Corner pizza spot in Riverdale. Ordered 2 mushroom slices and got a polar seltzer $14.00. Slices were great as to no flop with the crust a nice sauce cheese balance and a ton of shrooms. Decent hard working staff was helping out a the local fire station ordered for 40+ right in front of me but no co
The Brushchetta pizza was delicious! The extra $4 to add bacon on half a pie was worth it. Didn’t get pics but the garlic knots were a bit burnt. Also the slices weren’t cut all the way through. Other than that though this was great NY pizza.
Came here on a Saturday afternoon they were busy with deliveries, I got a regular slice to go , a bit much got a slice and a snapple 6 and change ,the slice itself id give it a 5 out of 10
Casual , relaxed atmosphere , easy take out or dine in option , Italian American done well in Riverdale
Great tasting cheese slice, not thick, just has the right crunch and cheese. Nice pizza discount, 2 slices and fountain soda $6. My first time stop, I will revisit. Decor needs remodeling, their sturdy solid tables and chairs just needs refinishing.
Meatball hero was excellent. Server was polite. I would rate 5 . But it was chilly night. When door open my friends were cold. You felt cold blast until door closed. I was good 👍.
Very good thin style pizza. As of June 25th a slice was 3.75
So the pizza is good and specials are great in this economy. I’ve had take out and delivery food is hot -fresh and delicious - not fine dining quality- but great local pizza spot quality food. The guys are all friendly and eye candy as well. ;) pizza delicious - manicotti- cheesy mmm, garlic knot
Good pizza, really friendly staff
We've lived right around the corner from these guys for about 7 years, and they never disappoint! New Yorkers have super high expectations for good pizza, and Goodfellas delivers on all big, gooey, juicy, delicious fronts! They are also very fast, with a friendly staff.
I really really enjoyed their chicken parm . They even toasted the bread without me asking which I completely forgot to do. Delivery in Riverdale is always super quick as well.
Decent spot to get the Pizza by slice. They do have a nice variety of slices and the whole pies are pretty good too. They have daily special entrees which are decent as well and they have a limited seating. I usually order for delivery or pick it up to-go.
Great place to get pizza across from Overlook Manor dorm of Manhattan College. Had a large pizza with sausage and mushrooms and was over the top! Was my main pizza place years ago when I was in school and I'm sure it is still for the current generation. Look forward to many return trips.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes