Everything about my experience was amazing. The wait staff was there before you even needed anything, they don’t rush you through your meals and the food was cooked perfectly and seasoned to make each dish delicious. I would highly recommend the dining experience here.
My boyfriend and I have been to PSI a handful of times and every dining experience surpasses the previous. From verbally making the reservation, to walking in and being sat, to ordering and enjoying every morsel is a stellar experience! My surprise birthday dinner in July was incredible, but this last visit on Sunday 9/3 was hands down the best yet! Our waiter Chris was incredibly personable and professional in his craft at this fine establishment. The food is the best by far in Cape May. Also, being a BYOB enhances the meal. Counting the minutes until our next meal and experience at PSI! Happy Fall everyone �
We had dinner here the other night while on our honeymoon. Couldn’t have picked a better restaurant. Wait staff was friendly in a genuine manner, food was exquisite, view of the ocean from our table on the porch brought everything together. Highly recommended, we will definitely return.
We got engaged here 12 years ago and have come back a few times throughout the years we are here now for our anniversary and I cannot say enough wonderful things about this place and the restaurant is an absolute must best meal we've ever had
Amazing meal. Started with the butter poached shrimp and I had the bacon wrapped monkfish. Ended with the chocolate lava cake and a cappachino. Amazing. The entire meal was fantastic. The plating was beautiful, and the flavors were spot on.
Best place for a meal, best venue for an event. Entire staff is friendly, courteous, and respectful and the Inn is absolutely immaculate. Cannot wait for our return trip!
There were 4 of us at dinner and we all loved our meals. The atmosphere was warm and cozy and the inn is lovely. I had the grilled pork chop which was juicy and cooked to perfection. The entire dining experience was wonderful and I recommend this restaurant to anyone looking for a delicious meal in a beautiful setting.
A beautiful place and venue. Always 5-star service and always professional. Lots of history here too. Men In Black Wedding Officiants always enjoys coming to Peter Shields Inn to officiate and celebrate a couples union. Call them today!
Beautiful old waterfront mansion and fabulous food. Definitely a stellar destination for very important occasions. Two of us dining, shared the beet salad - ample for two - and had seafood entrees with our BYOB Sauvignon blanc. My scallops were perfectly prepared, light sauce, nicely seasoned, nothing overpowering their delicate taste. My companion had the halibut and really enjoyed it. (She’s a NYC foodie, so knows her stuff...) You will be happy here!
The food and atmosphere were excellent and Dorothy who waited on us was great made us feel at home for our anniversary, we will be back , we highly recommend
Absolutely delicious! Excellent service from the minute you walk in , greeted by staff, to our table and our waitress! Food was excellent, from appetizers to our dinner!
Excellent food, ambiance. Our third visit.
Service outstanding, server, Loraine Ferreny was the key to our great service.
Can mot wait for a return visit
Incredibly good food and exceptionally good service. We arrived before our reservation and enjoyed the hors d'oeuvres by the fireplace in one of two lounges. RJ was great server and team was attentive.
My Brother and Sister In-law where in from Sarasota for a family wedding and he wanted to try PSI. We were not disappointed. Food was outstanding and our server Loraine was exceptional. We will be back!!!
One of my favorite restaurants in Cape May.Classy and pristine service. We were promptly seated as expected. Our waiter was very professional and courteous. I had the crab cakes and corn, rice dinner which was excellent. My wife had the scallops and my Girls had a steak. The establishment is beautiful, rich in tradition and artfully decorated.
Excellent experience! After a terribly disappointing experience with another restaurant in town we were determined to celebrate our combined birthdays while we were still down there. Friendly service and delicious food! How refreshing! We finally were able to enjoy our evening. Everything from appetizers to the delicious dessert.s were enjoyed. We will definitely return and recommend .
From the service to the floors this place exceed any expectations I had. Every plate, the entire staff and of course the food was perfection. The place is stunning and gardens are thriving. Pianist played happy birthday for me and other guests. Very wonderful experience thank you
Great location, facing beach, all amenities included. Wonderful restaurant, complimentary breakfast, wine and cheese tasting 4:30-6:30 daily. Free beach access, towels, chairs and umbrella! Wonderful time, 3 day vacation. Loved it. Beautiful weather
Landscape design is top notch.
The atmosphere of this place is lovely and upscale, with live piano music. Service was great with knowledgeable servers. But the food was disappointing for the price point. The crab bisque was the best part, while the filet was the most underwhelming. Order the creme brûlée! Nice date anyway but will probably try something else next time for food that matches the price tag.
Highly recommend for small weddings! Our wedding dinner at PSI was AMAZING. The food was AMAZING. The service was AMAZING. Everyone was so kind and really went out of their way to help you. They made me feel relaxed and able to enjoy myself. I cannot say enough about Amy, PSI’s event coordinator. She was very responsive and helped me plan the whole dinner. She sent me recommendations and answered every question I had. We had a small wedding of about 30 people and this was the PERFECT location. 100/10.
Great atmosphere and service. Chris was awesome and very professional and knew the best recommendations. Location - you couldn’t ask for anything better. Food was not really up to par with the price point. Ordered the pork chop and lobster - both not really up to value. Will try other places in the future.
Justin Friedland (Just Sailing)
+5
Beautiful and elegant atmosphere. Sean, our waiter was amazing. Piano is a great touch and not too loud , perfect way to complete our fabulous meal. Will definitely be going back.
Peter and Lisa Roberts
+5
Cape May in early November. Went for a “romantic” dinner. We’ve had some inconsistencies in the past but this time they were on point. Excellent oysters, foie gras, venison and halibut. Service was on top of everything and we didn’t want for anything.
We Celebrated a special birthday at PSI. Chris was our waiter. He was fabulous. Chris knew the menu well and offered great suggestions. He was professional and polite. The piano man was an added touch. Chris knew the names to some so gs I was trying to remember. My sister in law loved her filet. It was prepared exactly how she likes it. My husband got the clean plate award. I thoroughly enjoyed my surf and turf special. The crab cake had absolutely no filler. I don't know how that is possible. DELICIOUS 😋 They have an awesome porch area that you can sit, talk and enjoy the surroundings. The lawn and flower beds were perfectly manicured.
We will be returning. We wanted to stay there, but no room at the inn for our almost last minute reservations.
There is always next year, cause this place isn't going anywhere.
We came to celebrate my parents' 60th wedding anniversary and were treated like royalty. A larger group can come with food and service challenges for some restaurants. Not so, for The Peter Shields Inn restaurant. In fact, they exceeded all expectations. The food was outstanding; each and every person in our group raved about their meals. The only thing better than the food was the service - truly the best I've had in a long time. Thank you psi for making my parents' day special. It will be a day and meal we long remember.
Our dinner was one of our best in Cape May. Each meal was made special with flavor and presentation of excellence. The service was impeccable. A true 5 Star Experience!
We have been going to PS for about 10 years now. This was the first time I stayed at Inn. They didn't disappoint me. Everyone was on point as always, and the room had a warm and comfortable feeling
Amazing meal - so beautifully decorated, staff very friendly/knowledgeable & meal was amazing from start to finish! Referred by cousins who make it an annual outing, we will return!
Food and atmosphere was stunning. Piano and ocean breeze in the background. Food and drink was delish. Out host offered to take our family picture at the the end without us asking. It’s like she read our minds.
We come every year for our Anniversary and usually dine here as well. Absolutely love the Inn the Staff and Kahlil the pianist! Could literally not be happier with the overall experience!
This is a review for the restaurant: excellent food, great atmosphere. The restaurant technically is BYOB however, they do serve a selection of local wines. So bring your own or sample wines from local vineyards. Expect to pay $100 per guest and yes it's worth it. Will definitely be back.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes