Seafood cuisine: the best places to taste it in Bay Shore
13 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
"My first experience was absolutely outstanding. My boyfriend and I went for opening night to support the new fantastic owners Alex and Tracy. We..."
Samantha Steinhart
"Loved the FROZEN PALOMA and HANG 10 MARGARITA! Street Corn was also phenomenal, amazing guacamole, as well as all the food we had! Great vibe! ..."
Matthew “Matt from the North Fork” Chizever
"Very nice place! We didn't have reservations and were able to be seated on a Friday night. Food was delicious and our drinks too!! Clam chowder, tuna..."
Jessica PrestigeRecruits
"Beautiful new restaurant near the water, across from the marina and around the corner from Nicky's. Tacos were very good and the drinks were fresh..."
Mike “Bar.snobs” DeMarino
"This is our second time at Ditch! What a fantastic little spot. Dylan and Olivia at the bar made our time there exceptional! Drinks are great. The..."
Steve C
"We very much enjoyed the food - especially the share items. We had the Crab cake, Tuna tartare, Duck wings and Brussel sprouts and a kind of apple..."
Roman Laczkovich
"This was a fantastic eating experience! We had 10 people and the service was excellent. The food was so great and the portions were huge. And there..."
Chase Lewis
"The vibes here are on point. It’s unique and original. The margaritas are the best in Bayshore! You must try the yucca poppers and duck wings!..."
Gaetano Greco
"First time here and absolutely loved it. The design of the restaurant is so relaxing, servers are friendly and the food was phenomenal! Took my..."
Erika Vides
"We love Ditch Kitchen & Surf Bar! It was such a fun time with our friends and family. The food and drinks were delightful and we will definitely be..."
"Beautiful restaurant and great setting. We had a birthday dinner with 15 people, we sat in their private room. The staff was attentive,..."
Natalia Giancola
"Great location for on the water dinning. Visited on a Saturday for outdoor brunch. Table for two are closer to the water. Depending on the..."
Ashley Perez
"First time at the Lakehouse and not the last.
Had a great time. Excellent drinks, the most delicious New England Chowder, warm bread, excellent..."
Tom Olenick
"I was trying to find a nice seaside restaurant on Long Island and found Lakehouse on Google. The restaurant could use a little refurbishing but the..."
Eric Lee
"This place was extremely good. Service was fast and food was delicious. Desert came at same time as the ☕️. Everyone was super nice. the view is..."
sandra valdebenito
"The Lakehouse was really very nice. We went for the brunch menu and the atmosphere was great. Well except for a raucous group of women the next table..."
Gary Moore
"Great experience, even if you're looking to dock your boat and..."
Jessica PrestigeRecruits
"Great food, great service, beautiful setting and views. Love this..."
Alicia Escalante Polizotto
"The hostess was friendly and helpful, selecting a nice corner table for my first date. The wait staff were very patient and checked to ensure we did..."
Michael Tillman
"A great waterfront restaurant with delicious food and scrumptious desserts! We enjoyed the fried calamari appetizer followed by the almond crusted..."
Ron Santram
"Wow.. most water front restaurants are good views and bad food, this place is the exception! The food, ambiance, and service were all great. Will..."
Zab Ros
"Definitely one my favorite restaurant! Starting with the fresh and grilled oysters, definitely one of the best I’ve had. The duck breast and leg..."
Clarisse Laigo
"I absolutely loved the Long Island Duck and their version of Clam Chowder. As a Holbrook South shore native this place does the area justice. Can't..."
Todd Patrick
"Had my daughter's bridal shower at the Lakehouse. Everything was beautiful. Our guests raved about the food and the atmosphere. I had been there..."
grace accardi
"The best meal I’ve ever had from a restaurant! I’m so glad I came here to eat dinner on March 18 - to celebrate my dad’s birthday. The staff..."
Kimiko
"Can't say enough about the food & drink ! Everything was delicious, I've never ever had such huge colossal shrimp. Unfortunately we just laid our..."
Tom Eng
"What a perfect evening to dine on the water. We chose The Lakehouse. This is our first time here. We enjoyed a cocktail by the water while we waited...."
"PSA: Get here immediately! Fabulous food, delicious drinks, and an amazing atmosphere. More casual than their sister restaurant Verde, but food and..."
Remy Torsiello
"Great spot! Drinks are on point and the atmosphere is awesome! They have pool, dart and other bar games towards the back of the bar. Great laid back..."
Robert Anthony
"The concept is to feel like you are hanging in a laid back spot along the coast. It totally works. Nice seafood menu options. Tropical inspired..."
Stacy L Niessing
"Great new place! Went with 6 couples and played shuffle board and pool. The food was great. The appetizer menu could be expanded because you want..."
Claudia Trinceri Kavitt
"This place is absolutely gorgeous and the food was so damn good !!! The coastal burger was probably the best burger I’ve had in a long time !!! And..."
Kimberly Palanisamy
"This place is phenomenal! Exactly what Bayshore needed. Exquisite food, outstanding atmosphere and superb bartenders! All with an island vibe...."
Jay FitzPatrick
"The cocktail list rocks!! Try the Oaxacan Zombie Swizzle - off the hook!! The food is so flavorful, a fav is the miso & black garlic..."
Tara Fedozzi
"The best cocktails in Long Island! Staff is superb! Super friendly and so accomodating! Overall a great atmosphere and great..."
Marissa Tartaglia
"Bayshore is lucky to have a gem like this! Just got back from one of my most favorite Beaches, St.Augustine in Florida and I swear I was back there..."
Chanda Misevis
"Great service. The decor is so cool. It is a must go to. Had the chicken jerky sandwich -..."
Marie Dlouhy Allmendinger
"Very cool place, need to try the rum punch they sneak up on..."
Brian Zweifler
"Best staff, best drinks! Excellent..."
Abby Marinescu
"Love this place! Great drinks, delicious food and awesome..."
Nancy Ann
"I would like to thank Joe for accommodating my Birthday party of 15 in such short notice. I was able to bring balloons and decor for the table..."
Tania Reyes
"There are 2 Coastal experiences. 1 is the inside dining where the music is loud and crowded and young people having fun. Then there's 2 where you..."
Executive Group Realty
"Daiquiri is my new favorite. I'm glad it was suggested by the waitress. One drink, and I felt the rum 😄. Also happy I chose fried for my chicken..."
Vashti Persad
"Jerk chicken bowl and lobster quesadillas (not pictured) were bangin. Frozen drinks were just OK, have had..."
Robert Torossian
"Have the Classic Marg and the Jerk chicken quesadilla with street corn. Chef's kiss. Tell 'em Barsnobs sent..."
Mike “Bar.snobs” DeMarino
"A wonderful use of space, bare walls and ceilings really opens the place up. Dart boards, a pool table and shuffleboard makes it a fun spot for a..."
kebby koppe
"Food was good.
Service a little slow
A little to loud for dinner..
Should keep music a little lower during dinner hours then blast it after 10:30 or..."
Chris Leon
"Bloody Mary’s with Tito’s tasted delicious. Plates are clean and food smells amazing! I definitely recommend this place! Waiters were all super..."
Antonio Clavijo
"First time here tonight and had a great time. Place is decorated well and the ambience is perfect for a weekend evening out with friends. There are..."
Lord Admiral Lee
"Hands down best service, drinks, and food. This place is absolutely phenomenal. The bar tender, Joe was fantastic, seriously one of the best..."
A A
"Bustling lively spot on MainSt with Thai infused cuisine at rusticly industrial spacious restaurant perfect for lunch, meeting up for drinks at the..."
"Bought fresh local fish ($18- 25/ lb), oysters to cook at home and recently enjoyed fried clams w French fries ($15), which u can eat there. Service..."
Dina Miller
"I love Dean’s! The seafood is always fresh and someone always gives great recommendations. The reno is awesome and even has a patio with outdoor..."
Kimberly Roof
"Excellent service and fresh fish and shellfish..."
Mark Leonhardt
"A must go to for all seafood lovers!! The seafood is so fresh as always!! Take out or dine in menu!! I had the Fish and chips!! Delicious and the..."
Sonia Panzica
"We enjoyed our dinner tonight so much I had the flounder sandwich and it was cooked perfectly and so tasty, seasoned to perfection. The fries were..."
Donna Biba-Trott
"After reading about their remodeling in The List, we just had to go and give it a try. Ordered the Poke Bowl and Fish Tacos. Both were delicious! The..."
Lish Altieri
"This was the first time we had the food from Dean's and will not be the last. The food was outstanding and when I picked the food up there was a..."
Tom Papszycki
"From the Ocean to your table Deans Seafood sets the bar for both there quality of fish and professionalism and courtesy they show there customers. ..."
Dominick Divisconti
"Dean’s is terrific. Fish is fresh and store is..."
Babs Schaefer
"Absolutely love the seafood here! Everyone I’ve dealt with is super nice and knows what they are talking about. I am obsessed with the crab cake..."
"I love everything about this place!! The drinks and food are amazing. The service is the best service I’ve had in awhile. My favorite spot right..."
Danielle Kristen
"My wife picked this awesome restaurant for my birthday dinner! Was totally surprised! The oysters were really fresh and delicious, our drinks were..."
Eric J Auer
"Wonderful, attentive service, I believe Paul was our server, but the entire dining room responded to any request we had.
We all loved our meals, and..."
Karla Michelle
"We love this place !! It’s the best !!The oysters are always fantastic . Great wine � Beautiful atmosphere and great great music..."
Elyse Herr Halpern
"Food and service were perfect. I would recommend the lobster pot.the bay scallops were..."
Richard Schoppmann
"High end excellent trendy seafood and pub fare. Wonderful hidden..."
Paul DeStefano
"Excellent oysters - everything fresh . Ordered lobster special with coconut rice absolutely delicious. Best time to go for oysters is at Happy hour..."
Cherise Castagna-Gilberto
"Vincent was the best server! Thank you Sir for your hospitality� food was..."
Darla Álvarez
"This is my TOP place to get oysters. They are fresh, delicious & they know how to properly clean them. The drinks are always great. We love to sit at..."
Gina Pannone
"Oysters are on point with a very good selection. Didn't have the wine we ordered/wanted, prices are quite steep for what you..."
JV Young
"Awesome spot for Happy Hour. Eric is the best bartender on Long Island! Great service, food, and atmosphere. Stop in for Happy Hour and you’ll..."
Christian Miller
"We had a family of 6 at our table. The flavor, temperature and quality of all of the entrees was top notch. Although for the price of each did not..."
Dave Havenick
"Salt & Barrel exceeded our expectations for our wedding rehearsal dinner. Their team was incredibly accommodating, working with us to create a custom..."
Lauren Kulbit
"some of the best oysters I’ve ever had, especially the specialty cooked ones. incredible cocktails. Even more amazing service & staff.
great spot..."
Piyush Banker
"Quality beyond words. Highly recommend. Food was great, but the attention to detail in service was exceptional. Thanks mike our waiter made the..."
dirty jedi
"We sat at the bar and out bartender was amazing and he had a great personality. The food was delicious and the drinks were tasty. The happy hour was..."
Fabielle Daniel
"Went here for happy hour with a large group. Lots of great happy hour specials on oysters and cocktails. Highly recommend! There were several..."
John DiModica
"Food is great. Service is great. The wait staff is younger than your average staff but its cute to see them at work and they work well! Very kind,..."
"First off, the decor inside of this restaurant is absolutely stunning. Add that along with a great view of the bay and it's just simply amazing. Now..."
Frank Wu
"Great place food was amazing and the service was on point highly recommend this..."
Angelo J. Raucci
"Great time at Whalers. The band, Souls on Board, were Awesome as usual. The venue is great, with room to dance or just watch the band. The crowd and..."
John Lennon
"I have been there several times. The menu is great and the nautical atmosphere makes me look forward to summer!! Can’t wait for the outdoor patio..."
Suzie Q Oconnor
"The service was great and the food was delicious!! The view wasn’t bad either! I highly recommend!!!..."
Terry Wiegand Virga
"Was great , service and food was fantastic . Sea scallops were awesome . Highly..."
Robert Tamburello
"We had our engagement party at Whalers last Saturday and it was absolutely amazing! Nikki was so awesome to work with and helped us plan an amazing..."
Shauna DeFeo
"Great place and food smelled awesome... hoping band this past Saturday will be rescheduling... as I will be back for that and dinner next..."
Rich Ryan
"The food is delicious! We ordered the “Surf and Turf”, the coconut crusted cod and finally as a dessert, the bread pudding. The plates are well..."
Michele
"Came here for our 6 year anniversary for the first time. We did not make a reservation and wanted to sit outdoors. The hostess expressed they were..."
Vanessa Gonzalez
"Food is good as the view! From the appetizers to desserts, everything was wonderful. So many options on their menu & the lunch menu has a delicious..."
staci manning
"Where do I start… we planned a rehearsal dinner for my son and future daughter in law . Kelly made everything so easy . We had a fixed menu dinner..."
AnnMarie L
"Everything was excellent! We had a beautiful table overlooking the Great South Bay, we always make sure we get a seat upstairs when available. All..."
James Wood
"A good restaurant near the sea with a marvelous view and a pleasant atmosphere, and very tasty food, although a bit expensive..."
Meidos De Jesús
"Went there to check out the catering hall as a possibility for our wedding. The space upstairs is beautiful. We decided to eat at the restaurant to..."
Chris Almeida
"The place is definitely inviting and has a wonderful atmosphere. Cocktails were great, food even better.
Jenifer the manager/owner came to our table..."
Tai Vicari
"We had a fantastic experience at Whalers. Everything we ordered was delicious and the staff was super friendly! I had the burrata salad and the tuna..."
Bridget Coolick
"If your in Bay Shore & looking to have dinner by the water. Stop in at Whalers. No better duo then Gianna greeting you with smiles at the door and..."
Alexander Rivera
"I've dined here many times, I often order the same entrée and it has never disappointed. We started with the baked clams 5/5, and the seafood..."
Cindy Romero
"Beautiful atmosphere inside and out with great views and amazing food. The potstickers and lobster roll are my favorites. Great drink menu too but..."
J Shea
"Gorgeous views and exceptional service from Joseph. The food was delicious and the drinks were out outstanding!! And also the complimentary valet..."
Brett “El Guerrero” Harte
"The best experience in Bay Shore. We always come to this restaurant for our anniversary and the food is always delicious, the staff is always nice..."
Jefferson Bien-Aime
"This was our first time out since COVID started and I have to admit their Korean Lettuce Wraps with Beef Bulgogi was to die for! My wife thoroughly..."
Trav Ramkissoon
"Came here last summer. This place is packed,but we made reservations ahead. Though we had to wait, we didn’t wait long enough. Plus they have a bar..."
Tiny
"Started with a Coconut Margarita 🍹 & dozen oysters. Main was Shrimp Pappardred Great Food, Great Place and Great..."
Laura Kenny
"We ended up here due to a terrible experience at The Lake House next door and what a blessing that was. Alissa the hostess was amazing as due to..."
"Nicky’s Clam Bar really blew away my expectations! The mussels (garlic & white wine + porky version) were divine. The Surf & Turf burger was..."
Paul R
"Super fresh seafood no matter what you order.
Great little getaway spot for a bite and wine.
Available both indoor and outdoor..."
Jesse Yuan
"After returning from Fire Island, it was lunch time and we were all pretty hungry so we decided to have lunch at Nicky's Clam Bar, which is..."
Samantha Lee
"I had the absolute best experience at Nicky’s Clam bar. The manager Chrissy was so welcoming and informative on the menu. This establishment is..."
Emily Beier
"The greatest steamers you’ll ever eat . Always on point. Great service. Classic old world ferry station bar/ restaurant. I drive an hour . Worth..."
Lloyd Malsin
"Would go again - I ordered the seafood bisque soup and lobster roll, which comes with fries. The soup has tons of seafood in it. The visual is quite..."
Ryan Lee
"The food was SPECTACULAR! I started with the Clam Bisque, which was New England Clam Chowder. It was creamy, very well seasoned. Next, I had Clams..."
Alan Goodman
"Highly highly recommend Nicky’s clam bar! The food here is to die for! Food always comes out hot and cooked wonderfully!!! The staff is really..."
Stephanie C.
"Seafood Cobb Salad! Chefs 💋 No matter what you order, you can't go wrong with the best seafood in town. And don't sleep on the fresh homade..."
Maria Johnson
"I ordered the top next baked clams which normally I only get from Lenny's Clam bar, and I must say they're just as good. I normally cannot find clams..."
Helen Proffes
"Decent place, decent place was meant as a compliment apologies if taken in wrong context and thank you for responding back, definitely a staple in..."
Felix Garcia
"Still the best if not better! LOVE the expanded menu. Celebrating my 60th birthday on Mother's Day, this dockside tiny gem was hopping! Thank you,..."
Laura E Eydeler
"Delicious food! Great service too!
They have options for non-seafood eaters too. Eat local. Shop..."
"Wanted to try something new and came upon this adorable place. DEE was our server and truly made the whole experience She was so sweet and truly..."
Rita Orlando Goodman
"Loved the food ! The prime rib was to die for! Cooked to order and the potatoes and spinach were great! The service was very professional and kept us..."
Patricia Holzmann McMillen
"We had a delicious meal with my husband and friends. Wait staff was very attentive, live music was wonderful! Just a fabulous..."
Christine Maben
"Great food and people in an unpretentious environment. Reasonable prices. Like chilling on the back patio in the summer. Been coming here for..."
Mike Ferrari
"This is such a classy place...the food,people,location and service is everything you would expect from a five star..."
Matt Slater
"Food is great, service fantastic and you’re not rushed through your..."
Alice Wylibaum
"My friends & I love this restaurant! Food is delicious! Waitresses are welcoming & attentive! Atmosphere is charming. Prices are very reasonable!!..."
Kathy Korba McCormick
"Great atmoshere. Love the menu. Looking foward to going back to try more dishes. Had thai chicken kale sliders. Great taste, Drinks were great, reaso..."
Karin Loomis Bongiorno
"Great place. Great service. Great food. Great live �. Opposite of the marina. Oh and great nautical..."
Lynn Ingenito
"The boys from Verde, Costa Grill and the new BWI do it again with this latest addition to Bay Shore’s ever growing array of restaurant choices...."
Marc Johnson
"Decided to try LaLa’s Lounge in Bay Shore with my fiancé and what a great place! Immediately greeted by one of the owners with a big smile and a..."
Jade_Star
"It is no longer Lala's lounge when we went recently, but I have been to both. The current restaurant had a small menu, and we ordered an appetizer,..."
Clare Sullivan
"My wife and I went there for lunch and had a great meal, the guacamole is very good, my wife Taco's and my Lala Smash Burger w/special French fries..."
Chuck Martin
"Great Restaurant and Bar. Food was delicious. Friendly attentive service. Good value. Great Happy hour..."
J V
"We have loved this property for many years
The owner has a great menu, super servers
Taylor and Cheyenne..only negative was the hip hop music that..."
Bob Coletti
"New restaurant by an established restaurateur family.
Food is incredible! Fresh with some nice twists on classic dishes.
Recommend the guac and..."
Kristina Markovitch
"Casual and delicious! Fair pricing, friendly service and a warm place on a rainy night for a family dinner at the holidays! The largest pork chop..."
Glenn
"Was looking for somewhere to grab a drink and a quick bite this place was great. The drinks were on point, I actually ended up staying way longer..."
Brian Batista
"I've been here when it was Swept Away and let me tell you, they've done a great job revamping the place. The vibe is great and so are the food and..."
"Incredible food and service! Met one of the owners, Lynda, who was super kind and personable!! The Long Island clam chowder is THE BEST CHOWDER I've..."
Grace M
"Nice little place that was built in 1947. It has that kind of charming vibe. The Long Island chowder is a mix of new England and Manhattan styles..."
Martin G Miller
"Small eatery not far from Robert Moses state park beach
Great selection of seafood soups, clams and oysters. Draft beer.
We really..."
Angela D
"Great seafood. It is the perfect place to go to after the..."
Jeffrey Peltz
"The management is superb. As you step inside, you feel the history and smell the delicious food being prepared. The service is A+. The management is..."
Dan Dee
"Always a 5-star experience.
We love the New England soup! There's also the Cajun fries, calamari, clams casino, shrimp scampi, so much!! Ellen is one..."
Ruth Espada, LMT
"There's a reason this place has been here for so many years!! Great staff! AMAZING FOOD! Best Chowders I've ever had!!! Try the Long Island..."
Tina Arcuri
"Tasty food in a cool spot right by the water. Their clam chowder was EXCELLENT - the name suits them well!
Kid-friendly, and our kids enjoyed all..."
Tim Walsh
"A true Gem in Bay Shore...among all the ferry boats sits this cute chowder house.
Everything including the free parking is GREAT. Hot portions of..."
Bob Coletti
"I've lived on Long Island for all 33 years of my life so far and had never been to the Chowder Bar, which was a huge oversight on my part. The decor..."
Jacqueline Besanceney
"The Chowder bar is one of my favorite places to go. The food is always good. The spinach salad with warm dressing is delicious. And my favorite go to..."
Debbie Bailey
"LOVEEEE THIS PLACE!! Ambience is low key and casual! Food is delish!! ~~ loveee their soups! ~ LOVEEEE coming here for seafood and service staff are..."
Connie Henriquez Kimmel
"Before our ferry to Fire Island, a relative recommended that we grab lunch at Chowder Bar, a fanciful and nautical restaurant that serves appetizers,..."
Samantha Lee
"This is a family style seafood place. Wait staff very friendly, they always have toasted logger on tap, and the food is always good. Prices..."
Art “A2Jr” Angst
"We just ate here this past Sunday evening. If you love Braun's out east on the North Fork, you'll enjoy stepping back in time here!Our table is..."
Jean Lederer
"Nice! Cozy!
Fresh Oysters and Steamers are recommended.
Fishwich is really yummy.
Lobster Roll is nice.
Stuffed shrimp is super delicious.
Try..."
tammy uthairungsri
"My go to meal is a cup of seafood bisque and a grilled cheese with fries. Great prices and very small town feel. The ascetic is old salty saloon...."
Chris Balcerak
"This place is awesome! Very quaint and cozy little place with friendly service and delicious food. The fish sandwich was definitely the best I've..."
jim2boston
"Had lunch as a large group (11 people) here, the employees were very nice and helpful. The soups were good, broiled seafood platter was just alright...."
"The best!!!! If you want great food and friendly service. Not just a deli. It's a restaurant too. Sat at the bar for lunch the other day and the..."
Eric McKee
"The Best!!!. This Restaurant is a great find!!!!Authentic Latin food at its best..The prices are way too cheap for the AMazing food .But Ill take..."
Stacey
"I love Pine Air Fish market and have been coming here for over twenty years now for the absolutely best Ceviche I've had anywhere. I have had quite a..."
Garrett Nuttall
"Music was so loud inside and outside. We are Fried Fish but it came so hard over fired and was salty too. Service was very good and waiters she was..."
M A
"The best lobster and lobster sauce I've ever tasted. I drive all the way from Jamaica, Queens to Brentwood, Long Island, Exit 53 on the Long Island..."
Dickens Malave
"Wow wow wow! Our good friend brought us here and said it would be a dining "experience". I had no clue what we were in for. We ordered a massive..."
Amanda “Callahan_K9” Callahan
"Hands down the best Ceviche (MIXED) in Long Island. Soups are delicious as well, my favorite is the captains which is a seafood soup. They also have..."
Albert Kim
"Food and service were..."
Isela Herrera
"Food was delicious and everything was fresh. However we had a rude waitress. Will definitely come back for the good..."
Mayra Portillo
"Came here with my family and the food was incredible. Fresh delicious seafood, the Ceviche was amazing. Service..."
Irina Kondrashova
"Great seafood restaurant waitters special Ariana are very attentive and professional place is always clean Follow Covid19 regulations food delicious..."
agustin alvarez
"Great place for fresh and tasty sea food clean restaurant waitters very knowledgeable and professional
Come and see for..."
agustin alvarez
"Is an exelent place to went with the family delicious food exelent service I wish I can give more stars but I only aloud to..."
Wally Siliezar
"Best seafood ever amazing service will definitely recommend everything on the menu I try a few dishes and was very..."
thelma sandoval
"I haven't been here in years. They have updated and expanded. They have a lovely outdoor..."
Flutterflies Empowerment TV
"Great service and good..."
Erick Salgado
"You can get the biggest pupusas here! And they are so good! Mondays thru Thursdays there is a special for 10 (giant!) pupusas for $15. Always fresh,..."
"Views and good food. This place has a great location and it really nice to take visitors to. We enjoyed several fish dishes here and will definitely..."
Loving Long Island
"Wonderful. Captain Bill's is a gorgeous restaurant with handsome decor and a wonderful view of the waterfront. Their seafood is excellent, their..."
CharlesM
"Very up class yet down to earth place food was very..."
JimEJames
"The appetizers tasted great. The spinach dip almost had a buttery consistency which went well with the..."
Long Island Restaurant Review
"Visited a Sunday afternoon and restaurant was not too busy. Restaurant is by the water and would be great to sit outside on a summer day however its..."
Kay S
"Captain Bills made our dream night come true. We had our wedding reception at the Bayview House on 8/18/2023. The venue is beautiful and is located..."
JD Sheets
"Love crab cake here,big chunk of the crab meat, oyster rocketfeller, I think too much cheese thrn I didn't taste the oyster....
Ordered Magarita ,..."
fone Anan
"Overlooking the water, it is a beautiful restaurant and has many great seafood dishes. This is where we were supposed to have our wedding reception,..."
Frank Lynch
"My wife and I had lunch at Captain Bill's- we used to visit here when we were dating, but hadn't been here in probably 30 years. We've been trying to..."
Terry Parrett
"Nice resturant, calamari was very good. The clam chowder also great. Nice views of the marina. Blacked grouper was great too. Didn't have anything..."
Vibes & Good Times
"We got married at the Bayview House on 10/8/23, and it was an absolutely beautiful event! Annie, our Maitre'D, made sure that the entire evening ran..."
Nicole Perlman
"Wow just wow.
From the view, to the staff, to the delicious sea food dishes, to the drinks (that made me do a double take look into my glass from the..."
Russell
"A favorite dining experience for me! The food is AMAZING! Nice size portions. The special for Octoberfest was $37-$38 pp You received soup or salad,..."
A Gordon
"Outstanding drinks, food and service! Loved the Espresso Martini, Oysters, Stuffed Salmon, Lobster Bisque and Linguini with Shrimp &..."
"Excellent place, great menu...so different and fresh and plentiful..my family and are making this our get together spot.
Great service, cocktails not..."
Michelle Labriola-Parolari
"Was there for the first night of the 2017 season. The weather was awful, but the food delicious . I especially enjoyed the steak skewers and the..."
Kathy Lynch
"Amazing food, friendly and helpful staff, gorgeous view and a casually elegant vibe. For a special occasion or just to celebrate a relaxing summer..."
B.A. Fagerland
"Beautiful location, good band with excellent food and service. Will go back and highly..."
Val VG
"The atmosphere of being on the water is fun!! The food was great and the service even better! My daughter didn't like her dinner so they immediately..."
Maria Ribaudo Caturano
"Went for lunch with my mom. Had great wine (recommended by our waitress), great view, relaxed atmosphere. We loved..."
Linda M. Papagna-Ackley
"Nice little waterfront restaurant.
Food was so good , I was not a fan of the style of the salmon but the texture was top quality.
The dessert was..."
Thomas
"I meet friends here every summer and we're never disappointed. Every dish and drink is beautifully presented and delicious- good portion sizes,..."
Kirsten Ostrofsky
"My fifth or six visit here and never disappointed. Service is always great as well as the bay views. Wines by the glass offer excellent choices. ..."
J RL
"My husband and I went with another couple and had a bunch of delicious appetizers! We had not been here in years and I am not sure why because the..."
Dana Varricchio - Long Island, NY
"Restaurant has a lot of potential. Great location and atmosphere. Food is average, but reasonable..."
Kyle Schlesinger
"Beautiful spot on the water with a lovely team that runs the show. We came on a Sunday and sat on the covered patio.
The food was tasty, but the fish..."
Maria
"This is a lovely setting with great views of the bay and the passing boats. The food was delicious 😋 and the service was fantastic. Our server,..."
Dave Leach
"This place is really not for everyone, considering how expensive it was. Food was good, the service was super attentive and quick, and you can’t..."
William Hum
"The food portion was not much generous for the price and it didn't impressively taste good for..."
RL LEE
"What a fabulous night with the family. Beautiful setting. Dinner was pricey but worth it. I had the swordfish. Also had a beet and goat cheese salad,..."
"Had a great day here ! Southbound played here upstairs on the roof ! What a beautiful view ! The crowd there was awesome both line Dancers & people..."
Elizabeth Byrne
"Breathtaking view, great music and great food. Loved it and can't wait to go back. I wish there was a more extensive menu for rooftop..."
John Lennon
"If your going here for a gourmet meal, turn around, if your gonna bitch about the prices, stay home. This is where you go to enjoy the best thing..."
Charles D'Angelo
"First, the view and atmosphere are perfect. The server I had was excellent and the shrimp scampi was as good as I've ever had. I will definitely come..."
Mark Mariano
"Great place and the food was delicious! Our waiter was outstanding and so friendly! I believe his name wad CJ-sorry if I got the name wrong. We were..."
Rosemarie Mccarthy
"We love Nicky's on the Bay! Great atmosphere, good food and the owner Nicky always makes time to say hello & introduce himself to any new people we..."
Dana Persico
"Excellent food and view! Good variety on the menu. Friendly..."
Felicia Rybak Adorno
"This was my first time here and everything about this place was amazing!
We sat outside and watched all the ferries go by while sipping a delicious..."
Michele Stokes
"The food is still amazing and spectacular service and a nice view of the ferries and boats! This time around I was able to have a perfect view of..."
Shenera Boodie
"omg ！this is best seafood restaurant I ever been to!oyster is so fresh! Personally I hate oysters! But I had half dozen! That’s how fresh..."
wayne weng
"This new food they have is light years ahead of the old menu. We had the burger, lobster roll, chop chop salad, and salmon with a few apps. Thanks to..."
kenny powers
"Nice place on the water to watch the boats come and go. Baked clams and calamari were very good. I had fish and chips, which were good. My husband..."
Deborah Carleton-Tierney
"First I would like to give a shout out to Sherry our waitress for the outstanding service and the small talk we shared. Everything was beyond..."
Brett “El Guerrero” Harte
"Fantastic food. From the first to the last bite it was absolutely delicious. I had the special which was the salmon w summer pasta. I loved it. The..."
Jessica Seegolam
"We loved it. The fried clams are their specialty and the portion was huge. Great prices too. Everything was covid safe and the service was on point...."
Annie Pisapia
"Nestled beautifully along the water's edge, Nicky's On the Bay is a beacon for those seeking an exceptional dining experience combined with..."
Const Const
"Definitely coming back to Nicky's for Fried Calamari (tasted fresh and was crispy), Steamed Mussels (delicious!), and crab cakes! I ordered the..."
J K
"Very nice place next to the water.I had to wait a bit on the waiting list.But the wait was worth it.The food was very tasty.A bit pricey though.But..."
Tatiana Panova
"Very romantic, food was extremely fresh, homemade dipping sauces extremely fresh great quality, professional and persistent staff. Beautiful scenery,..."
Davina Wynn
"Great location on the water, food was delicious and service was very attentive. They had long island Vinyard wine, which was a nice surprise. Perfect..."
Matt Beriloff
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes