This place was great! We have nothing even close to tasting this good in CT. Glad I stumbled upon it while I was staying close by for one night.
There is no other! The best ice-cream.
We go to Carlisle yearly for a reunion at Dickinson and visit Massey’s at least twice while there. We also take a few pints home.
The perfect ice cream for a warm evening. I ordered an Oreo cookie Arctic Mount made with their chocolate frozen custard. It was delicious, as their ice cream is every time.
Large chocolate shakes to die for. Yum yum! Friendly staff.
:) yum this is the best place evvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvver
Literally the best ice cream place in the area! Delicious treats, great and friendly staff, and perfect location. It doesn't get any better than Massey's frozen custard!
Still a great place for milkshakes and ice cream. New owners have decided to keep it open all year long. Many great memories over the years......
Yummy homemade custard! Thank you for being open even when it was freezing outside! :) Can't wait to go again for a second (third, fourth, fifth, sixth...) vist! :)
Massey's never disappoints! Everything is always delicious and we'll look forward to our next visit.
Always delicious, never changes....why fix what's not broken.....
Local favorite. The quality has remained exceptional. The custard is creamy and delicious. The peanut butter milkshake is delightful!! They sell a pup cup with vanilla and treats.
Truly one one of the old fashioned ice cream stores left, with all the charm you'd expect from an older building. The menu was so varied it was difficult to choose. We went on a Friday night, where Dickinson College students were swarming, but the service was still fairly quick, and totally friendly.. The custard was delicious, and the prices weren't bad.
The ice cream here was so good. The sundae I ordered was fantastic and my girlfriend and her son raved about their ice cream as well. This is somewhere I can't wait to go back to. Also there selection of flavors was decent something for everyone.
Pretty good. Not like years ago it used to be great custard. Now just ice cream but good.
I returned to Carlisle to visit my Mom, we were driving by and I noticed it was open all year now. I don't think it was open all year when I moved to Texas in 2009. Anyway, I ordered a hand dipped chocolate frozen custard with peanut butter syrup. CHANGED MY LIFE!!! I'm back home in Texas now and I've challenged all my local family and friends to name a frozen custard spot here that they think is good. I told them I would tell them if it compared or not but, if it doesn't (I can't possibly imagine another heaven on earth) I would bring them back with me next April so I can change their life too! 😂😂😂😂
Love their rotation of flavors. The raspberry cheesecake was absolutely delicious. Go there quite a lot and the prices are very reasonable
A local Carlisle treat since 1949! A great stop after spending all day at the Spring Carlisle car parts swap meet and car corral. The service by local "youngsters" is outstanding. Must try their "high test" custard.
Good old fashioned frozen custard. I had chocolate with chocolate sprinkles!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes