Sluurpy
Reset

There are 7 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Mexican cuisine: the best places to taste it in Bay Shore

There are 7 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Pecado Mexican
88/100 (1069 ratings)
Restaurants
Mexican
Mexican
Dinner
Lunch
Sit down
Mexican
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
Pico Tequila Grill
81/100 (950 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Mexican
Mexican
Southwestern
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Lunch
Salad
Tapas
Tacos
Burrito
Nachos
Pork
Shrimp
Sit down
Mexican
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Full Bar
Takeout
Television
Seating
Table Service
Lunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"Tried this place for the first time with my girlfriend and it was absolutely amazing. Our server was great, extremely attentive and friendly. We will..."
Kenny Miller
"I have never been disappointed with anything on the menu. The burritos are my favorite on the island, the margaritas are delicious!! I recommend the..."
Dana Marie
"Creative menu, great staff. You should try Pico. The owners are great, friendly people. Oh & if you like tequila this is the place to..."
Eddie Knox
"This was my first tex-mex restaurant experience, and I loved it! Due to their great staff, the atmosphere was very warm and welcoming. Their..."
Ayesha Rahman
"Good food reasonably priced. Great happy hour. Friendly bartender. Makes a great..."
Jim Brady
"Hermoso ambiente, la comida excelente, me encanto los tacos de pescado muy deliciosos , las bebidas exquisitas especialmente las margaritas..."
Fabiola Bermeo
"Fresh ingredients, fun menu, great tap beer and margarita's. I really like the vibe at Pico. Pico's fills a void in the Bay Shore restaurant scene...."
Kyle Mulhern
"Great place for a drink or quick eats. Service is friendly. And the burrito bowl is awesome. Cat where have yoy..."
Celeste Stella
"Great cozy space. We were looking for a few apps and drinks. Luckily, happy hour is until closing on Saturday nights. $2 tacos and $1 off tap beer..."
Leah Stamatiades
"The staff is genuinely friendly. The guacamole and the buffalo chicken burrito were..."
Stephen Bellone
"Went here for taco Tuesday deal and the tacos were legit crazy good. Might make it a tradition to just go there Tuesdays when I'm hungry with the..."
WKUK B
"Spring rolls in and all of a sudden the urge to go out and take a walk in Bay Shore is so appealing...especially when on the way to lunch! I..."
Glenn
"Pork steak fish and southern chicken tacos, didn't care for the pork steak was burnt but the fish and chicken tacos were really good. So not bad. On..."
Samantha Kronenbitter
"Real good place, happy hour specials we're a good deal..tacos we're tasty.. wife liked the drinks.. we had the pork nachos and they were excellent....."
Richard Ruggiero
"Tacos ala cart. I ordered 4 only made it through 3. Tuna, bang bang shrimp, and pork were all excellent. I took a bite from the ground beef to taste..."
Joey D
"The pico burrito and the bang bang tacos do not disappoint. I’ve come here several times and I always get the same ones because they’re just so..."
Daniela R
"Services was very good. I enjoyed the food as well..."
I is Gamerz
"My first time there and I will be back. Staff is so friendly. Food was great and drinks..."
Natalie Gordon-Lomax
"Everything was great! Fried ice cream is a..."
PHILLIP HARVEY
"So many gluten free options, friendly staff, and very delicious food make this a new favorite spot for the husband and I. Check out how they plated..."
Melissa Posada
Verde Kitchen & Cocktails
81/100 (2150 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Mexican
Spanish
Mexican
Latin
Latin
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Dinner
Lunch
Tapas
Tacos
Fish
Pork
Shrimp
Sit down
Mexican
Latin
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Full Bar
Takeout
Reservations
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"I enjoyed the lunch special of four tacos, plus soup, salad or a side. I had two barbacoa (brisket) tacos and two pulpo (grilled octopus) tacos, with..."
Rahadyan Timoteo Sastrowardoyo
"I love everything about this place, but especially the happy hour specials! The drinks are always incredible and the price is right! You can taste..."
Stacie Camirand
"WOW! Where do I start... I was Blown Away with the Fantastic service! I was setting up my bridal shower and the Tartaglia brothers couldn't have been..."
Nicole Marie
"Being a Bay Shore resident this is our all time favorite place to eat in town! We dine here at least once a month if not more. Food is amazing as..."
Mike Cardascia
"Every time I go to Verde's Kitchen & Cocktails I have a top of the line experience! The great service, great food, and awesome ambiance is unlike..."
Melissa Anne
"We had the original and pomegranate margaritas, they were amazing!!! The 3 salsas and chicken flautas, and the 4 taco lunch special. Ryan our server..."
Tammy Randazzo Sweeney
"The fish � so fresh, I've had fish tacos so many times before elsewhere, nothing compares to Verde… The ambience is quaint, the staff is..."
Laura Caputo
"Went for Cinco de Mayo (cliche, I know). Super glad we did. Food is phenomenal, cocktails are on point and the atmosphere is laid back. Try the..."
Peter Vaccaro Jr.
"Taco Tuesday is the best! Half price and $5 margaritas as well. They are fresh and delicious! Service is reliable and..."
Lou LaFleur
"I went to Verde with 4 friends for dinner, and we wanted to go for 1/2 half tacos on Tuesdays as well as happy hour! Normally you have to sit at a..."
Jane Gulla Angileri
"Delicious food and amazing margaritas. The staff is top..."
Debbie A Burack
"To start, the host was very accommodating, finding us a seat outside, the waitstaff happily guided us through Falls new menu options. The options..."
Heather Kristy
"Guacamole was amazing! Our waiter was great. Overall great experience. I had the steak and rice. The summer sangria was good too! Can't wait to go..."
Kim Kondak
"Went there for the first time yesterday for dinner and loved it! Friendly staff, excellent food and the margaritas were delicious. The atmosphere is..."
Debbie Genin Beberman
"Their happy hour is the best deal in town, by far. Great drinks, tacos, and quesadillas at great prices. Try the whole fish, I've had many whole fish..."
John Charvat
"Came here with my boyfriend for my birthday a few months ago and it was hands down the best experience ever. The server was amazing! The food and..."
Erika B
"We had the baby shower, The staff was great, and the waitresses were so inventive and caring to everyone. They took extra care to all my grandkids..."
Robert Schaefer
"The food is absolutely delicious.. but I have to rave about the staff! The entire staff was so helpful and pleasant all around. Justin took care of..."
Minela Mueller
"Had a beautiful date night here mid-October 2023. We ordered the Oaxacan Market for two (pictures), which was wonderful. Superb food, we couldn’t..."
Tim Walsh
"Had an amazing girls night, with the perfect ambience. Our server John was absolutely fabulous. We sampled a few different margaritas which were..."
Bonnie Neidecker
"I've been coming here for quite a few years and I must say that I have had nothing but the absolute best experience every single time!! Drinks and..."
Dr Wilfredo Morales
"I cannot stop talking about Verde. The drinks , appetizers , entrees and desserts are all heavenly. And they also have an excellent Happy Hour. The..."
Ariel Brunot
"Excellent customer service, every single employee was very attentive and courteous. I will have to highly recommend the Carne Asada. A marinated..."
jorge lam ki
"This restaurant has two areas, one bohemian type, the other patio type with gardens, the service is very friendly, the cooks are excellent… the..."
M&M
"Staff is very pleasant. . Restaurant Ambiance was perfect. Restroom not the cleanest. The Market on the menu => not worth the price. Charred..."
NG B.
"Went there for dinner we had shrimp tacos and brisket tacos, excellent. We also had the plantain and the rice and beans excellent. Angelica our..."
Joe Mosc
"Great atmosphere and good drinks. Food was very average but not bad. Not plain but could use more spices especially for Mexican food. FINAL VERDICT:..."
WKUK B
"My Taste Buds and I went to Verde a few weeks ago. We loved the atmosphere. We wanted a spot in the back, but it was being used. It was ok, though,..."
Taste Buds
"My go to spot. I get the Oaxaca steak with a side of chorizo. Absolute banger every single time. The subtle flavors in their rice and tortillas are..."
Alt
"I’ll start with the hostess, Taylor. She was absolutely the best! I mentioned to her that I had never been to the restaurant before and she decided..."
Melissa Lowe
"First time here, excellent service at the counter. Outdoor area looks nice. Brisket tacos were tender and juicy but sauce was loose and soaked the..."
Joey D
"Verde is consistently top notch! As a Realtor I often stop for food in the road during a long day of work, but often make it a point to come here...."
Dominique Dalia-Rudolph
Pollo Campero Restaurant
81/100 (2337 ratings)
Restaurants
Mexican
Mexican
Dinner
Lunch
Sit down
Mexican
Dinner
Lunch
"Always visit Pollo Campero when I travel to Brentwood!! Honestly love their food and the best fried chicken ever! Highly Recomend..."
Pirelys Cordero Sanchez
"I love this food, is the best!!! Very good, #CAMPERO..."
Juan Carlos Hdez
"Es muy lento y los empleados de verían estar mas limpió es un..."
Liliana Cruz
"Muy bueno el pollo, solo deben mejorar el servicio por que están muy..."
Armando Zamora
"The best Fried Chicken in good old USA is brought to you from Guatemala. If haven't had it and do like fried chicken, you too will be convert as I..."
Syed Doha
"Great place! Food is good, customer service is..."
David Nhan
"Ordered on Uber eats because it was 2 for 1 meals. The fried chicken was very good. The fries were pretty good. I was not a fan of the..."
Jay Abra
"Great atmosphere. Employees are extremely friendly and halófito when ordering. They constantly ask if you’re doing okay when you dine in. Food is..."
Melissa Moreira
"Literally the best fried chicken I have ever eaten in my life. Thighs and legs are plump, juicy, and exploding with flavor. Good choice of sides,..."
Nysports Mcp
"Very happy we finally tried Pollo Campero. My son wanted to try the new spicy chicken sandwich. He saw it mentioned on Twitter. My husband and I got..."
Andrea B
"Extremely friendly staff and halófito when ordering. They keep asking if you're okay with your meal. Food is always served quickly and is always..."
Hải Quốc
"Great chicken place. Been here a few times and I've only been upset by the fact that they got rid of the grilled chicken. Their fried chicken is..."
Nick Kovalevich
"Employees were great, very attentive to you needs and Excellence in their..."
Nancy Lopez
"Delicious 😋 campers salad but the dress..."
Rene Lopez
"Best fast food Chicken on the island..!! I've hit all the Pollo camperos on Long island, and they're all great. The Bayshore spot stands out though...."
John Carriglio
"Great taste,.. little..."
A
Tacos Guacamola
77/100 (246 ratings)
Restaurants
South American
Mexican
Central American
Spanish
Spanish
Mexican
Dinner
Lunch
Breakfast
Burrito
Sit down
Spanish
South American
Mexican
Central American
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"My faves are the chicken tacos and chili tacos and the chicken burrito. This place is decent. I like it a heck of a lot better than Taco Bell. The..."
Mom Of Two
"Best Burrito's. If you like Burrito's you have to try this place. Be sure to try the Shrimp and Pineapple burrito it is the best. If you are ordering..."
Mike C
"Authentic, and delicious!. Despite the name, the real attraction of this tiny little hole in the wall is the burritos. Don't let the humble..."
ClockworkSoul
Chili's Grill & Bar
74/100 (1521 ratings)
Restaurants
Pub
Mexican
Southwestern
Steakhouse
Bar
Pub
Steakhouse
American
Mexican
Southwestern
Bar
Dinner
Lunch
Sit down
American
Mexican
Southwestern
Bar
Pub
Steakhouse
Takeout
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Highchairs Available
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Matt was great friendly and good quick service. Food was excellent as well and even though there was a minor error with the order they fixed it with..."
Michael Reyes
"Unsurprisingly busy on Cinco de Mayo. To my amazement my companions and I only had to wait 20 minutes. I hear that the wait at the Farmingdale..."
Quentin Hodges
"Met a bunch of old friends here and it was a fantastic night. The young man who was our server was patient, knowledgeable and had a great sense of..."
Christine Littmann
"First time ordering Chili’s, (I know, hard to believe) we live a hot minute from the Bay Shore location & I always thought I couldn’t eat it..."
Kellyann Gillen
"The food was good. The burger was amazing. Felt bad for the waitress because Chili's was understaffed and she was running between at least 10 tables...."
Mark Kline
"Chili’s always has my favorite food and the margarita is the best out of all. The staff is super attentive specially Nicole, she is a 11 of 10 me..."
Warhead 809
"I had a nice lunch here with a friend of mine. The restaurant had just opened. We asked for a seat by the window. Our waitress was also the..."
Angelina Mascol
"our server trey was so understanding and friendly with my gluten allergy. He was very nice and attentive overall. A great..."
Julia Dunne
"It's a nice place to watch NY Jets football game. The food and drinks are good. Staff are friendly and..."
Robert Jones
"Nice place, fast service easy menu to choose from for kids and family. Great deals and good..."
Tyrus Curtis
"Every bite was wholesome and delicious..."
Miss Tina
Taco Bell
74/100 (1875 ratings)
Quick Bites
Fast food
Mexican
Mexican
Fast Food
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Brunch
Tapas
Tacos
Burrito
Sit down
Fast food
Mexican
Drive Thru
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Brunch
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"It's a newly remodeled place looks very nice. Placed our order on the touch computer was easy to use and paid for with debit card. The wait for the..."
Dennis Fairbrother
"Always one of my favorite fast food stops. Love the newly renovated location here. Did was as I..."
Jason McMahon
"Girl working the dining room was kind enough to bring me my wild strawberry freeze while I waited for my order- I do miss the vegan nacho cheese..."
David Catania
"If you want your food, use the drive through! Been waiting 20 minutes..."
Tony Correnti
"Make that fun for the border when you want a quick "Mexican" food..."
Joey M
"My favorite location. The staff is always super friendly and they never mess up my customized orders! They deserve recognition! Unfortunately the..."
Amanda A
"It doesn't make a difference how late you come to this Taco Bell and always taste like the food is fresh & hot. Never that sitting on the lights..."
Kurtiz
"It doesn't make a difference how late you come to this Taco Bell and always taste like the food is fresh & hot. Never that sitting on the lights..."
Kurtiz
"I can't explain it, but no Mexican restaurant compares to this fast food. I can become easily addicted to eating at Taco Bell if I let myself...."
Diane P
"After ordering inside I preceded to the soda machine to select my fountain soda of choice. Which happened to be flat. I asked a young lady by the..."
Travis Tee
"I love Tbell!! I really like that it is fairly inexpensive compared to other fast food chains. I like their food better too! It gets 5 stars for..."
Rivst Brelm
"If you're gonna go out, go out high af and trying to re enter taco bell in the middle of the line so you can do a second order and then when they say..."
Jenn Jennington
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use