Reviews Hawthorne's New York Pizza

Zomato
Jeremy Christ
+3.5
Meh, it's fine. Food I've ordered has been good enough...but no burgers?! lol come on...how hard is it to make a burger? Surprised they're not on their menu.
May 08, 2017
Zomato
Alison Legault
+4.5
Surprisingly good for a neighborhood restaurant. Moved to the area and have now eaten here 3 times. Each time great food.
Sep 02, 2014
Zomato
Brent
+4.5
Good pizza and gluten free menu. Just tried for first time - had a big group with one person who needed gluten free. The wings were good and the pizza was good (even the gluten free one). I will be coming back.
Dec 01, 2013
Zomato
Alc90
+4.5
We have been eating here every Wednesday for over a year, frequenting this place even before this routine. Specials are fantastic, pizza is delicious...nothing on the menu disappoints. Can be heavy handed with sauces. Service is great. Tip: wraps are on the lunch menu but you can order them for dinner! Check the date on those bad reviews.....we LOVE Hawthornes!
Apr 30, 2013
Zomato
Shannon Johnson Ziegler
+4.5
You won't be disappointed! .... You won't be disappointed!
We've been going here for 7 years and have never had a bad meal or service. LOVE this place!!
Feb 15, 2013
Zomato
Katie
+4.5
Great all around. Went there today, and was greeted by a very polite hostess/waitress. Seated promptly and drink orders were taken and brought to us almost immediately. We settled on the Hawthorne's Sicilian pizza with pepperoni. The waitress was kind enough to let us know that it was going to be a little longer than usual since it was such a thick pizza. During the wait, she never let our drinks run out. When we got the pizza, it was huge! I could only manage two slices before I had to quit. It was so delicious though. The cheese was gooey and the pepperoni was just crispy enough. It was like garlic bread pizza, crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. Mmm... I'm glad that I live just down the street from the place, because this is going to be my regular pizza spot. Next time I get a sicilian though, I'm going to have more help eating it. :)
Mar 20, 2011
Zomato
Shootpar
+4.5
Above average all the way around. I've never really had a bad meal here. The food is above average and the service is slightly above average. They're not terribly fast, but I guess it does take time to make a pizza or calzone. They have a very good beer selection on tap. They used to have $1.50 drafts on Monday's (including imports). They do have a tendency to burn the crust on the pizzas and calzones which some people may like, but I don't.
Dec 31, 2010
Zomato
Pickypuppy PDX
+4.5
Great lunch specials. Not the best pizza I've had, but certainly not the worst. We ordered pizza by the slice and the 'slice of the day' was very good - BBQ chicken with hot sauce instead of traditional pizza sauce. The 'NY Style' cheese slice however was served cold. Which to most people may have been an issue, but I prefer my pizza at room temperature anyway, so it was just fine. The pizza was mediocre at best, but the crust was excellent, I suspect ordering an actual full sized pizza would result in a better quality product, which is what I plan on doing next time I'm in the area.
Sep 26, 2010
Zomato
CreeksList.com
+4.5
Great pizza wth fresh ingredients. A good selection of fresh salads and homemade garlic bread. Plenty on the new menu to choose from & 1.50 beers on Monday.
Aug 13, 2009
5
Garrett Krause
+5
Had a great late lunch. Our server was super friendly and helpful with recommendations. We had the meatballs and mozzarella sticks for an appetizer and had cheese pizza, BBQ wings, Stromboli, and chicken Alfredo. Food came out pretty quick and hot. All in all was a good experience.
5
QC Cici
+5
Hawthorne’s , a hidden gem! I was out running errands on this rainy Memorial Day weekend, there weren’t any barbecues to go to, I didn’t feel like cooking, and I wasn’t in the mood for fast food … I called my foodie friend for a good suggestion, and he highly recommended Hawthorne’s. I was hungry, curious, and in the area, so I placed my order for the Classic White 4 Cheese Pepperoni Pizza with garlic butter crust, and hoped that they would live up to their rave reviews. The moment of truth… I arrived home, opened my pizza box and was about to devour this pizza (my 1st meal of the day), but it was so beautiful that I had to take a picture. I had a feeling that this pizza was going to be review worthy, and I was right! This pizza tastes as good as it looks! Everything about this pizza was perfection.. it literally melted in my mouth. The 4 cheeses complimented each other nicely, paired w/the perfectly cooked pepperoni, and the delectable garlic butter crust. This pizza wasn’t just delicious, it was a culinarily masterpiece! Hawthorne’s on Highland Shoppe Dr. is the best pizza that I’ve had in Charlotte. If you're in the area, it's definitely worth a visit!
4
Lana Decker
+4
Food is amazing and tasty and I willing order it - to go. Our server was very nice and attentive. Food was great as it is in all Hawthorne restaurants. Our drinks looked great, but unfortunately I would describe it as "tastes the same perfume smells" - would not order raspberry mohito or mango margarita again. Another detractor was that no one cleaned the tables after people left. I didn't think it would bother me to eat surrounded by uncleaned tables but it did (they were at 50-60% capacity, not crazy buzy). All in all, I'd recommend this place for food and beer /wine, definitely not mixed drinks.
5
Fortenowski The Myth the Legend
+5
Call in an order and go pick it up and it will be handled! Customers don’t even touch the front door ... there is a full service employee greeter there to open the door! Want to sit in your car?? No worries ... they will bring your order to you and you can sit in your car or stand around and watch things under control as good as can be. Difficulty feeling comfortable getting out? I recommend you drop by and see what all restaurants need to be doing! I felt comfortable here at Hawthorne’s and I’ve yet to see any restaurant handle this any better! Review pre-pandemic: Hawthorne’s is ten times better than Olive Garden. We just finished another great meal at Hawthorne’s Prosperity! The leftovers from Hawthorne’s are actually even better the next day when I reheat them. Olive Garden leftovers I throw away. Please everybody keep standing in line at Olive Garden while me and my family eat drink and play Trivia on line at Hawthorne’s! Locals hangout regularly here and they love the drinks and the pizzas! I call in an order every once in awhile but my favorite way is to go in and order in the back at the takeout register and then I belly up to the bar and see if I can drink three before they have the order ready... so far only been able to drink one or two and then they summon me that my order is ready ...
4
Tom Brouillette
+4
Located in strip mall a number of tables with bar, nothing special but clean and service was very good. Also provide a great deal of take-out. Nice selection of menu items and server suggestions were very good. We had 2 pizzas; Buffalo chicken and white along with. Ceasars salad and it was all very good. Overall, very good experience
5
Chase Price
+5
Picked up a to go order and it was fantastic as always. The staff is friendly when you walk in, and the order was ready when I was told that it would be. The wings are great and you can tell they have homemade wing sauce. Also had spaghetti and cheesecake on this order and both of those dishes were great too. Definitely recommend giving this place a try!
5
Ben W
+5
Five stars for the basic yet surprisingly tasty NY cheese pie, and for the attentive spot on service from Ashley. The restaurant was also spotlessly clean and well appointed. We were there at prime dinner time on 8-9-22 and we’ll definitely be back.
4
Jonathan Stevenson
+4
Alex was our server, super attentive and respectful! Only reason not 5 stars is we wanted to watch NFL network but never happened after we asked twice. All good though, pizza was AMAZING and the Budweiser was ICE COLD!
4
Jess
+4
Staff isn't the most attentive, but the food is to DIE for. NY pizza is delicious, the pasta is fresh and amazing, and everything is fairly priced. You can have a 3 course dinner for 2 for under 60$, with alcohol! Definitely a great place to sit down or get to-go.
5
Ron Israel
+5
Love It, Love It, and oh yea...Love It. Great pizza and a huge fan of "The Inducer." Also, who can deny themselves 10/$10 wings on Saturday's and Sunday's? Not moi. Lol. Long Island, me, please. Don't meet me there, beat me there.
4
Juanita
+4
The first time I had Hawthorne's was at the location on 7th Street. I had such an amazing veggie pizza (light cheese) with garlic knots, I decided to try the Highland Creek location which is closer to my home. I placed the same order as I did when I visited the location on 7th Street. My veggie pizza was the worst veggie pizza I've ever had in my entire life. No Exaggeration. The pizza barely had any vegetables, and when I asked for light cheese, the cheese was not light, it was more like a sprinkle, barely any cheese and barely any sauce. In addition, the pizza was slightly burnt, but not in a good way. The only positives were the garlic knots, and the friendly staff at this location. Moving forward, if I ever have a hankering for any pizza I will go to the 7th Street location or to my local Domino's. Update: December 2nd, 2023 The restaurant reached out to me and apologized. They sent me a gift card for a replacement pizza. Since then I've bought about 3 more veggie pizzas, at separate times, from this location and each one has been delightful. Definitely a positive turnaround from the first time at this location. If you're in the area, please stop by.
5
MiChelle Kirk
+5
Shrimp caprese Yummy! And Anna, our server is a sweetheart. The entire dining experience gets 5 stars from me👌🏽 Update 10/5/2022...2 years after our last visit😋 Our server was DeLeon👌🏽very good. We were even approached by the host named Jack. Listen. These two guys made our experience worthwhile. Today we had Hawthorne's Trio Carbonara. Excellent choice. Glad we stopped here for old times sake. We moved to Florida and just passing through Charlotte for a few days. Glad this place is still here.
5
Bruchelle Simmons
+5
I love a good cannoli that isn’t jammed packed with chocolate chips and they delivered!!! The pizza was pretty good too. We sat over in the bar area and our bartender was super sweet. There was a large party at the restaurant that she was also assisting with, but she was SO attentive to us. I’ll definitely go back!
5
Adam Ill
+5
I ordered a delivery/pickup from Hawthorne's. I ordered Chicken Parm and Garlic knots. In the description I wrote "I DO NOT want Garlic knots. I paid extra for just a HEALTHY serving of Chicken Parm" Let me tell you, they did NOT disappoint. This thing had to be 4lbs of pasta and chicken(3 huge pieces), loaded and slathered in sauce and cheese. 10/10 service - exactly what I was asking for. Also, it was phenomenal.
5
Lindsey Carrick
+5
Amazing food here! We've never had a bad meal. Love this place but do agree with other reviewers that it seems a little overpriced. We came for lunch and the 4 of us has a bill over $50 and we all only ordered a meal a piece.
5
Destiny Mickell
+5
I did a pick up order so can’t say much about dining services but the take out team was great, communicated and gave me exactly what I asked for. Pizza was really good too!
4
Linda Lindsey
+4
Went for lunch the first time today. I had the veggie wrap which was delicious. The person with me had the chicken Philly hoagie which was tasty, but he felt like it could have been improved with some mushrooms and green peppers. It was just chicken with onion on the hoagie roll. Quality food, but I feel like it was a quite pricey especially for lunch.
Clicca per espandere