Amber Russell Gonzalez
+5
We tried out Prodigy Burger & Bar last Monday evening and we really enjoyed the experience. It has a sports bar atmosphere but very clean and well-kept. Great drink selection and I love the open kitchen concept. We started with the cheesesteak eggrolls and they were delic! It came with four eggrolls, I had two and they were very satisfying. A good portion of steak and cheese in a crispy outer shell...yum! I had a heavy lunch that day so decided to order The Innovator for dinner. It's a Kale salad with cranberries, pecans and grilled chicken, super tasty and I felt like I could still try some "boozy dessert" after our meal. My husband went for the Prodigy Burger which has a waygu blend, pepper jack, cheddar, mushrooms caramelized onions, peppers and garlic aioli. Of course I had to try it too! I loved the bun it came on and the burger was cooked perfectly. Flavor combos were great and the fries came in a fun little basket and tasted fresh and crispy. We finished the night off with one of their boozy sundaes/shakes. We had "The Dude", OMG, soooo yummy! We will be back to try out some more options!
Ordered a medium-rare burger with mushroom, Swiss and some other fancy cream cheese. What did I get? A real medium-rare wagyu burger, sizzling on an iron plate, slathered in shrooms and cheese. Awesome. Most burger joints screw up the burger temperature. They nailed it! Wife and kids gave thumbs up as well. Great atmosphere and the service was top notch too. Lots of TV’s, family friendly, great beer selection. Will definitely come back.
Vivian Elliott Lawhead
+5
Kudos to our server, Omar, at Prodigy last night( new to Clay Terrace)First, we had a table of 10, 6 of whom were gluten free, and 5 of whom were kids. Omar was accommodating, and even let us know the fabulous kitchen was firing up a separate fryer just for our fries so there would be no cross contamination. Delicious food and superb service!
Best burger spot in Carmel/Westfield/Noblesville now. Been hoping and waiting for a place like this. Great burger options, awesome fries and the Mrs loved the grilled chicken sandwich. Awesome craft beer selection as well.
Amazing burgers, Mac n cheese and dessert!! Love this place! Very impressed with the food and the great service! Highly recommend.
We sat at a high top by the bar and had excellent service. Beer selection was great and the food was on point!! We will definitely be going here again soon!
Easily the best place in clay Terrance to have a burger and a beer. Also has a great bourbon selection.
With great food and excellent service, this establishment is the perfect place for lunch and drinks. On Wednesday's, they have half off bottles of wine. In addition, they offer a diverse selection of craft beers and flights of various types of whiskey. I would recommend the Wagyu Prodigy Burger, which is one of the most delicious burgers I've ever had. Lastly, our server (Lydia) was excellent - helpful and attentive!
Got the pulled pork egg rolls, they were delicious. I also got the "16th Masterpiece" it was so good, I forgot to take a picture of it. Their fries are fantastic and the service is very good. The only criticism I have is that it is a bit loud in there and that makes it difficult to carry on a conversation, but I would definitely recommend a burger and a beer there.
![4]( "Recensione")
Three of us went to this place for the first time on Oct. 5th. We ordered 3 different burgers with fries and short rib nachos for the appetizer. They made their nachos with potatoes. Actually potato nachos were very good, not salty at all, well balanced with short rib. Three burgers we ordered, the Prodigy burger, the Mozart, the Goat, were cooked exactly how we ordered. All burgers were perfectly seasoned, served well made home-made sauces, and they are a half pound. The server was very nice, kind and knows what she has to do. And the singer was bold, courageous and made us comfortable with her songs. We will go back and try something else.
Oct.13 Sat.
I went this place one more time with my daughter.
She ordered the GOAT and I ordered the Captain, medium both. And I asked if we change the fries to duck fat pom. Frittes and steamed broccoli, the server or the bartender said ok. But when I got the check, she (prodigy)charged me $3 extra for both substitutes. Anyway it’s ok. The burgers were cook perfectly. The good burger so far.
Jan. 21, 2019
My son and I went to this place for dinner. We ordered a cup of Chicken Tortilla, a cup of chili , the sheriff, the Craisian. The two soups are ok, just ok, actually below the average. Two burgers are very good, not awesome. Actually I ordered medium burger, but mine came almost well done. But still ok, good burgers and very good fries.
02/22/19
It’s been a while to come this place. We ordered the Captain, Captain Ahab, and the 16th Masterpiece. I ordered the 16th Masterpiece, medium, but I got well-done burger. Crab! I had to eat this dry, well-done, no taste burger all the way. They are used really good at cooking the patties, but today I really dissatisfied and disappointed. I have to think about to keep 5 stars or drop to 1 star.
6/7/2019
We went to this place for 2 months. We ordered one Captain, one Prodigy Burger and one Summer Ale from Sam Adams. We had really good time. The server, Aspen, was awesome.
10/19/2019
6 of us came this place for my wife’s Birthday. Everything was pretty good. Thanks to the our server, Ashley B, she was awesome.
Prodigy is an upscale sports bar/restaurant. The burger was quite good but could have been great with just a little more effort. Reading some of the other reviews seemed to say similar things - namely, everything could use a little more flavor. I had their version of a mushroom and swiss burger made with wagyu beef. It was good. However, put a little salted butter on the patty while its cooking and saute the mushrooms and it would be awesome! The meat patty and mushrooms were delivered on a hot fajita type skillet which was cool. They have gluten free hamburger and sandwich buns.
Had a great experience at Prodigy. Their burgers are amazing and the beer selection is diverse. Our table was just inside the open garage doors on a beautiful spring day. Can't wait to come back again!
Great staff great atmosphere tried for the first time for Devour Indy. I will definitely be coming back.
I had the Wagu burger and I can’t show you a picture because I Devoured it (get it) one of the best burgers I have had in a long time. Kids eat free in Monday’s now I have a reason to return
My husband i love this place, i am not big on burgers but when i have an onion ring craving or maybe a burger we go here. The meat is always the temperature we asked to be cooked at, usually we order our burgers medium well. The service is good too, our last server was patient and very nice. This place does not disappoint, i don't go into burger spots with great expectations,but i also think as easy a burger is to grill its also easy to screw up. We like the burgers here, the fries are awesome and i can't get enough of the hand battered onions rings.
Went here for lunch with my wife. Staff was great and very knowledgeable about the menu. Everyone was very helpful and made it clear they were half we were there and wanted is back.
Burgers are thin so having a double send to be the standard. Lots of different selections of burgers and they're really tasty. The have a Metallica Burger so I had to get that. Yum!
Fries were pretty good although my wife thought they could use more seasoning.
It's not a cheap place to eat, but the food is great.
Love that we tried PBB on a whim. I got the no name burger on a lettuce bun with tots!! Yum. Husband got the chili and Buffalo chicken wrap. You could tell they were short staff, but had amazing service regardless, we will definitely be back!!
Good burgers, fast friendly service. Wish we could have opted to try an adult milkshake, but little sleep and a long drive doesn't mix with alcohol. Well I guess we'll have to come back....
Great service and food! Loved it! They definitely didn’t disappoint and our bartender, Cameron, surprised us with the Prodigy Donut for dessert which was definitely the highlight of dinner. I will definitely be coming back!
Had the best burger here!!!
I choose the build your own burger and it was perfect, taste amazing along with their fries!
If you are in Carmel and around the Clay Terrace, check them out!
Came for a late lunch on Friday afternoon, place was quiet so service was quick. Built my own burger, they have many options if you go this route, I was not disappointed.
Great menu variety, friendly service, great food that was quick to the table. Highly recommend the Prodigy IPA.
Fantastic menu: full of variety and originality! Food was delicious. Our bellies were full when we left!
Great Mac and cheese smash burger and loaded tots. Forgot my fries on the pickup, but quickly replaced them when I mentioned it, happens to the best of us.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes