Food was delicious, prices were awesome, and Nick, the owner, was so friendly and polite. We really enjoyed our experience here and would definitely return! The Chicken Parmesan Pizza was incredible and we simply could not get enough of the Garlic Knots - 10/10
Absolutely love the pizza! We absolutely love Nick! A little bit overpriced, some of the help can be less than friendly and service oriented but I know he has trouble keeping good people. Definitely could use a little ambience upgrade. Even a few hundred dollars we could make some nice changes in there. Very very Bland tables and nothing exciting to look at when there isn't great art on the walls. Hope you'll do something special with that second room. I definitely wish I could help make it a more inviting place!
Wonderful little Family Italian restaurant in the quiet little town of Bellport. Ate in back dining room...very comfortable and airy. Our server was Sweet and took great care of us. Dinner choices were vast
I got Cappelli with white clam sauce which was excellent. BJ got her Chicken Parm..large order and tasted great. Mussels Posillipo was nice
..lotsa plump Mussels in tasty garlic tomato sauce and for dessertwe got the Bomba, big ball of vanilla/Chocolate icecream covered with delish frozen milk chocolate. Didn't try Pizza but we will return soon and try some more dishes!
Had a large catering order and Nick the owner was fantastic. Everything was on time and delicious. No one could stop talkin about the food all night!
It's a quaint little pizza shop in the heart of bellport.
Nick and his crew supply great service and very tasty dishes. Homemade mozzarella and pasta from scratch.. all fresh ingredients..need I say more
Patriot The Penguin (Bottlesgonewild)
+5
They also have the best lemon pancakes around!
Amazing local pizza place. Nick, the owner, is so friendly, and my kids love him. The pizza...amazing.
Nick is the best person in the world he is generous and he was funny. The service is great the food is delicious but you get full easily
The buffalo chicken pizza is hands down the best pizza I've ever had. That's not too say anything they make isn't good, I seriously don't think you can choose anything bad on their menu. Even the plain cheese pizza is phenomenal! We'll be ordering from here from now on 😊
Awesome food from pizza to delicious Italian entrees. They have tables to eat indoors as well. Also, for nicer weather there's a back outdoor patio with string lights which is so cute.
The owner is the nicest man - my son has an egg allergy so said if he wants egg free pasta made for him, just call ahead. We love going there for the friendly atmosphere and amazing food. Highly recommend!
This place is awesome! The pizza is delicious and the owner Nick and all of his staff are really friendly and make this restaurant feel very inviting. The prices are good and there's three dining areas, one is outside where I'm told they have music in the summer. Try the Lasagna pizza with pepperoni(my personal fave)you won't be disappointed!
Authentic Italian made with love , Nick the owner makes you feel right at home and has a real passion for his craft that you taste in every bite. Whether you just want a quick slice or a meal that makes me feel like your sitting in Naples, this is a place to stop and enjoy
Best Pizza in the village and best staff ever!
Excellent value and quality. Nicola, the owner, has 20 years of experience as a chef in Milan, and it shows.
Besides the great food, you can also buy authentic high quality ingredients directly imported from Italy.
A true gem that is worth the drive from towns in the general area.
Cafe Castello is a wonderful asset to Bellport village and the community. Nick is a gracious host and the staff is very helpful. We always look forward to their baked clams, cold antipasto and wonderful pizza. their pastas are also great. This is not a big commercial operation but an intimate family endeavor. Everything is made carefully by hand so use a bit of patience and you will be richly rewarded!
Just downright good pizza
Food is always delicious, and the owner treats you like family. Our go to spot for Italian food.
Stopped in for breakfast while my car was being serviced across the street at MVP. The lady working this morning was very pleasant and service was delightful. I opted for the healthy breakfast sandwich which was served promptly and was delicious. The sandwich comes with a cup of coffee and was very reasonable priced. I'll definitely be back!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes