A Cape classic. The House Pizza well done is my favorite. Delivery is fast and consistent. Just tip driver well! If you come for lunch at counter my go to is Meatball sub. They always have 1970’s game shows on TV. Beer selection while different is very cold.
Thanksgiving is a time for family gatherings. My family has all moved on. My friends are my family now. Even though numerous offers were made, I declined. I want to thank Craigville Pizza & Mexican for the outstanding meal provided for Thanksgiving dinner free to the public and those like myself who would have been alone.
Our server was attentive, polite, and tended to every request made with the warmest smile at all times.
Thank you for opening your doors.
Heavy tipper 😉
A very nice place, not far from Craigville beach. A big selection on the menu. Chili was delicious. I had them add extra hots. Enchilada was delicious too, nicely prepared. And I had a nice salad with Greek dressing, also nice. Waitress friendly and attentive.
Tv is on with games, locals order take out, has beer. Old fashioned booths. Had the personal Craigville pie, 14.95. Delicious..good crust, onions, green peppers, pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms. Ate it all by myself.
Simply delicious, fresh pizza with what tastes like dough made in-house! Service was great, staff was friendly, place was clean and great atmosphere.
First time in a long time. Pizza is as good as I remember. Salad was fresh, and grilled chicken was very good. Service was a little slow, but they are clearly understaffed.
Such a lovely place we went twice in 4 days. So welcoming and the staff are just wonderful, friendly and work incredibly hard. Food is good, we ate pizzas, salads, kids food, mexican...all of it finished off with full bellies and happy faces.
Reasonably priced, clean, good TV and a few arcade games but really its the waiting staff who made our experience so positive. Super friendly, accommodating, chatty and great with our 3 kids!!
Definitely recommend!!!
Consistently good food and service throughout the 40+ years I have been going here. Came back to Hyannis after a long hiatus and went for dinner and was pleasantly surprised by a beautiful large salad with truly delicious grilled chicken. Always have looked forward to hitting the spot after a long day at the beach for some delicious pizza
Don't be fooled by the look of this place - totally authentic retro, right down to the melamine plates and plastic soda cups. We were greeted by a friendly young woman at the counter who told us to sit anywhere that had a set up. She brought us menus and took our drink order. We decided to share a small house salad and a house pizza. While the salad was adequate but underwhelming (iceberg lettuce, one tomato slice, one cucumber slice, one olive, one pepperoncini, grated carrot and thin sliced red onion) the pizza was the star of the show. The crust was a perfect blend of crunchy and soft, the homemade sauce was very tasty and the toppings just right. While I'm not sure if it would taste as good after travelling in a box, the dine-in experience was perfect. We will definitely be back!
Grabbed take out last night. The calzones are just as yummy as we remembered. It was delicious!! Thank you for not changing the recipe. Amazing service, atmosphere and food!!
Hands down the best pizza I've had on my trip was the Hercules. Really great service and good food. Don't miss this place.
Really nice people. Clean restaurant. Reliable service in tough times. The Craigville chicken pasta dish is really good.
We always eat at Craigville Pizza when we are in the area. The service is always friendly and fast; the pizza is the best on the Cape and the beer is always cold. We haven’t tried any Mexican options yet, we always go for pizza. If you are nearby, stop here, you won’t be disappointed.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes