Shannon Newerth-Henson
+5
My husband and I visited Slice of Humboldt Pie at the end of August. The atmosphere was great! Plenty of indoor and a outdoor seating. We went for dessert - I had the Lemon Raspberry Pie and my husband had the Peanut Butter Fudge! It was AMAZING!! We visited the restaurant on our last night in Arcata, I wish we would have had more time to go back and try the savory pies!! I highly recommend!
Thank you so much to Sam and Patrick for all their help. They gave great service today, our first time to this establishment from the Bay Area! We loved the chicken pot pie and empanadas so much we bought some to bring home! We will definitely be coming back for the great service, pie, and ciders!!
Patrick and Kela helped us out. Got chicken pot pie and strawberry rhubarb, and sloppy Joe and corn& cheese. The Squirt and Coke just didn't do justice. Service was outstanding. My CPP was the best I've ever had. It's clean, sorry, fun... Worth the >1 hour drive.
got the pork hand pie and a slice of lemon raspberry; i’ve also had the peanut butter fudge and chocolate silk and they’re all unbelievable!! great crust, great filling, and super cute outdoor seating. love this place!!
Fun little pie and cider shop in Arcata. We tried several different flavors of pie and couldn't try them all. They also had a large savory pie menu that we didn't explore. Many buying full pies.
One local suggested asking about the "second chances" menu for 50% off on items. Guessing day-old menu. Didn't confirm that menu.
Had both indoor and outdoor patio seating.
I would go to Eureka just for this restaurant. The gluten free crust is decent (flaky but a little too starchy {potato?} for me) but it’s the chicken and veggie gravy mix that just blew me away. The environment is fun and hip with options for all.
Blueberry pie was loved even the next day. Road trip anyone?!
Best chocolate silk pie EVER! Topped with homemade whipped cream, amazing. We sat outside in their outdoor dining space which was super nice.
Very yummy pie & a cute little building! Packed but I completely understand why! 🤣
My wife & I got a slice of the traditional apple & chocolate pies; great value per slice too!
We went for the cider bar which is located in the same spot. The chicken curry empanada was staring at us so we ordered some to go. It was so good that we came back the next day to order some more for lunch. We even picked up a blueberry pie for dessert. It was sooo good and so rich.
Update: We picked up the chicken curry empanada 3 days in a row since we discovered this place. Would have gone more had we discovered it earlier in our trip.
Delicious, homemade pies. We stopped by for a slice and were happy to see they have numerous gluten-free and vegan options, both for sweet and savory pies! We ordered a slice of apple pie with a crumble topping and it was truly the perfect apple pie - not too sweet with a delicious crust and topping. We ate our slice of pie with a few ciders from the next door Local Cider Bar - a match made in heaven!
We had this recommended to us by a local. They said it was new and worth a visit. The cider was great although a bit more than I was used to paying...overall, if I lived in the area, I would go back. Definitely worth a visit. We had fun! It’s a very hip place.
Awesome pie shop and brewery in the same building. Sweet and savory pie with wide selection. This place is absolutely a must try if you are in town
Okay it's been a week or two since I've been there and I'm still trying to figure out what they put in there pot pie that makes it so good. It was a great little place that had savory meat pies as well as dessert pies. We got the chocolate silk pie and the chicken pot pie.
Now that I'm back in Utah I'm really wishing I would have got some of that empanadas.
Their pie cookies were so good.
They have Pie! Lot’s of pie, need I say more. Popular place with limited seating. Be prepared to wait in line during the busy time. Here you Order from the counter, pickup food, then find a place to eat it. One of the few places you can have pie for both dinner and dessert! Friendly service, hot food.
Really good pie. Gluten free options are awesome. But one pie seemed like it lacked 1/2 it's filling (raspberry lemon), they sometimes don't update their door dash menu which ruins the order and once they forgot the sauces for the hand pies, which is super important! No one wants a dry hand pie. Good pie. Service is meh.
Such a wonderful spot to grab a small bite like their delicious hand pies, dessert pies. They have a great selection of drinks off the tap the local cider is always my favorite!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes