Reviews Catanias Pizza Cafe

5
Klein Visuals
+5
My sibling and I wanted to wander in the cool breeze of Arthur Ave in the early Fall, and we stumbled upon a new pizzeria that opened three months ago. We were curious to try it out, so we ordered our delicious cheese slices with pepperoni. Meanwhile, we noticed that they have a wooden homely vibe, a plushy lounge, and a large flat screen TV displaying sharp visuals and playing the trendiest alternative music. The friendly cashier explained how to order Personal Pies, custom made with different flavors. The food was delicious and I enjoyed the warm vibe. Unexpectedly, the cashier wanted my sibling and I to eat a new Margarita-flavored pizza for testing - on the house! After giving my suggestion, he told me to come back for Number 9: Proper Pizza. Some of the flavors are shown in the photos. Come to Proper Pizza in Arthur Ave! Next week later, my sibling and I tried the Proper Pizza and the Garlic Bread and Cheese, which happens to be another Pizza! Cheers to Proper Pizza in Arthur Ave!
5
p b
+5
I recently visited Proper Pizza and had a wonderful experience. The staff was very friendly and welcoming, and the mushroom pizza was delicious. The crust was thin and crispy, and the mushrooms were cooked perfectly. I would definitely recommend Proper Pizza to anyone looking for a great pizza place.
5
Fisnik Alaj
+5
It's always great to experience cuisine from different parts of the world, and trying famous pizza from Pristina, Kosovo, in New York City. Proper Pizza is a great place to visit for thin crust pizza lovers, especially with their professional staff and extraordinary service. I'm sure pizza enthusiasts in NYC will appreciate the addition of Proper Pizza to the city's culinary scene. Enjoy your pizza experience!
5
kelvin
+5
It’s a great place to hangout with friends and eat a few pizza slices. It’s a beautiful modern place with music to listen too. Pizza was awesome with great different toppings to add on your pizza!
5
Ms. K
+5
Great pizza, awesome customer service and a nice cozy place to chill with friends and eat. Definitely recommend you all stop by and give them a try 💜
5
Lorik Haxhishabani
+5
Great service. Very friendly staff who take care of costumers. I go there for that unique pizza!
5
Frank Costello
+5
I ordered through Uber eats, don’t order using Uber eats this restaurant deserves better. Don’t waste your time using delivery
5
Pegi Bracaj
+5
Great service and even better food. We got the 4 season 24inch pizza and it was amazing. Staff is very professional and helpful. I 100% recommend this place. Very cozy atmosphere and great food. I will be back soon.
5
melissa derosa
+5
The pizza was amazing! The decor was very comfy and welcoming. The employees were friendly, and respectful. I definitely will be coming back. ☺️ ❤️
5
Brandon Najera
+5
Amazing pizza if you’re in the area you need to come here and try it out
5
yll behluli
+5
I just had a very good experience, I missed the Proper Pizza , I just ate it after 6 months and it tasted the same as always, the order arrived very quickly and they were very kind, I fully recommend it !
5
Dajana Neziri
+5
One of the most exceptional pizzas I've ever tasted. Highly recommended!
5
Jola Gosturani
+5
Great service and delicious food! Made me feel like I was having Proper pizza in Albania, where it is originated. Good job 👏🏻
5
Mr Mike
+5
Excellent all around. One of the tastiest pizzas you'll ever have
Clicca per espandere