I must say for pizzeria based in Brooklyn in this day and age they're very good at what they do. With a variety of different foods and menu options you are sure to find something to satisfy even the most finicky eater in your family. The environment is clean and we'll managed and the staff is friend
Must try these slices everything is fresh. I do recommend the margarita with fresh basil.
Friendly, family owned neighborhood pizzeria. My children and I come here often and order from home for delivery. They make an awesome white slice 😋
Honestly, I was skeptical to try this place. I saw some bad reviews under the new ownership, there were a lot that turned me off for a while. So I’d always go out of my way to try other pizza shops. I’m convinced it’s some sort of personal vendetta lol. What the hell?! This pizza is great. Service i
Tasty pizza without the attitude. Glad that Nicky's Pizza was replaced by Gus's. The new owners respect their customers and produce better pizza. The place is cleaner.
It is very hard to find good pizza in this area I have tried them all Gus has the best pizza always hot lots of cheese I have had his sandwiches Philly and chk Parm delicious his vodka slice is amazing and also his white this is from now on my only pizza place thank God for good pizza
Best Cesar salad slice I have ever tasted!! The crust was crunchy but a soft texture . I love the Cesar dressing it was delicious and the grilled chicken was so soft and fresh !! Was far from chewy or that weird texture. I recommend it most definitely!
This pizzeria reminds me of Lenny and Johns in Marine Park, my old neighborhood...the pizza from Nicky's is just as good; of not better than what I used to get. Excellent and very tasty-bursting with flavor, it puts most pizzerias to shame!
Pretty good pizza. Soft crust on the thick side, which I love. The staff is always really nice. Ive only tried their regular pie, garlic knots and mozzarella sticks. All were good and fair price. My only complaint is that the pizza is a little on the salty side.
Lots of variety. Food is good.
Excellent pizza and service classic Brooklyn style
Superb NY style. Not doughy. Crisp. Tasty. Worth the trip
Delicious baked zeti's and garlic knots. Our new favorite place for pasta.
Decent pizza, ziti was okay not my fav Staff is very friendly! Pizza taste good!
Small neighborhood pizzeria but the pizza is awesome. It's my favorite in the neighborhood and the staff is super friendly. Not a fancy place but the pizza is fantastic.
nice big slice of pizz
Nicky's is our family's favorite pizza! No matter what we order we are never disappointed. Definitely the best garlic knots around. Been going there since I moved to the neighborhood 9 years ago. Staff is very pleasant and food is always delivered fast!!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes