First time customer and I’m very happy! Ordering in person was super easy. Everyone was really nice and helpful. The cake came out beautiful and looked just like the photo I provided when ordering, and it tasted great! Definitely ordering again!
For the last year I have trusted Reuter’s with my family & dog special birth milestones. Their cakes are so delicious and they always impress me with their details. The last cake ordered was for my grandfathers 90th bday and he was so overwhelmed there were tears of joy! Thanks to Estrella for taking this particular order and noting down my request. Customer service is the key to bring in business and she assisted in executing this request perfectly. Thanks to any other associate who made or had any part of these orders!
I had the best experience with the bakery and the sweet woman that took my order. I brought in a picture of what I wanted for my sons birthday,and they nailed it!!!. The cake was so delicious and completely exceeded my expectations. We have found our new bakery.
I went in a week before my daughter's birthday and was able to get a cake ordered just in time. Service was fast and friendly. We were absolutely in love with the cake.
Very fast paced bakery. The ladies are lovely, never have a negative experience here. My gender reveal cake was worth it, exactly how it looked in the picture. They accept EBT which is great.
BEST bakery I’ve ever been to. My friend told me about this bakery about 8 years ago and I go here for ALL KINDS OF CAKES😋They have messed my cakes up at least twice but it was fixed and I was pleased!!!! I have referred hundreds of people here. I should get HALF-OFF my on cakes from now on😩😊
My family has been going here for years... They never disappoint... Did a phenomenal job on my daughters Toy Story cake... I highly recommend them
Two cakes in one month, wow what a celebration, one cake was pineapple the other strawberries. Their whip cream and butter cream were perfect very tasty. Cakes were delicious and moist, great price. I tip my hat thank you and will refer others to buy. Thank you for making our days enjoyable. Woo hoo
We ordered custom cookies from Reuter's and we couldn't've be happier!! They came out better then we thought and boy oh boy they were delicious and everyone raved about them and they melted in my mouth, I knew Reuter's was a class A bakery, I will ALWAYS use Reuter's for all my upcoming Holiday parties!! Thank you, thank you, thank you Reuter's you are #1 :)
Came back for a second cake, this time it was a simple smash cake and it was perfection! The confetti decorations were super cute but some of the pieces had to be removed before I could let the little one have at it. I did also get some of their amazing yellow and chocolate cupcakes but they seemed to be a little bit dry. Still everything is well worth it. Great prices, easy people to work with and the quality of the baked goods is splendid!!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes