Alex Issokson
I absolutely LOVE Marion’s Pie Shop—easily some of the best pies and bakery goods down on Cape Cod! I always come here at least once or twice a year over the summer to get some berry pies (Baileyberry is a favorite), as well as some pecan squares. When we recently went, we even got some chicken pot pie and cinnamon rolls. All were excellent. Here are pictures of everything! I highly recommend heating up in the oven before consumption.
Michael Tunick
First time in Cape Cod and we were super excited to try this place.
We ordered the shepherds pie, hamburger pie, macaroni and cheese, apple pie, and Dutch apple pie.
The shepherds pie and hamburger pies were delicious. Super tasty with good crusts. The macaroni was ok. Taste was alright but the consistency was not really to our liking.
The apple pies were so good. Each different but very very delicious.
Things to keep in mind - the meat pies need to be warmed up in an oven prior to eating.
Only real critique, having a menu outside would be super helpful. Inside is small and if you haven’t been there before it can take a while to order. And that creates a logjam inside.
We will absolutely be back for more the next time we’re in the area!
Elise LeBlanc
We used Marion’s Pie Shop for our wedding desserts and we cannot recommend and thank Cindy and her team enough! They went far above and beyond to create a variety of our favorite desserts for our guests - even trialing new recipes just for the occasion until they were perfect! We got an overwhelming number of compliments and we cannot thank them enough for their flexibility and high quality services! We can’t wait to use them again for our next event too!
Viraj Patel
My girlfriend loved the slice of Bumbleberry pie we got but while I think it was well made with good ingredients, the filling was under sweetened and the crust was a bit salty and not buttery enough. But that might just be my taste.
Larry Hazen
Not do crazy about the chicken pot pie we got... very few veggies... granted got tons of chicken and the extra gravy bucket comes in real handy.
The cinnamon rolls were pretty good though... Yummy
Louise Baddiley
I'm a New Zealander and we are pretty fussy about our pies which are considered a national dish. My brother and I stopped by and grabbed the Hamburger Pie (which we would call a Mince Pie) and it is LEGIT! Delicious! Thanks for this slice of home. The guy in the shop was lovely too - we had a lovely conversation with him. Highly recommend!
Amy Gentile
For our Cape Cod wedding in June, we decided to skip the traditional cake and go with something different. Marion’s Pie Shop was the clear choice, since we know how delicious the pies are. Wanting to support a local business and having a smaller guest count- it worked out perfectly! We went with one large and two smaller pies: strawberry rhubarb, dutch apple, and lemon meringue. We didn’t order ahead, just went by the shop and picked them up the day before the wedding (we went right when they opened though, because we know they don’t last long!). The pies were so amazing and our guests loved the idea!
Adolfo Diaz
I have not had their dessert pies, but the savory Seafood pie and chicken pie are excellent! Pick one up , add a quick salad and you got yourself a delicious dinner in a few minutes.
Cheryl Saunders
Best carrot cake you will ever have. We always buy the Bumbleberry pie which is awesome. This week we tried the carrot cake and it's the tastiest, moist carrot cake you will find anywhere. The Bumbleberry pie, cinnamon rolls, pecan bar and Parker House rolls were wonderful.
Michelle Iler
We stopped just before closing. Staff was very happy to explain items to us and offer us what was left. We purchased a small chocolate cream pie! Delicious!!
Emma Popowski
not exaggerating— best pie I’ve ever had. Baked fresh and melts in your mouth. And they have savory treats too??? Do yourself a favor and stop by here. And get more pie than you think you’ll need because it disappears fast 😂
Anna Romanov
We dropped by Marion’s Pie Shop for the first time a few days ago and were delighted to discover their assortment of sweet and savory pies and treats! They had blueberry, cherry, apple cinnamon and rhubarb pies. We got the latter, along with a bacon quiche - and both were amazing. We’ll be back!
Mary McPartland
Wowza!! Literally the BEST pie I ever ate! Get the BaileyBerry Pie, large. Actually, get two! Wish I'd tried the Clam Pie, bought for my house host, looked amazing. Thank you for an amazing good experience! We are a chicken potpie for breakfast! Warm up that crust and let it rip. I tried the lentil bean soup in the shop. Personally, too salty and really, this place is about their crusts.
Bit of a line and the cranky customers who can't have a pleasant wait seem really out of place.
Parking is challenging here. The pull-in is easy, but you back right out into traffic. Have patience!!
My best advice is to buy as much as your budget will allow. Bring some pies home to freeze. Insanely good!
Kev Alexandra
Picked up a couple of pies, strawberry and rubarb, and a hamburger. Both were delicious and as a Kiwi (New Zealander), the pie tastes just like one from home. I will be back!
C Smith
Absolutely delicious! Crust is amazing. Fruit pie is not too sweet. Chicken pot pie and quiche are spot on.😋
p walkie
Wonderful set up. Cozy and welcoming. I got a chix pot pie too. Great treat!
Helen Jean Stipo
Yum yum yum! Has Marion's grown over the years! It's been quite a number of years since I've been to the Cape, and I was (not) very surprised that Marion's has gone from a small shop to a much busier operation. However, this is a sign of how yummy the pies are and the success that has ensued. And the best part is that the pies are just as delicious. Making them in larger quantities hasn't compromised flavor. My favorites are always peach, blueberry peach, and strawberry rhubarb. And now (well probably for a long time, now--like I said, it's been years since I was last there) they sell many other things - quiche, savory pies, cookies, pastries, etc. A must go to when in the Cape.
Sapientia Thomas
This is honestly the best pie I have ever had. I killed an entire Rhubarb pie myself amd then came back for more the next day. 5 stars, hands down best little pie shop in the Notheast.
John Robards
So I tried the Peach Pie and the Razzleberry Pie. I really liked the Razzleberry , this is an apple, raspberry and blackberry I think. It was delicious and well worth the money spent. I tried the Peach Pie as well but wasn't so keen on that as it was sort of spiced with cinnamon and such but I would have preferred it sweeter. Good pie but not my cup of tea.
I thought the prices were good for fresh baked pies. I thought it was money well spent. Might even try to grab a pie to take home.
Sueann Waryas Van Buren
OMG, if you love pies, you must stop at this gem! Key Lime is our favorite but there are lots more to enjoy! All fantastic! On our way out of town we got there at opening to get the fresh cinnamon rolls! They’re huge and out of this world deelish! They sell out early so we’re happy to have enjoyed them! We will return when in Chatham again!
Mitchell Louis
Went in looking for a chocolate silk pie and the women says try the Boston cream pie as it was her favorite. Didn’t catch her name but wanted to say thanks as your suggestion was GREAT!! Also purchased an Apple pie that didn’t disappoint either!
Kathleen McManus Allen
I stopped by and picked up a chicken pie with gravy and a cherry pie while I was staying in W.Yarmouth. they were so delicious I would drive the 96.8 miles from my home for more- and I will!
Very nice chatting with another retired nurse ( owner), too!
Pamela Pakey
Love Marion's Pie Shop! Just got back from Chatham and had both their savory and sweet pies. The crust melts in your mouth YUM!
Tammy Hare
This place is amazing. Baked goods are fresh and delicious. Chicken pot pies are our favorite. Even comes with gravy on the side. I stock up for the work Ter and freeze them!!!
Tami Conn
Such delicious pies! I can’t wait to go back and try some of the other goodies on the menu!!
Jimmy Bee
Stumbled on this place while driving around on vacay. Cookies were delicious, as were the pies. Staff was so friendly and helpful!
Holly Abate
What’s not to love about yummy chicken pot pies ?!!
Zoe Swartz Koston
Honestly, this was the best pie we’ve ever had! We purchased a razzle berry pie and the next day came back for a cherry pie. Today I am going back for cinnamon rolls! This is a very popular place, usually a line out the door. Tip - If you want a particular pie go on their website and call ahead to reserve the items that you want.
Michael J Farrell
So happy we came across this little gem out on the Cape!!! The pies are amazing and well worth the ride!!!!�
Jim Pressman
What’s not to love?? Delicious muffins, cookies and pies. When you go be sure to try the Chatham Muffins- mmm!
Diane Tufts
The Beef Pie we brought home from our trip was pure EVIL....so delicious, we cannot stop talking about it. �
Alec Schwartz
Razzleberry pie is our absolute favorite! Have been going for decades.
Genevieve St.Louis Jan
Go all the time... great hermits and turnovers- All our favorites!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes