Yum! I’ve never had Sicilian pizza before. This was amazing! Soft and crunchy crust. Saucy! It’s just damn good!
Est. 1952
Layout/atmosphere
*Small counter area in front with TV near display case/oven; tables in back; backyard area with tables; covered outdoor dining structure in street
Food/Drink
*Grandma Pizza - really good; thin; crispy crust; cheesy; fresh tomatoes in the sauce; little oily though
*Deep
Best Pizza and Fried Calzone EVER! I’ve been eating here since the mid ‘60’s, as a 5 year old little boy. A traditional spot for Good Friday meals. Since moving to Florida a few years ago I make it a point to stop by here whenever in NY. Paulie is only the second owner since John and Onofrio owne
Try their incredibly cheesy DEEP FRIED calzones with a side of sauce or artisan pizzas. The place has been established so long for a reason. Definitely gone back twice already.
Great place.
Lightning fast no-nonsense customer service.
All the slices we got were excellent including the olive slice and the regular slice.
I would go back in a heartbeat.
Delicious! Cute place right off the street.
This place has ruined my life. Horribly. I work in NYC, live in SC, and rarely get to Brooklyn. I had the Primadonna, and now all I can do is dream about it, obsess over it, and plot how I can get back for it. All other pizzas are now just meh to me.
Gas oven, delicious cooked garlicky sauce. I could eat the sauce by itself.
Very high quality pizza and authentic, not greasy, fresh mozzerella. My order tonight had a small error and they immediately rectified it by sending over 2 slices so everyone could eat.
Fried calzones!!!! They fry them when u order one. Not reheated in an oven. Do I need to say more?
The quality of the pizza here is on a higher level. The atmosphere is ambient and the price is reasonable. The ricotta put me in heaven.
The only place to get a real pizza from a real Italian in Brooklyn. Very good 🍕
It was a good pie. Good flavor and everything tasted fresh. Would go well with watching a game on tv.
Pizza Adventures: Destination #146
Probably the best pizza I had in my life. My wife and I were visiting next door and decided to have lunch here. It was the best idea we had. If you are in the area... you have to try this place.
I love coming here when I’m in Brooklyn! All the dishes are outstanding! You can not eat just one slice! It tastes like more!!
Took a ride in with some brothers today for pizza and Calpine. Food was phenomenal.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes