My page
Exit
×
×
Reset
There are 8 restaurants
Cuisine
Dietary restrictions
Meals
Structure
Dishes
Home
Restaurants in Cicero
Italian cuisine: the best places to taste it in Cicero
There are 8 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Sapori By Antonio
95
/100 (454 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Vegan Options
American
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Pasta
Salad
Shrimp
Sit down
American
Pizza
Italian
Serves Alcohol
Delivery
Takeout
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Sapori is my go-to spot every time I'm in the Cicero area. The pizza is phenomenal (especially the cheese pizza) and every pasta dish I've tried has..."
Adam Arpa
"10/10 Highly recommend!! Absolutely love everything about this place! The food, the service, literally everything was amazing. We knew it was a hit..."
Chels Nicole
"First time visitors. As we often drive through rt31, we happened to spot this very small, tucked in the middle of a nearly empty plaza, pizza..."
Robert Sames
"Great food and service. I got a box of pizza for take out, which was Antonio's favorite pizza...."
Henry Dankert
"Just realized that this place was still opened but moved locations! Got the grandmas pizza slice and a knot just as fresh and tasty as I remembered!..."
rachel rasmussen
"Fantastic Italian food, service, and atmosphere! Would definitely be back, and I recommend trying it if you’re in the area and in the mood for..."
AJ
"As we are at the end of our Great Lent and abstaining from meat the only place where I could try something in Vegetarian was Sapori by Antonio with a..."
Shabu Mathew
"We stopped here by chance when travelling. The food was wonderful--my wife and I each had pasta dishes--and family that owns it were amazingly kind..."
Sean Kistler
"LOVE LOVE LOVE, Gramma's pizza, some of the best pizza I've ever had! Owners very nice and pleasant..."
Terry Desantis
"Amazing food! Would recommend the chicken parm. Angel hair pasta and chicken cooked great and sauce was very..."
Joseph Akiki
"Order garlic pizza with ricotta cheese - you won't be disappointed! The best pizza place in the area in my opinion. Also, I ordered an antipasto..."
J W
"Worth the wait after being seated at the time of our reservation. Slow service due to limited staff. Staff is pleasant and attentive. Food was..."
Sam Pearlstein
"Awesome dishes and service. The wife and I had Farfelle Dolce Vita, and the Chicken Parm. Fastastic meals. We will be visiting them..."
Sidney Kaine
"I really like this place and they have some awesome pizza. However, ive gotten 2 pies since they moved locations and they are completely different ?..."
joseph sicherman
"We went here for the first time a couple of weeks ago, and we both really enjoyed our meal. My wife was excited for her leftovers, which usually she..."
Matt Stone
"This place has the best garlic pizza I've had in my life I come here every week on one of my days off because they are so good great service friendly..."
Sean Cowart
"His Pizza is the Best but so is his Riggies but so is his Antipasta....The..."
Randie Hughes
"Went on a Friday night without a reservation(Highly recommend) and they fit us in. Very simple yet nice atmosphere, staff was very friendly and the..."
Thomas Newton
"Great food and lots of it! Had enough for 2 dinners with one order of chicken parmigiana with penne. Staff friendly and..."
Cynthia
Delullo's Trattoria
94
/100 (591 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Meatballs
Lasagne
Pesto
Pasta
Salad
Sit down
Italian
Takeout
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Highchairs Available
Dinner
Mid-range
"Best thing I've ever stuffed in my mouth- the oh so amazing sweet garlic bread from the bruschetta. If you come here... without hesitation, you MUST..."
Quynhmy Raley
"What a gem! The food is absolutely wonderful. The bread sticks are best I have ever eaten. The Alfredo sauce is to die for. It is definitely..."
Kim Pottenger
"What a adorable and friendly group of new friends! From the moment you walk into this home renovated into an Italian bistro you can see the care and..."
Mandy Tosh
"The food was amazing...YUM! They had great gluten free options and a good wine menu! The staff was amazing as well. Can't wait to go..."
Christy Campbell Conaway
"Amazing food this evening, straight from the farm. The Mangalitsa ravioli was absolutely delightful. Enjoyed the conversations with the chefs and the..."
Kelli J. Huth
"Met friends for dinner here last night and was super excited with our experience. The atmosphere was charming, the food was delicious, and the staff..."
Lynn Williams
"We had the special, mahi mahi, this weekend. It was one of the best meals we've had at a restaurant! The staff and owners are so friendly. It is a..."
Keilah Schmicker
"Where do I even begin? If you're looking for a place to go on a romatic date or just with your family for dinner DeLullo's is a great place to do..."
Elizabeth Proffitt
"Excellent Service - Quality Food - Very Accommodating. I called the owner - Jama Fernung to inquire about a private event on a Sunday and she was..."
Sean Michael McCormack
"We went on a whim because we were starving after unpacking (new to Cicero 👋🏻.) We had excellent service from Abby. She gave great..."
Mallery Apple
"I took my family there this weekend and it was AWESOME!! I got the sea scallops which I highly recommend. The tour was a large portion and so was the..."
Bryce Garman
"We have been here many times, and are never disappointed....great food and wonderful service always! I had the lobster Mac and cheese this time, and..."
Kim Spence-Bollinger
"Absolutely love this place, amazing food!! And great service, telling all my friends and co-workers about this place to check..."
Rob Dye
"The food was fantastic! A very warm and inviting place. Service was very friendly. We will absolutely be back to try another..."
Autumn Jacobs
"Best Italian food I have ever eaten. Everything is made from scratch and fresh. Nothing is spared on this fine authentic Italian cuisine. Reasonably..."
Craig Bryant
"Fantastic food, friendly staff highly..."
Lynda Willingham
"Loved everything about this place. Great staff and food was delicious. We will return very..."
Amy Jester Murphy
"Nice little family-owned Italian place. It's always great to have a go-to Italian restaurant other than Olive Garden. Food is good, nothing super..."
Thomas Brackett III
"First time visiting. We really enjoyed eating on the back deck. Cocktails and appetizers were very good as was our dinners. Staff was really..."
charles dale
"Food was all made in house, including the pasta. By far the best price for such good food. Service was excellent and had no problem accommodating us..."
Joshua Stewart
"When most Americans think of Italian food, the comfort foods from Napoli and Sicilia generally come to mind: spaghetti with meatballs or sausage,..."
Cherrie. L
"The DeLullo's pizza was outstanding. Food delivery was very slow. Our waiter seemed busy elsewhere. Water glasses were not refilled. Had to ask a..."
R.W. P.
"Dined outside in a large group of 10. Very good food at reasonable prices. Wait staff very attentive and efficient. Not crowded for a Saturday night..."
E dawg
"All of our dinners were fantastic! Fairly priced, casual yet nice, above-and-beyond service, and (expected) large Italian portions. Will be..."
Kris Deutsch
"Great food! Every meal I’ve had there has been outstanding. Best pesto sauce I’ve EVER..."
John Gilmore Songs (John Gilmore Music)
"Everything was so delicious, service was great, the prices were great, large portions and a very nice atmosphere. I regret not trying DeLullo’s..."
Jennifer Egan
"A favorite of ours. Food is always on point, service is awesome. Atmosphere is cozy and..."
Douglas Overmyer
"Great small restaurant. Brunch was amazing. We tried several dishes. Fried green tomato BLT was awesome, had just the right amount of italian..."
Jeramy Madlung
"One of my favorite places to go and unwind , the food is consistently delicious, and everyone goes above and beyond to make your experience..."
Kindra Tragesser
"Great time celebrating a birthday with friends today! Food was amazing. Don't forget to make a reservation. Fills up fast. Highly recommend..."
Adrienne Rogers
"So overall we had a very good experience while dining. The restaurant has been converted from an old house and was very warm and welcoming. It..."
Benjamin Bryant
"Oh my goodness, first time at DeLullo's this week. Went on a Friday evening, about 530 pm and ate indoors. Service was quick, portions were huge, and..."
Dan Y
"Two visits with several friends and only positive comments! We were fortunate to have a wonderful server named Shannon who could not have been..."
MPT
"Can't say enough great things about this place! Had the pizza that was very good. Last time I got pizza here it was not good at all. That was two..."
Media Manley
"Start off with some great bread sticks, they are homemade, and brick oven cooked, the salads are amazing, you can't go wrong with any of them. Then..."
Craig Owens
Freddy's Pizzeria
90
/100 (6465 ratings)
Quick Bites
Specialty Food Market
Pizza
Italian
Deli
Pizza
Deli
Vegetarian Friendly
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Chicken parmigiana
Salad
Salami Salad
Meatball Sandwich
Risotto
Deli Meats
Artichoke Hearts
Italian Sub
Meatballs
Lasagne
Chicken Limone
Watermelon Italian Ice
Ice Cream
Sandwiches
Chicken Vesuvio
Gelato
Butter Pecano
Pesto
Beef
Italian Beef Sandwich W
Pizza
Italian Sandwiches
Lasagna
Calzones
Breaded Pork Sandwich
Seafood salad
Eggplant
Eggplant Parmiggiana
Marsala
Fast food
Pizza
Italian
Deli
Seating
Parking Available
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
Vicinos Brick & Brew
90
/100 (562 ratings)
Restaurants
Pub
Pizza
Bar
Italian
Pub
Brew Pub
Pizza
American
Italian
Brew Pub
American
Bar
Dinner
Lunch
Salad
Burger
Sit down
American
Brew Pub
Bar
Pub
Pizza
Italian
Takeout
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"We stopped for some leisurely drinks and apps on the patio before dropping friends off at the airport. Avianna was our waitress and she did an..."
D. Ross
"I came here Saturday evening with my dad, and we were sat quickly, and our server was very friendly and helpful. They have a good tap list here with..."
Attilio Lospinoso
"Great pizzas and Beer selection. Staff is always super nice. Plus they have Deep fried..."
Ron Carey Santangelo
"We stopped in for a quick bite mid week. Little did we know it was Trivia Tuesday! How fun!! We were on a bit of a limited schedule, so we just ate,..."
Colleen Kimble
"We spent a FANTASTIC afternoon at Brick and Brew in Cicero for the Sunday Brunch. They had 20+ local beers on tap and offered flights. The food was a..."
Shark Man
"Pizza was incredible!! Wife got the prosciutto & arugula and I got double pepperoni. Pizzas were..."
Dave C
"This was my 1st time here and I can't stop raving about my experience. From Kelly our server to Kathi the owner. The variety in the menu's, my food..."
Kennidyann Galloway
"Nice atmosphere, decent food, several beers to choose from and live entertainment. Our waitress was really friendly and accommodating. FYI - if you..."
Laura LaPorta
"Went back again and the drinks were waiting for us when we walked in!!! M remembered. That is OUTSTANDING service. Thank you!! I travel for work so..."
Jason Ricker
"Brick and Brew is one of the best local spots I can think of. The staff and owners are super friendly and supportive. They gave a free gift card to..."
Eric O'Mara
"I really appreciate Meghan for the awesome service and pizza creations. Service was spectacular and friendly. Food was the best pizza around hands..."
Drew Nelipowitz
"Updating my review! The food is delicious and the service is excellent. Friendly atmosphere, prepare for music (playing over speakers or live bands),..."
Stephen Mitchell
"We had a very good dining experience at Vicinos. The chicken wings were lightly crispy and large. The Capone pizza was really good with plenty of..."
Thomas Hayduk
"#FirstTimers Absolutely amazed Staff was ONPOINT #HAILEY shows such commitment and compassion for her customers. She truly goes above and beyond. ..."
Toni Vadala
"We shared a couple of pizzas, some amazing wings, and few cold Fiddleheads for an early Father's Day dinner at the Brick and Brew last night. As is..."
Tim Brown
"Brick and Brew is the real deal. The burgers are juicy, the pizza is cooked to perfection in their brick oven, and the service is top-notch. I mean,..."
Jerry Schavone
"Buffalo Chicken wrap was very spicy but good! Cajun fries were also very..."
austin diana
"Phenomenal food reasonable prices, and fun atmosphere (we sat outside under the string lights, inside is a sports bar feel and not my..."
Acacia Jones
Paladino's Cicero Pizza
85
/100 (861 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Wings
Salad
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Gift Cards Available
Delivery
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"This is the best pizza in central New York! I have going to the latest location since it opened. Paladino's pizza has been a family must for..."
Todd
"My Go To Pizza Place. Absolutlely love this place! Their pizza is hands down the best pizza in the area. Their customer service is better than..."
Nateman8818
"I adore this pizza. Among all the pizza places in the area, this is the only one I crave, and I'm happy they opened a Cicero location. It's..."
Lindsey
"I love going into Paladino's!! The food is superb and the service couldn't be any better (especially that dashing young counter guy on weekends)...."
SB96
"Always accommodating! If it's not on the menu, ask! I've used Paladino's for a few CNS school events and they have never disappointed! When 30 plus..."
Annette
"So good.... We were in town from ottawa for the weekend and found this spot off Urbanspoon...the reviews were so right! Awesome wings, best pizza and..."
JoBed
"Best pizza..."
Amanda
"Awesome pizza, delicious wings....AND they deliver? Yep. Oh and I hear you're going to be open on Sundays now too...perfect for the games! We order a..."
Casey Heick
"Paladinos is by far the best pizza around! There ingredients are always fresh and there pizzas, wings calzones, salads are awesome! They always put..."
Lindsay Miller
"I have been eating their pizza since they opened in Mattydale over 30 years ago. Best pizza ever! So glad they are now in..."
Kevin
"Awesome food! When I order pizza it's always this place. The wings are the best too! They always make them crispy and..."
Sarah
"Outstanding Food. Paladino's is the place to go when you want great food for a great price. Whether you are going for pizza and wings, or eggplant..."
Cindy A.
"Best New York Style Pizza in CNY. So I grew up on Paladino's in Mattydale and always loved it. When Paladin's Cicero opened I thought, could it be?..."
Jason
"MMMmmmm. My favorite pizza place of all time. You have to try their thin crust extra cheese pizza..."
S. Anderson
"YUMMY YUMMY IN MY TUMMY. Best pizza I've ever tasted..."
Scout
"Yum Yum!. Real New York Style Pizza. Crispy crust that is thin but not to much that it gets soggy. Wonderful sauce , cheese and other ingredients..."
Bill M
"Pie-Licious!. I'm a pizzaholic...I've tried probably a sampling of the majority of pizza parlors in the Upstate NY area and while many of them were..."
AJ Knight
"My family loves Paladino's Cicero Pizza. It's the best pizza in town! We've tried others and no one delivers a consistently great product no matter..."
Monica Byrne
"The best pizza in town!!! The crispy crust can't be beat!!! Love us some..."
Shanna
"Best pizza in Syracuse, hands down! The owner is also very friendly and helpful! Can't go wrong with..."
Jackie
"This is the best pizza in syracuse by a mile I have gone to Paladinos mattydale location for 15 years so happy they are in Cicero now! Dan..."
Dan Mulpagano
"Incredible pizza and wings keep up the good..."
Jeffd
"I’ve gone here for years and never reviewed because I never really think about voicing my opinion but I decided to finally. As a long time customer..."
Caden Dambach
"Best pizza I’ve had in over 40 years! We’re just passing through and the desk clerk at the hotel recommended this for delivery. We were not..."
Bev Nichols
"Today was something really exciting that happened to me as I saw the time was closer to 8 pm and had doubt if they would pick the order, to my..."
Shabu Mathew
"Delicious Pizza, Great Personal service. Very clean and a nice family atmosphere, with plenty of seating. Myself and my Daughter really enjoyed our..."
Bill Sutorius
"Best chicken wing pizza I have ever tasted. I couldn't resist and took a bite before taking a picture. 2nd time and quality is as good as the 1st..."
Hanny Almagrabi
"Literally my favorite pizza place in Syracuse! This place is clean and the food is amazing. Huge deal to me. This place is usually swamped (great..."
Linda Hawley
"My experience with them was very good. Their pizza is a traditional NY style pizza the crust is good and thin, but not cracker crunchy thin, and the..."
WildBill 1989
"This was our first time ordering their "everything" wing sauce, and will definitely not be our last! The sauce was delicious and the wings were..."
Jackie Woods
"Sooo good!! Pizza was amazing, dough was perfect. Boneless wings - top 5 I’ve ever had. Garlic Knots - fantastic! Cool inside, great air..."
Andrew Proctor
"Traveling through New York, we stopped here for dinner. Staff was very friendly, even though I had four young children in town. Really made us feel..."
Regina Richter Lagha
Paisans Pizzeria & Bar
84
/100 (1183 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Pizza
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Delivery
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Cicero Country Pizza
84
/100 (733 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Chicken Cacciatore
Wings
Tater Tots
Wings
Fried Dough
Super Cheese Calzone
Happy Birthday Mom
Salad
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"We ordered tonight after not ordering from there in a while. Everything was Perfect! The fried cauliflower can't be beat, the fried dough was amazing..."
Jennifer George
"Pizza was very good (filling with thick cheese, yet still thin enough overall to be considered New York style) , but what made this a wonderful..."
Jason Borges
"I stopped by myself after shopping at Walmart hadn’t been here in years but I remember it was very good . I came in and was seated quickly the..."
Douglas
"We were in town for a few days for a local event and discovered this restaurant. Pizza was delicious and cooked to perfection , we also ordered a..."
Marco Cannon
"I have NEVER left a review before but after our experience here, I must! Not one part of our experience was less than perfection. Portion sizes..."
Emily DeFazio
"Great food and friendly staff, been going there for a long long time. 1 of the few places that have anchovies. My wife loves the eggplant dinner ..."
michael truax
"Omg..the simple small chef salad was delicious.service was astounding.wings were ok...maybe a bit old..we are making this small business a place to..."
Bob Quinn
"The deep dish pizza is like pizza hut in the 1980s. Only..."
john armstrong
"The very best pizza in the area. Friendly staff and fair prices. I judge other pizzas by comparing with Cicero Country’s. Usually no comparison!..."
George Hotaling
"Phenomenal pizza! We got a pepperoni and garlic pizza. We chose this place because of other reviews and they were definitely right. Amanda was our..."
Amanda Kennedy
"I haven't been here in 10 years, it was even better than I remembered. I may be a little biased but my family is currently making plans to go again..."
Billy Sotherden
"Best pizza and wings around Syracuse..."
David Wang
"We love Cicero Country so much we had their pizza for our rehearsal dinner years ago. The decor of the dining room is a bit plain Jane but it's a..."
Rachel Vryhof
"The staff is timely and friendly and the food is absolutely..."
Cindy Hanchett
"Simple Italian restaurant that's been serving Pizza for over four decades. Classic style ambiance inside, with homemade style pizza and Italian..."
J. Shaun
"Lost power just as food was delivered to table,but all went..."
Renee H
"Delicious food and a fun atmosphere! We bring our family and friends here all the time! The waitresses are really funny and make everyone feel..."
Rebecca LaMora
Al's Italian Restaurant
81
/100 (775 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
Reservations
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Delivery
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Italian food and the setting at this spot is great. Nice place to meet and catch up with family. Definitely worth a return visit. Prices were..."
Aiden Herrera
"Friday fish buffet was..."
Kristina Lopez
"Working for a large company on the overnight shift makes the Holiday's challenging. Al's catered our Thanksgiving Dinner last night for 65 employees..."
S R2019
"Half price pizza on mondays always..."
James Wilson
"Visited Al's for the first time tonight, but it definitely will not be the last. Not being from this area, I read some reviews and I loved that it..."
Jena Rexroth
"We love to go out. Yesterday we visited this magnificent restaurant which we didn’t know before. We had a delightful evening there with..."
Elijah Mccullough
"The menu and service were ahead of our expectations. I really liked the ambience of this restaurant. Excellent restaurant to take the family out for..."
Geraldo Meeks
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred!
Please try again in a few minutes
Sign in with Facebook
Sign in with Google
Sign in with Apple
By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
-
Privacy policy
-
Terms of use
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes