Highly recommend! The staff was very knowledgeable and the cake was everything I expected it to be. Flavors and design were spot on!
We had a WONDERFUL display of many flavors of mini cupcakes for our wedding! It was delicious and beautiful. I love that Sarah's has TONS of flavor options, and it was so much fun to have those at the wedding! We also had some to-die-for cake pops. Having basically sampled everything at this bakery, I can confidently recommend their sweets and services!
I mean, really?!?! HOW do they get these incredible little cake balls to be SO moist?!? I have never been a fan of cake balls/pops until I tasted Sarah's at an event. Usually, cake pops are covered with too much frosting that is usually hard. Sarah's are the perfect cake to icing ratio with a soft outer "shell". They've truly perfected cake balls! Both the chocolate and vanilla are delicious! On top of that, I received great customer service from a friendly, helpful gentlemen when I went in to purchase some delicious treats yesterday! They also had a lot of adorable themed treats! I will definitely be back! :-)
Sarah's recently provided the desserts for my wedding, besides our wedding cake being spectacular in design, it tasted delicious. My sister took extra cake home and her roomates said it was the best and moistest cake they had ever had, and this was 3 days after our wedding. Sarah's made a dessert bar at our wedding with beautiful mini cupcakes that were complete with hand-painted peacock feathers, their glitter balls are out of this world, and their cakes are ridiculously good. My guests loved all the desserts and I will continue to use Sarah's in the future for any dessert need my husband and I have, I highly recommend them.
I just had your coffee and donut cupcake last night at Randall Gallery at a wedding. This was the best cupcake I've ever tasted. It was so moist and flavorful. Your icing was soft, but also held the Donut ball on top. Each bite was better that the last. I'm not usually a cake eater, but this was simply amazing!
I love this place! Great food, incredible service by a friendly staff, and the most amazing glitter bites await your visit!
Can't thank them enough for the fabulous sheet cake they made for our colleagues retirement party. It was delicious cake and the best frosting and the decoration was perfect and just what we wanted. I hope to do business again with them in the future.
Sarah’s is the best! I got married in June and Sarah’s made the cupcakes, boozie bites and a six inch cake (for me and my husband to cut). The price for all we had ordered for our reception was very reasonable and worked great for our budget. The staff is always friendly and the cupcakes....mmmmmmm! That’s the only way I can express it!
The best cake place ever! Love the wedding cake. All the other stuff that I've tried is also divine. I don't think you can go wrong with whatever you order from there.
Favorite bakery hands down! Have been going there since they opened. Even after moving to Phoenix, I love stopping in and getting their chocolate cake slices and cupcakes!
I LOVE them!! I go to the one in Eureka and even though I live in Illinois I make this a weekly treat on my day off to myself!!! The staff is awesome and so sweet!!! I take a couple boxes of treats home with me every time I visit!!! My favorites are the quiche (sweet onion �) but I normally take one of each flavor home, Glitter bites, and The Central Muffin!!!! I'm seriously in LOVE!!!! Everyone just has to try them!!!!!
We used Sarah's Cake Shop for our wedding this past weekend. They were perfect and soo easy to work with! Each interaction we had with them was positive. Our tasting was fun and they had it all down to a science. The day of our wedding they delivered on time and were so helpful. I had made a few changes in between our tasting and wedding and they rolled with the changes like it was nothing. The best part, everyone at our wedding LOVED the cake and cupcakes! Thank you so much!
We had a dessert reception catered by Sarah's Cake Shop and it was amazing. Everyone loves the desserts and we did too!
We recently stopped by the shop again to celebrate our anniversary with some treats and it, again, did not disappoint. The biggest surprise was their gooey butter cake. It could possibly be the best Gooey Butter that I've had.
We weren't the biggest fan of their cake. It is light and fluffy, but leaves something to be desired. I've not tried their cupcakes however, and would like to give them a try the next time we're around.
Nice laid back atmosphere. Staff is very welcoming and friendly. Great sandwiches. Price and proportions are great!
Friendly staff! Highly suggest the key lime glitter balls! I prefer the cake balls over the cupcakes
Great seating, friendly staff and delicious smooth coffee! Bonus is that it’s handicapped accessible and tons of outlets for working on your computer
We had a WONDERFUL display of many flavors of mini cupcakes for our wedding! It was delicious and beautiful. I love that Sarah's has TONS of flavor options, and it was so much fun to have those at the wedding! We also had some to-die-for cake pops. Having basically sampled everything at this bakery, I can confidently recommend their sweets and services!
Sarah's Cake Shop created an absolutely beautiful cake for a bridal shower using the bride's colors. The cake was the hit of the party....not only beautiful but also delicious. A big thank you to the bakers and the decorators! Exceptional job! I highly recommend Sarah's Cake Shop. I told everyone at the shower. We have 2 more brides in the group, expect more customers Sarah.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes