TOP 10 BEST Restaurants in Broken Arrow - Updated October 2024

Shiloh's Of Tulsa Restaurant

78/100 (1238 ratings)

Restaurants

Vegetarian Friendly

Gluten Free Options

Vegan Options

American

Vegetarian Friendly

Gluten Free Options

Vegan Options

Brunch

Breakfast

Dinner

Lunch

Fish

Beef

Dumplings

Meatloaf

Salad

Roast Beef

Crawfish

Burger

Catfish

Hamburgers

American

Seating

Table Service

Wheelchair Accessible

Parking Available

Highchairs Available

Takeout

Brunch

Breakfast

Dinner

Lunch

Mid-range

"They have the best rolls and pies. Their food is like Grandma's cooking. The owner walks around asking if everything is ok. If not he will fix it and..."

Sandy Ferrill

"I spent my birthday meal at Shiloh's the rolls and jelly were delicious we had the best server Kelly we all really enjoyed the food and my Italian..."

Adria Wellington

"This was my first time coming here and I really enjoyed this restaurant. Our server, Quinton, was attentive and polite. The bathrooms were clean and..."

Alisa Jamerson

"Excellent home cooked food. Had meatloaf special and open face turkey sandwich platter. Excellent bread pudding. Will be..."

Debbie Kehr Loy

"My husband and I eat at Shiloh's often. Their food is outstanding, especially goulash and their roast beef. I could go on and on. Their wait staff..."

Geri Tettemer

"I can't imagine anyone living in Tulsa or Broken Arrow and not having been to Shiloh's but it is one of the best restaurants in town. Everything is..."

Donna Rainbolt

"The rolls were great. The onion rings and chicken fried chicken were even better. Adriane wasn’t our server, but she went above and beyond to make..."

Mike Rasmussen

"Always fast, fresh, and yummy food. Chicken fried steak is the best. The fresh homemade dinner with their whipped butter is so awesome. ..."

Bea Bois

"Me and a friend ate here tonight. It was awesome. We had an awesome waitress! Her name is Stormy! Great food and great customer service. Very..."

Dawna McDonald

"We love to go to Shiloh as we live close and they have a varied menu. Chicken fried chicken, omelets, beef stew and their rolls are our favorites. ..."

Leah Ann Sebring

"We had the opportunity to eat here yesterday as we were picking up a race car down the street and dropping off another one to be wrapped. The owner..."

Jean Underwood Bradley

"Very good food and excellent service. The staff is extremely nice and courteous. Best place for comfort..."

Heather Crowder Paddock

"Great food, kind service, and very kid friendly. Very clean. Everything you'd want in a home style diner! We will definitely visit again in the..."

Natalie B

"awesome home cooking, huge dinner rolls, wonderful onion rings (huge portion), and friendly service. Best meatloaf in town. Fried catfish (huge..."

Carol Wages

"The food is incredible. Rolls are second to none. Reason for the lower rating? Speed of service. If you want to try to go during lunch..."

Kimberly

"Really good for a home style cooking diner. It at least tasted fresh and not like it had been microwaved. Its the only place I can think of to get a..."

Liz Andrews

"This is a typical Midwest diner. It was packed on the Sunday afternoon we went. I had read rave reviews of the rolls with strawberry rhubarb and they..."

Meowsical

"Ate here after church on a Wednesday night. We were one of the last ones seated as the evening came to a close. Great server who was able to help us..."

Win Noren

"Bacon wrapped hamburger steak! So..."

Tyler Schexnailder

"Second visit on 1-26-2013 dinner. This second visit was better than the first. The onion rings were fabulous. The "special" pork chop with mushroom..."

Melissa

"Great food like grandma makes. Best rolls in..."

Richard Dale

"Home cooking at it's best! I'm amazed to see negative reviews on the food, it's like eating at Grandma's house. The service us sometimes a little..."

Ed

"Home Cooked Meals. Home cooked meals with a choice of vegetables. The hot rolls are a real hit. You will have to go there to see what else they have..."

Bob Bell

"Rolls!. The rolls alone are almost worth a trip to Shiloh's. You have to ask for the strawberry rhubarb jam, that comes in a bottle you squeeze onto..."

Tadd Moore

"Casual family atmosphere. Reasonably priced entrees and awesome homemade..."

Chris Kidd

"Amazing rolls with strawberry jam! A lot of food for the..."

Bre Oberdick

"Quaint Hole in the Wall. I'd seen Shiloh's before when I used to work over in this area of town, but hadn't gone in until recently. As with most..."

C

"Best Home cooking in town. I really love this place and my server Rebekah was absolutely amazing. She was very helpful and was right on top of..."

precious ror

"Best home cooking in town. The huge fresh baked yeast rolls are like my Grandma made for holidays, with the strawberry rhubarb jelly served with..."

YAYASISTER70128

"Love this restaurant! Friendly and very welcoming staff. The food was sooo very good. I would recommend this place to every one. The rolls are..."

Ms. Daniels

"I absolutely love this amazing restaurant. The waitress Chelsy always remembers my order. I may not be here very often. Which is what is amazing to..."

Dustin Hines

"Chelsea is the most awesome server. When I come in with my family and friends and church she is always so helpful. I like all of your servers and the..."

Chris Embry

"Food was amazing but the service was even better! My server Rebekah was absolutely amazing! She was very friendly and extremely helpful. She did such..."

Sarah Willhite

"Chelsea took amazing care of me and my family during our Sunday lunch! She was helpful with ordering something I have never tried before and made..."

Reset

There are 2 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Meatloaf in Broken Arrow

Ranking

Sort A-Z

near you

Filters

Destiney Montgomery

Stuart Steele

Bruce Schultz

Kari Schaller

Andrew Mikus

Michelle Mallett

Amy Greene Wheeler

Chris Davis

Christie Richardson Schreppel

Jerry Herring

Marolyn Allred

Nancy Bean-Halderman