Review Jersey Mike's Subs - Bartonsville

I stopped in this afternoon for a sub. It was the most delicious sub I've had in months! The staff was friendly and bright! Well done! As always everyone mentions price which can always favor the customer better, but all in all, it was a great experience on a Tuesday afternoon.

Clean store, AWESOME employees. The giant sub can actually feed 2 people., best of all the veggies example... lettuce and tomatoes are never soggy! Check it out!

For a busy day the bartonsville location handled everything calmly and patiently. The sandwich was delicious they made everything without rushing. That location is super clean and tidy with a friendly staff and manager.

All their sandwiches are great. Always sliced fresh, not pre-packaged deli meats. Good portions, not stingy like other places. Their tuna is the best around anywhere. Awesome cheesesteaks too. Definitely join the Shore Points program.

The food was fresh and delicious. Our first time there and it won't be our last. Friendly outgoing staff and quick service. Thank you 😊

Hands down the best Jersey style sub around. FRESHLY cut cold cuts and freshly baked bread daily!

Clean, & looks organized & when my order was ready counter person came and delivered it to me. 🤓 Face masks, if not vaccinated & workers do wear masks. Food is good; they have delivery, dine in, you can order on the app and pick up at the curb. I would come here again.

Had a good sub with great service. Next time I'll order a sub and go the "Mike's" way.

Wonderful people work here. Pleasant. Subs made with Love

Great subs..better than subway

I love Jersey Mike's. As someone from New Jersey, I know a good sandwich. Every time I go to a Jersey Mike's, I am left happy full and pleased with the value. I've been to many Jersey Mike's, this one stands out. The sandwich was FRESH. STUFFED, and ready when it was supposed to be. The staff was friendly, and the sandwich hit the spot. I am so glad we stopped.

Sandwiches are good. The only thing is that they do not clean the knife after every sandwich. I can not eat mayo and it is on the knife. Also they are multi tasking and touching the food after. That is a no for me. I do ask them to wipe the knife and change out the gloves after they have done multiple things. It's a work in progress..

Owner is very nice and food is great.

Whether you call it a sub or by any other name, these are THE BEST subs anywhere! I should have gotten around to writing this review along time ago. The Bartonsville, Pennsylvania store delivers consistent quality, personable employees, an invariably clean restaurant, and let’s face it… this brand makes THE BEST sandwiches in THE WORLD! Shout outs to Lacey, John, and Shannon and the manager, Cindy, for another great lunch/dinner! This store and their team is the best I’ve ever visited. I also visit the Middletown, NJ store somewhat frequently and I have to give a shout out to Sue W. who is always on top of her game and runs a great shop. PS The # 13, The Original Italian, is “molto delizioso.” Trust me, I’m Italian!

Great sub and wrap. Both were carefully made and tasted delicious. Not like the other sub shop. They also were packed nicely and my driver juanita was very friendly and personable. A good experience all the way around, and will definitely order again.

Took our kids here to grab a bit. We all know kid's aren't too crazy about eating different things and to my surprise they enjoyed the sandwiches and chips. I ordered something out of my element as well and tasted rather good. This establishment has a great atmosphere for new customers.

I hadn't been here in about a year and my sandwich was awesome! The bread was so soft and tasty!! The staff is cheerful and helpful too. My favorite subs are from Wegmans, but Jersey Mike's is a close tie! The staff makes it a better experience at Jersey Mike's so...I guess they beat Wegmans!!!

I have been a loyal customer of Jersey Mike's since they opened, I have a rewards card I'm there a couple of times a month they know me by name some of them I don't know if I will be back for a while I'm very disappointed in what I just experienced I got a giant number 8 with extra meat and extra bacon and it cost me $20 I must say that is one of the most expensive sandwiches I've ever eaten in my life although their sandwiches are good I will not spend $20 on a sandwich ever again I couldn't believe how much it was for extra meat and extra bacon it was the most outrageous thing that's happened to me all week. This is the only bad experience I've ever had at Jersey Mikes all my other times I've been there have been good experiences but $20 for a sandwich I think is a bit ridiculous

My hubby and I ordered online so that we could just go in and pick it up. It wasn't ready when we got there, that was alright they were a bit busy. My issue is that both of our wraps were wrong that we ordered. My husbands wrap was supposed to be a whole wheat - it was not, it was plain. My wrap was supposed to have bacon on it (I paid extra for it) and there wasn't any on it. With the amount of money we paid for them and both being incorrect we will not be back again.

The people are friendly. The food is great. Sandwiches have just the right amount of cold cuts. Having it Mike's way is the best. I put mayo and hot peppers on mine. Yummy..

Very yummy! You can split a giant sub between 2-3 people easily. Having the sub "Mike's way" is out of this world. Lots of sub for a great price. Worth trying.

20 years in the Pocono's from jersey and spend every summer down the shore. This place gives me such great memories of my childhood. Sandwiches are like when I was a kid. Love it Mike's way!!

The food was great but even if it wasn't the level of costumer service would bring me back in the door. I give 100%.

I go here 2 to 3 times a month an have my rewards card which I like..I think this is the best place to get a sub..you chose what you want, an how much you want..not always clean inside an staff isn't always nice but, I love my #13....

First time I have been there, the food and service was great.

My best friend and I tried their subs on Sunday June 21, and we have finally found a GREAT place in the poconos for a terrific sub with great prices and awesome customer service!!! We will definitely be there often and tell everyone we know!!!!

I work in the shopping center and I eat there probably once every week or two if not more. The people who been there for awhile know me by name

It was a very tasty Chipotle cheese steak...no peppers. With bacon. And the roll was YUM! Def will go back to try something else.

Always delicious and made to order. Friendly service, too.

Great sandwiches! Mikes way or death by subways! Thanks Jersey Mike for coming out to the poconos!

It was ok, not bad... not great. The bread was nice and soft though.

I � Jersey Mike's!!! Every single time is perfection!!!

Everytime I've been they've greeted me right as I enter the establishment. Always friendly and efficient. I'm glad you built one here in the Poconos.

Overjoyed to have a little bit of home finally! AMAZING subs and great crew! Excellent food and service.

I'm from Point Pleasant and am so happy to finally have a Jersey Mikes near me! I grew up with it and missed it when I moved to the Poconos and my only option was a Subway.