fresh naps..."
Jaime Sumersille
"Kim the server was awesome! Really liked the mustard BBQ wings, spicy crabdip and chips, and the smoked brisket Carolina vinegar sauce 😋 was on..."
"Loved it! Stopped in on way home from pumpkin picking. While we love the other major coffee company, it was nice for a change. Perfect location..."
Chris C
"This must be one of the best coffees out here. I would always pass this gem but never stop, until today. Im so happy I stopped. Wherever I go I..."
Geo P
"Great coffee selections and welcoming staff. I enjoyed sitting outside to drink my coffee. There's limited parking in the back (it was pretty busy..."
Liz (Liz)
"We stopped by for a quick breakfast. Loves the sausage egg and cheese and the ham Gruyère and egg sandwiches. The iced coffee is delicious with a..."
S R
"Great coffee and a nice variety of pastries, but the service is the real highlight. Friendly personable staff make this a regular stop for me..."
Buck Schley
"I didn't get any food, but man, it did look good. This was the first time I had been here and I only ordered a coffee but the caramel mocciato that I..."
Robert Nelson
"Delicious! I'm so glad to find a place with flavored iced coffee! (Actual flavored coffee, not added..."
Rose Connelly
"Yummy coffee, delicious scone. Nice..."
Heidi Burmann
"Beautiful, cozy place, good espresso based coffee. A little bit price. Originally the place was rebuild from mechanic shop. Check the photos at the..."
cosmopus
"Super cute place, excellent service. Loved the coffee and pastries. Will go there on purpose just to sit a little bit outside while having my..."
silvia cristovao
"Delicious iced coffee..."
Holly Loughlin
"Excellent cold brew. Nice clean shop. Open..."
Keith Grande
"Coffee is quite good. Staff wear masks. Most of the patrons walking in wore masks. Bathroom was..."
Kenneth Tejada
"Love the location and their drinks. Took one star off because it is nearly impossible to make a left into or out of here if there is any traffic...."
Aly G
"Great place to stop and pick up a coffee. There is extremely limited seating inside. Outside tables, but weather controls if you use them.
Drinks are..."
"Excellent choice just outside of Riverhead. Delicious pasta and seafood dishes by Sicilian-born chef Gambino. We loved our table on the porch in..."
Janice F
"Sat wirh no wait at a pretty little table on the porch. (Have to note that upon leaving there appeared to be quite a wait so make your resys early)...."
Demi Laino
"Had some delicious pasta at Il Giardino. The pappardelle bolognese, the salmon pasta and the lemoncello cake were absolutely delicious. The rib eye,..."
PM
"Il Giardino "The Garden" is a farm to table scicilian restaurant by the Great John Gambino & its now one of my favorite places! I had such a..."
michael lapadula
"My wife and I had our first dinner here last month and were very pleased by the quality of the food, the friendly service and the charming..."
Sal Tantillo
"We recently moved to Greenport and been looking for a nice spot for dinner, a good friend recommended Il Giardino to my husband and we went here last..."
Dannisaur
"Hands down one of the best places on the Island to eat at. Food is out of this world and John the owner takes so much pride in his food and the..."
Bryan C
"One of the best meals I've had in a LONG time! Everything they served was excellent. The wine, the appetizers and the main course were all amazing...."
Craig Rose
"I’m very skeptical about Italian restaurants (hard to beat someone’s Nonna lol) but I may have had a dinner that I loved. My partner suggested we..."
John Paul Simon (JPS)
"We passed by this place so many times and finally went in. Wow! Everything was amazing! The food was delicious. Such a great combination of..."
James Dunn
"So glad we came here. Atmosphere is fantastic, love that the restaurant is converted from an old home. Our waitress knew the drink and dinner menu..."
Melina Spahija
"We had a wonderful Sunday dinner outside at this restaurant.The baby eggplant, calamari and bowtie salmon were delicious as were our watermelon..."
Marya Bell
"The food is always good and the variety is great. However, we were sitting in the "garden." The garden could use some trimming. My mother had..."
Barbara Schmidt
"Great food! Great drinks! Beautiful garden seating! Great service! The owner is the cook and not only is the food fresh and delicious, but he is..."
T Bryant
"Reservation system not so great …everything else AMAZING!! Great place!! Absolutely loved everything! Good food, amazing service, great atmosphere!..."
Deborah Siggilino
"Definitely recommend if you’re by the vineyards. We were a party of 4 and had a great time. Calamari, Ribeye Steak, Pasta Allá Nonna, Tiramisu and..."
"Great! Went in to order a half dozen sandwiches and salads for a last minute, small party. They looked through and suggested to set up platter. ..."
Jim Del Rossi
"Stopped by this afternoon to get something quick to eat and ordered two heros. My hubby said it was the best Pastrami and Swiss melt he ever had and..."
Kathryn Casalino
"A small soup, and a bag chips. $10.50. The soup was old and had no..."
Heidi Burmann
"Always has been my favorite deli and now I take my son here often 5 stars..."
Brian Linnen
"Exceptional deli. Wonderful food and service. Prices are..."
Robert Higgins
"Best local deli. Super friendly and food is..."
George Elia
"Took my nephew Seth here for breakfast. It was really good. Especially the toasted everything bagel with cream cheese tomato and pepper..😋..."
Maryann Amato
"Friendly service with a smile. Great sandwiches! The coffee cakes have been a personal fav for decades! Has a little of everything including milk of..."
Eyeja
"This place makes an incredible sandwich just like I grew up with and I'm 69 years old. I was blown away by the quantity and quality of the sandwich,..."
ed jodry
"Great place to pick up a sandwich and some salads. Friendly and efficient..."
Stuart Selip
"One of the best delis around the great service and you won't break the..."
Tommy Chic
"Always a good stop on a Saturday or Sunday or any day of the week. Egg sandwiches are on point. I dont usually go for lunch, but I got the famous..."
Daniel Young
"Best deli on the north fork. Sandwiches are awesome and breakfast is great too. Lou also has a butcher section. Pricey but excellent..."
Maryel Balletta
"The sandwiches are hand made and stacked high. Salads are..."
Colleen Lorge
"Basic deli with a wide variety of options and a great location. Don't expect to be paying absolute minimum prices on stuff not made by the deli. My..."
Kat Bernhardt
"Great service and delicious grilled chicken wrap. Stopped here before driving out to Orient Point State Park for a..."
Ken M
"Just stopped by for a quick egg sandwich cause I'm working right by here.
Quick service. Nice staff
Definitely a good stop for a good breakfast and..."
Damian Benitez
"You will never be disappointed when going to the meetinghouse deli !! With a multitude of choices and always fresh selections the food is..."
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes