Web User
Based on so many positive reviews, I placed phone order after reviewing the store's online menu. When I picked up my order, I was surprised by the higher charge on my order. Was told that the pricing on the online menu was incorrect, and they wouldn't honor the online pricing. I cancelled some items in my order, particularly one item that cost $3 more than the online pricing.
L D
I rarely order from here. Do yourself a favor and order from a different place. We ordered a pie and it was supposed to take 35 minutes. When I arrived, my order wasn’t ready so I waited an additional 15 minutes in the car. I went back inside and the young lady said “I’m sorry it’s not ready. Not sure how long”. It was already an hour wait. I kindly asked for my money back but owner refused. He was rude and said “no, I can’t do that. You must wait”. I’m not sure if it was because Of my race. But they refused to talk to me and also give me my receipt for the pizza I paid for. I would at least file a dispute with my card company. They finally gave me my order with receipt but after complaining about how rude they were. They should give proper time when customer orders. Not have them wait an additional 35 minutes. They did not meet customer satisfaction and it was clearly a disaster trying to place orders they couldn’t fulfill. I will never order from here again. Let’s not forget how cold the pizza was from waiting on the chicken order that took 20 minutes. It was not worth the wait. The place is also very expensive. Service is terrible also! Best place I e ordered from Zia Zia! Great fast service, on point all the time and fresh delicious food, nice and warm.
Sharday Hill
This pizza has the best authentic taste I have had in a while. I used to live in the city and you know great pizza the sauce is everything!We just bought a house in west Orange but I have been in area for a while and Mario’s from now on!!! Absolutely delicious
robert stone
I been a loyal customer of Mario's for decades, the service has always been good and with the new owners quality has stayed the same, unfortunately like everything else prices have sky rocketed
Latisha Eure
This place is right around the corner feom my home. Not the BEST pizza nor the service. The owner is and his Staff is terrible. I was overcharged and called to explain to the owner (Danny) he’s over talking me and NOT listening to the customer. To me it’s the principle of the matter listen to your customer and give me back my 2dollars. Don’t waste your time.
Tyler Biggs
One word deliciousness! I always hit this place up on my lunch days and they never disappoint. Even with the change in ownership they still stayed true.
Kevin Broomell
We ordered take out through a 3rd party app. Food was quick and super delicious! The pizza was pretty good - I really loved the crust. I think the sauce could use a little zing, but it was still tasty. The buffalo chicken pizza was solid. The wings were the star of the show - they beat Ralph's and Cucina 355's for sure. They were VERY good.
I definitely will be ordering from here again
Justin DeMuro
By far my favorite pizza place currently! I am even willing to drive here to pick up pizza since I'm just outside their delivery range - but it's well worth it. If you're looking for the "typical NJ pizzeria" with no frills except delicious pie, this is where you want to go.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes