Where to start? From the minute you walk through the door, it is like being home. Jerry, Brandy and their daughter Molly are wonderful hosts and are quick to make you feel welcome.
Wander up to the counter and order some of the best food in Indiana! Coffee, treats and hardy foods are all awaiting your approval. Bring a healthy appetite, the portions are generous and delicious!
The coffee and coffee drinks are top shelf with 4 different brewed coffees available and gourmet, hand crafted coffee delights for your taste buds to dance with.
5 stars plus extra credit of 1 star for being so darn friendly!
Brandy and Jerry serve up vegan deliciousness. Super friendly - made a special request dish for me that was stupendous. Love the art by RodMan on the walls. Can’t wait to get back up there
The tofu scramble and (vegan) pancakes we're both the best I've ever had of each. Vegan sausage patties will make you a believer. Biscuits and gravy we're great too. Solid portions, good prices, friendly staff! We will be going back regularly despite the 40-minute drive. UNREAL!!
When you travel much, you are lucky to find those kinds of places for which you make a special, mental note to never miss if ever visiting in the area again. The Cicero Coffee Company is that place. If you miss the opportunity to eat there, you have done yourself a great disservice. I recommend the Tayler Wrap made with tofu bacon and absolute magic.
It's home. The people, the drinks, the food, and the atmosphere are like home(maybe even better)! Haha Earl and Cindy have created a comfortable place to kick back and enjoy a nice breakfast/lunch in our small, quaint town.
Went for the first time and got an iced chai with the vegan rosemary biscuits and gravy with and a cinnamon roll. I was only sad I didn't have room to try the tofu bacon BLT �.
Tried for the first time today and was not let down! So unbelievably nice people with calm yet cool coffee shop with TONS of vegan options. Go early!!
The vegan Reuben was legit, had it with the chocolate orange coffee and will certainly be returning to try all the other vegan options �
Plenty of vegan options, great atmosphere. My new favorite place!
The bee's knees. The Cat's meow. Absolutely amazing staff with food and coffee that will keep you coming back for life.
Very good coffee and breakfast. The kind of small business you love to support ... The staff was very friendly too! Vegan menu available.
Carol Serensky Spencer
+5
Thanks Brandy & Molly for sharing the delicious yummy vegan Lil' Bits cookies with me this morning - they are so delicious � !!
Great food, a little pricey, one of the few places to do a pickle correctly when you order a sandwich to go "wrapped in parchment paper so it doesn't make the bread soggy" iced chai tea are good here.
3/16/21 Had the same traditional club still great and they still wrap the pickle in parchment so it doesn't make the bread soggy.
The name and outside look of this restaurant (the coffee is fine, but have no illusions; the food is the main attraction here) might not scream "You gotta try this," but once you've sampled the breakfasts, you will probably agree that Cicero Coffee Company is the hippest place in town. In a good way.
The baked oatmeal is yummy; the breakfast burrito is yummy; the omelettes are also yummy. If you don't like your bacon very crispy, you might want to say something like "Not too crispy please" when you order. The atmosphere is inviting and the wall art elicits conversation. You'll pay more here for breakfast than you would at a fast food place, but I'd say the vibe here is worth it, though that is a subjective call of course.
Great little coffee shop that has been around for awhile. Baked oatmeal is my personal favorite (even though I'm usually a bacon and eggs guy). Also plenty of vegan options as well.
I ordered the vegan biscuits and gravy — it was delicious! I was very pleased by all of the vegan options available that this cafe. The staff was incredibly friendly as well. I brought my dog to sit with me outdoors. We had a lovely morning
Awesome, awesome, awesome vegan menu. Best pancakes I've ever eaten, they make their own sausage, and the tofu scramble is excellent. We drive 40 minutes to get here and it's worth it. Friendly staff/owners, can't say enough good about this place. (There's a big menu of non-vegan stuff too, but why bother?)
This is the best place in Indiana for vegan breakfast! I tell everyone one about it. A true diamond in the rough. Worth the drive. They have meat options as well. And every Wednesday night they open back up at 5 or 6pm for all vegan dinner with a different special every Wednesday!
A little hidden secret...... my daughter asked me to come with her to have lunch so I did. I was a little shocked to hear they have a vegan menu. The food took awhile to make, which is normal for vegan food, but it was so good. The staff was very pleasant and they have a little patio you can go outside and eat. Really nice!!!
This is the absolute best place to go for breakfast and a cup of coffee. My wife and I make it up from Greenwood (over an hour away) about once a month. No one does it better. It is such a fantastic place. Not the biggest, not the fastest, but you will realize quickly that it is the best and they have created something truly unique. The Cindy Loo Hoo's Smothered Eggs or The Dave Special are our personal favorites. You can't go wrong with anything on their menu. Don't miss out!
Small hometown coffee company. Absolutely amazing place to go. Everything is so fresh. The owners are wonderful people who really get to know the locals. I travel all over the U.S. & can compare thier coffee to what you could find in Seattle and California bistros. The food is amazing. Fresh made to order with lots of options, prices are not bad. Local artist have work all over this place. It's very clean & a lot of natural light comes in from the bay window out front. Outdoor seating available that is covered. It's located on the main strip in town, so you see everything. I've lived here 20 years, & there's never been a slow day at this place. Worth the visit, get there early and check out the front food case full of fresh baked bagels, cinnamon rolls, & other treats which almost always sell out by days end.
The vegan food is to die for. I’ve ordered every single thing on that menu. The tofu scramble is the greatest scramble EVER. The only reason it has 4 stars is they are CONSTANTLY changing their hours. Twice I have come and the hours are different. Disappointed in that
My wife and I drive here from Tipton at least twice a week. The coffee and food are fantastic (love the vegan menu), but the vibe is just as important. Everyone is so friendly, and there’s always great music playing (listening to Grateful Dead right now). We’ll be coming here for years to come!
The decor is country kitchen, not my taste but still nice. The staff is very friendly. I loved their Reuben. Everyone said that Erika's place was great but I had a horrible experience there. Happy to see that there is a good place to eat in Cicero.
Cicero Coffee Company is one of those special places you'll keep wanting to come back to time, and again. Great coffee, friendly service, wonderful food items; it's all the best combination of small-town independent coffee shop with all the amenities, art gallery, and cafe with delicious appetite-quenching breakfast and lunch options. Be sure to consider the Cindy Loo Hoo Smothered Eggs and a bottomless cup of coffee.
Robert “Bopper Indy” Koehne
+5
Coffee was excellent. Our 1st visit for breakfast and my wife and I enjoyed. Very tasty and reasonably priced. Will visit again.
The food was very tasty and the portion sizes were good. The staff was very friendly and helpful. The restaurant was clean and tidy. It sounds like there are quite a few regulars that they know by name!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes