Great place, great owner in Jeff. Worth hanging out - mellow and good vibes.
Sandwiches, bagels, pastries, coffee - all terrific.
Bagels are so fresh and staff are friendly. A neighbor favorite of ours!
Best bagel i have ever eaten. They always have my coffee just right. Highly reccomend
Can you please ship some to south jersey!!! I'm in withdrawal of the bagels!
Felicia Jennings-Winterle
+5
I love their gluten-free bagels. Just got one and it was so, so delicious. It made my day!!
![4]( "Recensione")
My vegetable cream cheese on a toasted sesame bagel was prepared quickly and with a smile.
Although the bagel was a bit small, the cream cheese was surprisingly creamy and very fresh. Overall the sandwich was a bit pricey but possibly the best tasting in Bay Ridge.
As you walk inside you can’t help but notice their wall decorated with nostalgic theme based signs that add a nice touch.
You also can’t help but notice an adorable life size dancing Santa Claus in the store front window, but the wow factor is a bit negated by the exterior cloth flag bearing the store’s name which is torn and in urgent need of some thread and a needle.
On the interior the overhead exhaust duct registers needed cleaning as they have extensive built up dust accumulated from air passing through the vents. Also the floor under a few tables and behind the counter needed sweeping.
The gentlemen at the register who appeared to be the owner was friendly and had a nice rapport with many of his customers. His outgoing personality along with a delicious cream cheese and tasty bagels has a lot to do with the store’s success as it has several repeat customers.
Great atmosphere and bagels!
I saw Bagel Schmagel on the news recently and went with my family. We tried a few types of the bagels (including a cinnamon raisin with cream cheese, a bagel with lox, cream cheese and tomatoes, and a gluten free bagel with an omelette). The bagels were all amazing - definitely the best I’ve had in the city!
I would recommend the shop as a great place to bring family and friends visiting the city for a true NY bagel experience. Bonus is supporting a small local business!
Best bagels and coffee in Brooklyn. Can’t get any better then that. Love that I only live a couple of block away from this place and I just love the vintage look of the store. One thing I do hate is ordering on Grubhub and they forget items from my order. But other then that i love this place. Also hands down best homemade orange juice I ever had.
The bagel I had was out of this world standing there waiting for my bagel looking at the menu they every sandwich that I love going very soon you guys should to please
By far, this homey bagel shop has some of the best bagels I've eaten. Made with fresh ingredients, the food options are hearty and definitely priced fairly. The variety in cream cheeses, bagels, and meal options offers all so many great choices. The staff only add to the warm experience when ordering.
I was so thrilled to be able to visit Bagel Schmagel again this morning! The lady that served us was very professional and friendly. She recommended that we try the strawberry cream cheese with the blueberry bagel. My sis-in-law that was with me ordered everything with scallion cream cheese! Everything was beyond perfect!!
Btw- The updates to the shop look AMAZING!
So when this place first opened years ago I tried the bagels and it was not to my liking, but just recently I decided to give them another chance, and boy am I glad I did I was shocked how delicious these were, much different. Friendly staff, quick service, I have been going to another famous bagel spot for years, I have found my new favorite bagel shop. The only reason for the 4/5 and not 5/5 is bcs it is overpriced I order 3 bagels toasted with cream cheese and butter and was charged $18.52.
I went there for the first time with my daughter. She had a bacon, egg and cheese on a plain bagel. I had the avocado, bacon and cheddar cheese on an everything bagel with a coffee. The food was good, but the coffee was so amazing I had to ask the cashier where did they get it from. I recommend this place.
Very consistent bagel size and freshness, every day of the week. I was pleasantly surprised at how big and puffy they actually are. My favorites are the cinnamon raisin and blueberry. Also, attentive customer service and good prices
This is the only decent bagel spot in the neighborhood of the Third Ave and 75th street Brooklyn. It was my first time there. I ordered puppy seed bagel with cup of coffee. My bagel was fresh and crisp! I loved the fact that the poppy seeds didn't fall off the bagel easily. There was a generous amount of cream cheese on my bagel. I will definitely be back for more fresh bagels at Schmagel Bagel!
nor for nothing, gotta show this place MAD LOVE because is really, really, effing good. Like, I used to order from bagel boy and haven’t since this place. They deliver insanely fast, my 4-year-old loves to give the delivery men the tip and they always amuse him, which is so sweet. And best of all; the food is amazing. The breakfast sandwiches are literally delectable. Now if they start making iced cappuccinos (bye bye b-boy). Anyway, in conclusion, I didn’t want to write this review because I want this place all for myself.
I got the gluten free bagel. They have everything, cinnamon raisin and plain. Their gluten free bagels are made by them and are not a store brought brand. The bagels were actually nice and chewy, similar to a real bagel.. They are a but small in size but the flavor makes up for it. I have this place a 5 star not just for food but for their service. The Hispanic guy working there and the lady at the front were super nice people. Definitely recommend this place for my celiac community. They also have some packed gluten free items such as corn muffins and brownies.
So any bad reviews here I can say are def false! Arielle from what I can tell is the owner or manager is extremely nice as well as Anoshka apologies for any misspells! but the bagel was amazing (got the last rainbow bagel for my child) The four leaf clover cookies were an awesome touch I do not like sugar cookies but these were really good !
Amazing team. Super accommodating, delicious food, detail oriented and service with a smile. Used for catering, would absolutely recommend 10/10.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes