Sluurpy > Restaurants in Chatham > Buffy's Ice Cream Shop

Review Buffy's Ice Cream Shop - Chatham

B C
Pink Explosion! My daughter dove into a strawberry ice cream and pink sprinkle cup of deliciousness! We’ve never stumbled upon pink sprinkles before so she just had to give ‘em a try! I indulged in the Chatham Light Bar. The perfect amount of cookie, chocolate chucks and vanilla! I love biting through ice cream while hitting chewy chunks of dough and chocolate chips. I could eat about five more! The atmosphere inside and out was very charming and cozy. Can’t wait to go back for another bite!
Teresa S
Thinking about the girl who posed for a photo for her social media and them promptly handed it back to her man exclaiming, “Here, I don’t want this.” Can I have it? The pistachios on my banana split were absolute perfection!
Fran Marci-Glenn
The cookies that surround the home made ice cream bar are baked by hand by my friend, Nolan Linsky. Outstanding
Alf Raju
Great ice cream and great people that run this shop. As visitors to the area, we have been to get quarts of Heath bar vanilla ice cream 3 times. Just so 👍🏾
Claire Chiang
I ordered maple walnuts which is great! It’s not over sweetened and the walnuts smell great. They made these two in a perfect mix!
Morgan Milhomens
Tried the most popular cookie dough sandwich and the special snickerdoodle sandwich. Both were out of this world! The cookies were the perfect consistency and the ice cream was incredible. The cherry on top was the hand squeezed lemonade - the perfect tart compliment to the sweet ice cream.
John McCarthy
Great ice cream place. We went in for some ice cream after eating dinner nearby. Quick service and tasty ice cream. Two spoons way up!
Sahara Marte
Amazing homemade ice cream. Loved the coconut oreo and the waffle cone. It tasted so fresh. Social distancing inside and great outdoor seating area. Highly recommend.
Corey Rethage
This place is absolutely amazing. How good? Let’s just say Chatham Bars Inn is second best. Now to figure out how to bring some home.
David Ryan
Really, really, really good ice cream and the staff is very friendly and helpful when you are trying to make your choice. There are also picnic tables in the back for everyone to enjoy there ice cream.
Shahzad Zia
Very good ice cream in the heart of Chatham. We went on early evening one Saturday and the lines were not too bad. They have some outdoor seating as well. Overall a great ice cream experience on the Cape.
Laura Nedelcu
Amazing ice cream, I had the Banana Boat, it was huge but delicious
Sue Cluck
I had their blackberry ice cream in a waffle cone and it was the best ice cream I had in all of Cape Cod! There was a marshmallow and delicious chocolate at the bottom of my waffle cone. I ate every bite. Would highly recommend! Also--cash only! ❤️
Andy Davies
A great little ice cream and milkshakes. An easy 5 star rating
ShownLettuce430
oh wow, that milkshake was amazing. Would recommend if you’re nearby
Allie Turner
Delicious ice cream!! We got milkshakes and ice cream bars and they were some of the best we’ve ever had. We talked with the owner and he was extremely nice and personable. Would 10/10 recommend!
Matthew Liptak
With the tons of choices of ice cream on the Cape you may miss a place like this. This spot sits in downtown Chatham and is near the end of the town. The ice cream is creamy and they have tons of flavors and waffle cones. The staff is friendly and it hits the spot, however the prices are a bit extreme for Cape Cod and surprisingly high. Overall though great flavors and great tasting.
Arwen L
I love the variety of flavors here! Nice place to stop by especially as the weather warms up!
Jacin Diletizia
Rude staff
Liz Des Cognets Champagne
Best Peanutbutter ice cream EVER
100 Chicken Chow Mein 101 Shrimp Chow Mein 13 Fried Pork Dumpling 6 18 Bean Curd w Eggplant Alfredo Shrimp Spicy Pasta All American Burger Aperol Spritz Apple pie Arancini Arnold Palmer Bacon Egg and Cheese on a Roll Bacon Egg and Cheese on Rye Bagel Bagels Baja Fish Tacos Bakery Banana Cream Pie Bananas Foster Bass BBQ Chicken Bean Sprouts Beantown Buzz Mud Pie Beef Beef Beef Negimaki App Beef Negimaki Teriyaki Beer Big Boy Burger Biscotti Black Tea Blackened Fish Tacos and French Fries BLT blt Salad Blueberry Muffin Blueberry Pancakes Bolognese Bouillabaisse Braised Short Rib Bread and Almonds Bread Pudding Breakfast Burrito Breakfast Salad Breakfast Sandwich Bruschetta Buffalo Wings Burger Burrito Burrito Bowl Butternut Squash Pizza BYO Breakfast Sandwich caesar salad Cajun Shrimp Platter Cakes Calamares Calamari California Roll California Roll Cannoli Carbonara Carpaccio Carrot Cake Carrot Cake Challah French Toast Cheeseburger Cheesecake Cheesecakes Chicken and Waffles Chicken Caesar Wrap Chicken Parmesan Sandwich Chicken Ranch Sandwich Chicken Sandwich Chicken Taco and Pork Taco Chicken Wings Chicken with Broccoli Chicken Wontons Chili Chili Nachos Chocolate ice cream Chowder Cinnamon roll Cioppino Cioppino Clam Chowder Clams Classic Benedict Classic Lobster Roll Cobb Salad Coconut & Avocado Soup GF •DF •V Cod Cod Sandwich Coffee Oreo Cold Lobster Roll with French Fries and Cole Slaw Coral Mojito Corn and Black Bean Corn Soup Corned Beef Corned Beef Hash Corned Beef Sloppy Joe Cornish Game Hen Cotton Candy Crab Crab Benedict Crab Cake Crab Cake Topped with Baja Slaw Pineapple Salsa and Cilantro Crab Cake Warm Lobster Roll Crepes Crispy Duck Spring Rolls croissant Cuban Panini Curry Diced Chicken with Cashew Nuts Dim Sum Disco Fries Duck Duck breast Dumplings Eel Avocado Cucumber Eggplant Eggplant Miso Eggplant Spicy Galic Sauce Eggs Benedict Eggs Benedict and Homefries Escargot Escovitch and Festival Escovitch Fish Espresso Falafel Fettuccine and Clams Filet Mignon Firecracker Beef Fish Fish & Chips Fish & Chips Fish and Chips Fish Sandwich Fish Sandwich Fish Soup Fish Taco Fisherman's Platter Foie gras Four C's Sandwich French Dip French Fries French Toast Fresca Fresh Coffee Fresh Fruit Fresh Mozzarella with Tomato and Basil Fried Artichokes Fried Banana Fried calamari Fried Chicken Sandwich Fried Clams Fried Clams Fried Cod Fried Rice Vegetable Shrimp-Chicken Habachi Fried Scallops and Lobster Roll Fried shrimp Fried Shrimp Basket with Fries Fries Poutine Fritto Misto Frozen Maker's Mark Lemonade Frozen Yogurt Fruit Plate Gazpacho Gelato Gluten Free Lasagna Gnocchi Goose Lobster Bisque Grandma Pizza Granola Great Shrimp and Vegetable Tempora Grilled 16oz Rib-Eye Steak Grilled Asparagus Grilled cheese Grilled Chicken Ranch Grilled Chicken with Brie Fresh Beets & Fresh Fruit Grilled Neapolitan Style Pizza Margherita Grilled octopus Grilled Statler Chicken Breast Haddock Halibut Hamburger Hamburger and Fries Hamburgers Home Fries Homemade Sauce hot chocolate Hot Fudge Hot Lobster Roll House Special Mixed Delight Huevos Rancheros Hummus Ice Cream Ice Cream Ice Cream Two Scoop ice tea Iced tea Impossible Burger Italian Hot Dog Jalapeño Burger Jerk Chicken Combo Meal Jerk pork Juice Juice & Smoothies Jumbo Shrimp with Black Bean Sauce Just Got Serious Key lime pie Kids Chicken Tenders with French Fries Kids Grilled Cheese Lake Tung Ting Shrimp Lamb chops Lasagne Lemon Meringue Pie Linguini N' Clams Lobster Lobster Benedict Lobster Nachos Lobster Roll Lobster Roll Lobster Roll and Clam Chowder Love Boat for Two Lumpia Lumpia Mac and cheese Macaroni and Cheese Mai Tai Maine Lobster Ravioli Manhattan Margarita Margaritas Martini Meat Lovers Pizza Meatballs Meatloaf Meringue Milkshake Mitsuba Roll Mixed Green Salad moscow mule Mussels Mussels in Miso Broth Nabe Yaki Udon Nachos Nachos with Chili NE Clam Chowder New England Cod Noodle Octopus Omelette Onion Over Easy Egg on Toast with a Side of Sausage Links Oxtail Oyster Oyster Pad Thai Paella Pan Seared Scallops and Roasted Chatham Littleneck Clam Chowdah Pancakes Pancakes Paneer Panettone Panna Cotta Pascarella Special Sub Pasta Pastrami Pepper Jack Cheese Pepperoni Sausage Pizza Philly Cheese Steak Piña colada Pistachio Muffin Polenta Popovers Pork Belly Sisit Taco Porridge Oats Cornmeal Carrot Vanilla Cinnamon Portuguese Muffin with Egg Meat Cheese Praline French Toast Special Profiteroles Prosciutto Pulled Pork Pumpkin Pumpkin & Apple Soup GF•DF•V Quiche Raisin French Toast with Fruit Ranch Chicken Sandwich Red Stripe Ribs Rice and beans Risotto Risotto of the Day Roast Beef Roasted Salmon and Sea Scallops Rolls Set Salad Salad Salmon Sandwich with Fries Sandwiches Sauteed Chatham Mussels Scallion Pancakes Scallops Scallops Scallops with Mushrooms & Snow Peas Scorpion Bowl Seafood Bouillabaisse Seafood Platters Seaweed Salad Sesame Falafel Wrap Shashuka Shredded Beef in Peking Sauce Shrimp Shrimp and Grits Shrimp and Vegetable Tempura Shrimp Chips Shrimp Scampi over Risotto Shrimp Tacos Side Sweet Sour Sauce Single Waffle Cone Siopao Cheeseburger Smoked Strawberry Margarita Spicy Chicken Tacos Squash Statler Chicken Steak and Eggs Steamed Local Mussels Steamers Strawberries Gazpacho Strawberry daiquiri Strawberry Shortcake Waffle Surf And Turf Sushi & Sashimi Combo for Two Sweet Potato Sword Fish Tacos Swordfish Swordfish and Feta Spinach Risotto Swordfish Tacos with Mango Quinoa Salad Tacos Tapas Taylor Ham Egg & Cheese spk Aka the Hangover Helper Taylor Ham Egg Cheese Sandwich Tempura Tempura Soft Shell Crab & Vegetable App Tiramisu Tiramisu Martini and Chocolate Martini Toasts Todays Selection of Fresh Shucked Oysters Tomato Hummus Tonkotsu Ramen with Scallops Tortellini Tortelloni Tortillas Traditional Greek Salad Tres Leches Cake Triple Chocolate Brownie Tuna Tuna Melt Tuna Poke Bowl Tuna Sliders Turkey Club Sandwich Turkey Panini Turkey Wrap Vada pav Veggie Burger Waffle and Gelato Waffles Wasabi Shumai Watermelon Margarita Wings Wonton soup Zuppa Di Pesce
Share on WhastApp
Share on Facebook
Browse the menu
Add review