Tammra Schiller
Great atmosphere. Great food. Great service. My 13 year old loves the poutine. The beer is good as well. Many options to choose from. A definite must stop. Truly enjoyed the food - wings, french onion soup, and spinach & artichoke dip.
Tom Marasco
First time here, won’t be the last. Food was incredible (Perch Tacos and a burger). Beer was good, didn’t try too many, but the NEIPA was killer, low IBU but hoppy fruity and a great mouthfeel. This will be a regular spot for us. Well worth the trip from Webster.
Judy Peterson
Great menu...bar/pub selections but with their own take. They had some unique things and twists on traditional. Great atmosphere. I was there for lunch with an old friend and we had a great time. The bar is huge; I'm sure there's plenty of room even when the place is full and jumping. Totally enjoyed the place. Server was tremendous. She was the kind that doesn't have to write anything down, treats you like you've known her for years, giving the regulars the business, eager to please and never stopped moving. She helped make the visit the best.
Jennifer Baker
As if the food and atmosphere weren't enough to get me back in, Emily is hands down there best bartender and server ever! And Kole is also pretty chill. The food was great and they have standout service! Make sure to try the Ruby Rolls!
Chad Edwards
Quick and friendly service! We didn’t have a reservation, but they managed to fit us in. The food was excellent - fresh and perfectly prepared. If you haven’t been, you should go. This is my new go-to place.
Pamela Rogers
Freaking awesome. The fish tacos are incredible!!!! And love the Stitches for Snitches brew. Great service, friendly and helpful. Fantastic outdoor seating and weirdly interesting bathroom fixture...I happen to admire kitchen sinks LOL four thumbs up!
Evonne Pomerantz
Everything about this brewery is welcoming. We ordered 2 flites each with total 8 different drinks along with the delicious pulled pork nachos. Prices were awesome!
Shannon Gracie
Delicious food... So many great choices we ordered way too much! My fruity flight was tasty. Would totally get again. I love the veggie plate!
Zach gave us great service...
Shark Man
Our family happened by Irish Mafia while camping in the area. The atmosphere was inviting and themed toward the name. We were immediately intrigued by the menu, and were excited to try the food. We ordered flights, and enjoyed the local beers they offered. The food was fantastic, and left us wanting to return to try more. We bought some merch, and all decided we will return to try more. Highly recommend this brewery destination.
Sean Hanson
Went to eat with the family and had a great time. The flights are $7 so we got to try a lot of the beers and they are very good. They have IPAs, sours, lager, pilsner so something for everyone.
The staff was also very friendly and entertaining. Emily was patient, knowledgeable and funny. Lainey has amazing beer balancing skills!
The food was great. There were healthy options (ahi tuna salad) and comfort food (gangster plate!) so most people should have options to choice from.
Alex Fisher
Great spot for beer and food. Ordered a beer flight and the Gangster Plate. Nice, quiet atmosphere.
Attilio Lospinoso
The food here was really good, I had the Gangster plate, macaroni salad with tater tots and a burger with cheese on top. It was amazing. I also had the thin mint stout, and it tasted exactly as you would expect it to, and it was not very thick! The second beer I had was their irish red, which was also very good. I would definitely recommend visiting, the only con was that their beer menu was only 7 deep of their brews, but other than that it was great!
Caroline Callahan
Friendly and helpful staff! Helped find something dairy-free. Pleasant live music by a two man band. Outer and inside seating, and yard games. Great salad, even better tater tots!!!
Adriano Menezes
Great food, wait staff were very helpful and had great food and beer recommendations. Definitely a must go!!!
Dan Brewerton
Always amazing food and craft beers, superior servers, The owner comes around to say hello and see if you need anything. Overall top notch establishment!
Emily Sherwood
Emily is the absolute best and gave us recs for the rest of our time in the area! She is a gem and deserves a raise. We adored her!
Bridget Turkington
Stout was good, service at the bar was good, what's not good? Insulting an entire culture with blatantly racist branding. "Irish Mafia" is really pushing it to begin with, but I gave them a chance as a first generation Irish girl living in the area. What did I find when I entered but T-shirts plastered with the saying "Erin-Go Fuck Yourself". What a massive slap in the face to the Irish language and Irish culture. Here's a tip to the owner: do your damn research before you decide to participate in someone else's culture. Your representation of Ireland was exploitive and disgraceful. I walked out of your establishment in tears wishing that I never bothered. If you'd like to talk about Irish bar culture or Irish language at some point, feel free to reach out, because obviously you need some education.
Rhianna Wyss
Service was extremely slow (it took 30+ minutes with very few guests for us to receive our food), salad was very poor for being $10+, beets tasted like pure vinegar, and portobello mushroom sandwich was soggy- seemed like they sat in the window for a good 10-15 minutes. We are from out of town, and were very disappointed with the overall experience.
Ann Murphy Gonzales
What a great brewery! Went for lunch today. The beer, food, atmosphere and especially the staff..all first rate. Will be going back for sure!
Kristin Villnow Kumpf
Stopped by The Irish Mafia for lunch, Deli style turkey sandwich was loaded with turkey, delish! Also had a Ruben at our table, everything was great! Super nice atmosphere and friendly wait staff! Definitely will be back again
Kelly Dziadosz
We come to Canandaigua every year and on our way, we were at the red light and happened to see The Irish Mafia. My boyfriend is all about his Irish heritage and we absolutely loved this place! The prices weren't bad at all and the beer was on point. Definitely coming back and recommending the Irish Mafia to everyone �
Mary Jane Mook
Stopped in yesterday to check this place out. Found seats at the bar immediately and then waited at least 10 minutes while countless servers walked past us and never even acknowledged our presence. A couple sitting next to me also mentioned it took a long time for them to get served at the bar. The beer was good once we finally got it. Another customer mentioned that you get quicker service if you go to the register and order your drinks. If that's the case it should be made known when you enter the establishment. As we sat there other people walked up and got served immediately. Not sure it would be worth another trip back.
Elise Ducsay Kloesz
Great new brewery/restaurant/pub! Great place to stop after a day on the slopes! Food, beer, service was great! We'll be back!
Patrick Coughlin
Great venue; the beers were all solid examples of their styles, and the food menu had a nice variety. The food I had was delicious; I imagine the rest of the menu is equally tasty. Check it out, you won’t be disappointed!
Dawn Martin
Service at the bar was great. Enjoyed a flight of beer and each one was great! Highly recommend. I can’t wait to go back and enjoy the outdoor area in warmer weather
Roger J. Stephens
Great food , great beer , took a little while for the food , but the waitress was amazing and keep coming over to make sure everything was ok .
Bryan Tousley
Great beer, great food and excellent service. Doesn’t get much better than here. Love this place
Jamie Elizabeth
I started as a customer and loved the atmosphere so much I now work at Irish mafia!!! Great food, beer, and staff�
Christopher Walkenson
Perfect staff, perfect food, perfect beer. Honestly the only part that isn't perfect is how long of a drive it is for me to get there from Chicago!
Susan J. Boyle
Love stopping here. Reuben was great! Love the tots, fish fry is awesome. The Irish Red and the Bomber Brown ate both very good and I’m not a huge beer drinker. Had a really good sour too.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes