Its no longer called Joe's but the food was pretty good and the portion was pretty good for the price
Worth the ride from Ronkonkoma. Best pizza. Love the crust.
Amazing! The food is great and the service outstanding!
Been getting pizza from here for as long as I can remember. The people running the restaurant are friendly and know how to have fun. Prices are good and pizza is fresh. I’ve only recently started trying their pasta but it’s also good, although their pizza is the best thing they make.
Prices are good too, considering how big the pizzas are.
They don’t deliver, but making an order and waiting the 30 minutes or so it takes to make it is ABSOLUTELY worth it.
Joe's Pasta & Pizza of Bay Shore (since 1973) is now
Marcony's Pizza & Pasta Ristorante. (This name is on the menus and website; the outdoor signs have two mistakes.) Same great place (a friend of the family bought it), same phone number, different name. (Nov. 2022.) ((Please add any new reviews to Marcony's. Joe's Pasta & Pizza of Bay Shore might soon be marked "closed".))
Bob Mantione (Schoolteacher Bob)
+5
First time my wife and I had dinner at this local, family friendly, restaurant. . Although we've had great take out pizza, before. We had a mixed plate of sausage, meatball, ravioli, and manicotti. The last time I had Italian was in Little Italy. Joe's is right up there. His restaurant could be in Little Italy too. I highly recommend this restaurant.
Place is awesome. Since new ownership not only has the food gotten better but the service has significantly improved. Super nice waitress and the mew dining room looks so much better. The pizza counter also has a lot more options which is really nice. Overall a really good place.
![5]( "Recensione")
This place is good... really good. I used to just come for the slices which were decent, mostly out of convenience but even those have gotten better lately. Since they renovated the dining room and added some nice wines to their drink menu, my wife and I have gone in for dinner a few times and have not been disappointed.
Friday nights have been crowded, so i suggest reservations, but the wait staff is really professional and courteous and the food is awesome as well. This has turned into an unexpected date night spot for my wife and I instead of some more expensive restaurants.
As far as this review from Tatum Petrush... I just don't get it. The food before the latest ownership change was lousy at best... the pizza was ok. They completely renovated... it's a cleaner, nicer place to be and truth be told... now it is evident the previous owner was on their way out long before they sold. Their meatballs used to be HORRIBLE...the sauce was so acidic. Just a sad attempt at filing orders for pasta dishes. This place was saved from being run into the ground. I think Tatum is sadly mistaken... this place went from barely OK, to really good. It's obvious these owners care about what people say about their food. BUT, Tatum was right about the name... I think they should change it... The name Joe's is synonymous with "ehhhk... This food is lousy." They need to name it something other than a cliche' 1975 pizza place.
This place never fails to deliver on good quality pizza. I've been coming here since I was 5 & now the pizza tastes better than ever. Try the Drunken Gma slice, pretty damn good!!!!!
I love Sicilian accents all day. Same ole Joe's pizza. Doesn't seem like anything has changed. Same pasta night. Great sauce. Great chicken roll... Broccoli roll... Zeppoles (if you're lucky)... Happy faces. Great community restaurant.
I came in here for the first time in over a year and was super impressed with the renovations they have made. The dining room actually looks like somewhere id want to eat dinner with family & friends or even a date night spot versus what it used to look like. Not to mention they deliver now too! So glad to see this place enter the 21st century and look forward to coming back again!
This was the nicest restaurant experience I’ve ever had. The food was amazing and the owners were some of the kindest people I’ve ever met! Definitely recommend to anyone!
I lived in NY years ago, i remember when this place had just 1 shop, and around 10 or so customers when me, mom, and dad walked in... in my opinion, it was part of my childhood. When I heard from mom this place was still going strong I started crying in childish joy. Again, in my opinion, This place is MUCH better then all the main chain pizza places (Pizza Hut, Dominos, Little Ceasars, Etc.) and I hope it stays put til I can go there myself and order some pizza, and dip it in that gravy thing full of sauce again.
Hope you guys keep going strong.
-Ray
Pizza is great and staff is even better. Went in here for the first time and the place was super clean and everyone was so friendly. I even shared a piece of pizza with one of the cooks ;) While waiting for my food the guys kept me laughing and smiling. This place has such a warm friendly family vibe id go back just for that alone, and it helps the food was great :)
They make a sweet sauce pie definitely worth trying there sausage and peppers slice is better then most others there chicken parm pie is definitely another must there very friendly service is pretty fast never had a problem also reasonably priced not cheap but not expensive and quality food
Lisbeth Ortega Sanchez
+4
Videos of clothes place so the convenience is normal and a great as well. Who there isn't that bad since like I only love my teeth pizza so it's perfect for me in the pies are very good as well so I love it there the service is medium for me since I don't really talk to the service people there that make the pizza but they are friendly they don't argue they're not really negative to their customers. so yeah I give it four out of five
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes