Sluurpy
Reset

There are 3 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Ice Cream in Bexley

There are 3 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Johnson's Real Ice Cream
95/100 (832 ratings)
Dessert
American
American
Lunch
Root Beer Float
Gelato
Iced Sugar Cookies
Butter Pecan Ice Cream
Banana Split Brownie Sundae
Raspberry Cheesecake Milkshake
Buckeye Sundae Ice Cream
Banana Fudge and Blueberry Pie in a Cup
Clown Cones
Vanilla Ice Cream and Apple Pie
Pumpkin
Black Raspberry Chip Milkshake
Strawberry Ice Cream
Coconut Almond Chocolate Chip
Sundaes
Strawberry Cheesecake
Strawberry Shortcake
Ice Cream
Bubble Gum Ice Cream
Frappuccino
Chocolate Shake
Café
American
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"They have the best ice cream in Columbus I wouldn't go anywhere else for ice cream but Johnson's ice cream in..."
Dan Orozco
"I love this place! Amazing ice cream, and it beats Graters by a land slide! I can't wait for the Key Lime Pie flavor to come back out..."
Ashley Winter
"We just had our first visit to Johnson’s at the New Albany location. The staff was so friendly and the ice cream was delicious! We will be..."
Jennifer Dusenberry
"Matt and Lisa are the best! The Ice cream is awesome! So glad your coming to New..."
Brian Coccia
"We visit often! The ice cream is so so so good! I love the mocha chip and coconut almond chocolate chip! My guy is obsessed with the birthday cake..."
Tammy Cumberledge-Mcclure
"Johnson's ice cream is really good with a wide variety of new and old favorite flavors. They also have sandwiches and soup, making it a great place..."
Judith T Bird
"First time going and Had the Rollin’ in the cookie dough, was very good! Definitely would come back to try..."
Desiree Hedges
"Best ice cream and shop. We live close enough to walk. Our children know if they have a special event or just want to take a walk. Johnson's is where..."
Sara Mirvis Okoon
"The homemade butter pecan on a chocolate wafer sugar cone was delicious! The service was fast and friendly! ..."
Dinah Ward
"Such a cute place with lots of goodies to choose..."
Corinne Hollingsworth
"My husband and I tried this place on Saturday for the first time and I am in love! The s'mores Bexley and the blueberry pie are my current favorites,..."
Caitlyne Marie
"Awesome place! Kids loved it and so did I. We will..."
Daniel Charles Ross
"I had Johnson's in Lebanon, Ohio. It is great. Where can I find it in..."
Tom Benner
Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams
92/100 (749 ratings)
Dessert
American
Ice Cream
Sit down
American
Takeout
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Mid-range
"I’m so happy they finally have a vegan option other than sorbet! It’s delicious and I hope it’s the first of many dairy-free flavors! Also love..."
Elli Kallinicou
"Absolutely some of the best ice cream I have ever had. When you taste the ice cream here you will instantly taste the fresh ingredients. Although..."
Michael David
"Super friendly staff. Always happy to answer any question you have and give you all the samples you want. Every ice cream is amazing in its own way...."
Haley Dawson
"Love this place! Chad the manager is awesome. I had the pleasure of talking to him briefly this afternoon and I'm so glad I stopped..."
Julie Chambers
"I have NEVER EVER tasted ice cream so good in my life. Sorry Blue..."
Netosha Smith
"Brambleberry crisp is the best! Great service..."
Jennifer Lynn
"Awesome, friendly and patient when you have no clue what you..."
Bernie Welch III
"Best ice cream in the..."
Danielle Potter
Graeter's Ice Cream
90/100 (1319 ratings)
Dessert
American
American
Ice Cream
Gelato
Café
American
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Seating
Cheap Eats
"Graeter's has the best tasting ice cream by far! It's y favorite. Went to this location to get my free Sundae offered to my bday. The girls were..."
Donna Hill
"Always yummy, never disappoints. I love this location in Bexley, the oldest store. It has Wonderful..."
Lauren Connolly
"Loved the peanut brittle �. Should be a regular..."
Paul Hinders
"Great place! Great ice cream! Highly..."
Lisa Eppink Humphrey
"The best!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!Had cookies and cream my..."
Dayshawna Holland
"Thank goodness for ice cream..."
Kim Long
"Superr yumi. The people working there are awensome!!! I love it!!. Exelent..."
Marilyn Moreno
"One of the best Ice Cream shops in town. Good service, great..."
Ritchie Nichols
"Always a fantastic and delicious..."
Kelly Roth
"Great ice cream & right down the street from the best pizza,..."
Greg Moore
"Amazing! Absolutely Delicious! Creamy and..."
Leanna Jo Oglesby
"Today (05/10/22)was my first day revisiting this Graeter’s in a few years. Classically decorated and clean. Various flavors to sample before making..."
The Real Puma Fan
"Lovely place to get ice cream. Would have liked more brownie in the dark chocolate brownie, but it was still delish. Restrooms were clean, and the..."
Vicki Severn
"Amazing ice cream, quality and quantity very satisfying. I've had all kinds of ice cream at literally great places and obviously some bad one's, I'd..."
Sandeep Solanki
"Cool place for a frozen treat. I would milk any chance to stop here. Convince of location is nice and so is their service. Their prices are a little..."
Leavy Peretto
"So perfect, they serve absoutely fantastic flavorful delicious ice cream and other treats such as chocolates. So many choices and varieties on front..."
Rodney Yoswig
"I enjoyed my experience today at Graeter's ice cream I got a chocolate milkshake that was simply out of this world great customer service a good..."
daniel cromwell
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use