TOP 10 BEST Restaurants in Cicero - Updated November 2024

Big Dog's Smokehouse Bbq

83/100 (942 ratings)

Quick Bites

Restaurants

Barbecue

American

Dinner

Lunch

Brisket Platter

1 4 Chicken Plate

Brisket Sandwich with Smokehouse Baked Beans

Pasta

Flight of Sliders

Mac and cheese

Mac N Cheese Pulled Chicken Sandwich Bread Pudding

Ribs

Brisketmelt Sandwich

Pork

Triple Dog

Sauces

Brisket Lunch Special

Pulled Pork Platter

Fries Mac & Cheese

Green Beans

1 2 Pound Brisket Sandwich

Apple Fritter

Baby Back Ribs and Corn Bread

Beef Brisket Sandwich

Smoked Sausage

Mac and Cheese

Sausage Plate

Sit down

American

Barbecue

Highchairs Available

Accepts Credit Cards

Delivery

Outdoor Seating

Takeout

Seating

Wheelchair Accessible

Wine and Beer

Dinner

Lunch

Mid-range

"Visited for the first time yesterday. It is not a full service restaurant and you know that when you walk in. That doesn't bother me in the least. ..."

Carol Fultz

"Big Dogs handled an all day event with over 425 people. They came with amazing food, friendly servers and thoughtful extras like vases of flowers and..."

Amy McGlothin Biegel

"Greatest BBQ in town. Couldn't have asked for a better experience. Great staff amazing food. This is a must for anyone in the Cicero area. Not a..."

Eric Opsal

"Was taken there for my birthday lunch, first time... Was absolutely amazing, had the southern comfort sandwich omg to die for... Definatley recommend..."

Shay Harvey London

"I used Big Dogs for my daughter's barn wedding in October. They were fabulous. Cheryl is an absolute dream to work with. She's been doing this..."

Julie Snyder-Bristol

"This place is outstanding. I rode up from the south side of Indianapolis to try it out after hearing how good it was and it was absolutely worth the..."

Pete Heugel

"The pulled pork, potato salad, and baked beans were all very good. The Mac and cheese was a bit dry but the atmosphere and service were wonderful...."

Phil Stevens

"Born & raised in Indiana, I've been living in Florida since 2009. I'm up here visiting and my friend and I were driving through Cicero and stumbled..."

stacy Guillen

"Small town and home cooked BBQ joint. Awesome decor, friendly staff, and fun place to eat. The building is really neat and all the different decor..."

Chris Conway

"This is probably my favorite bbq joint I've ever been too. Not only is the food amazing but the decor is awesome. Vintage and rustic. I absolutely..."

Daniel Zook

"The brisket melt was the best. Tender brisket with cheese and jalapeño melt your mouth. Baked beans and potato salad added to make the most..."

gary merrill

"Love the atmosphere and decor. Lots to talk about while eating. This place has the best sliced beef brisket in Indiana and maybe the Midwest, but I..."

Mike Talhelm

"Very nostalgic bbq restaurant in Cicero, IN. The service was a little off. We ordered at the counter had to seat our selves, got our own drinks. The..."

Joe Eaton

"Very neat little place. The food was terrific. Everything had distinct flavors. It's decorated..."

Jim Slaight

"Hands down my favorite BBQ spot in Indiana. No one else compares. Not only is the food good, the staff are really friendly and you can tell they take..."

Elle

"Delicious food & great service! The atmosphere is just a bonus! Very neat place with vintage decor. The pulled pork and the brisket were delicious!..."

Kylee Wagner

"Great barbeque! This is a unique place. I loved the decor. The service was excellent. The pulled pork was moist and it was some of the best..."

Cynthia Warren

"Many cool things to say about this unique place. Big Dogs is super quick for lunch. Decorated in Americana and most of it is for sale. Music..."

Martin Cabela

"Fantastic experience for my first of many visits. I decided to go off-menu and try their special the Tripple-Dog-Dare. The sandwich consisted of a..."

Zech Smith

"Ate lunch today. Pulled pork with 2 sides and all the sauces. Waitress was more than polite and everything was awesome. Pretty crowded during..."

Jim Tomlinson

"Would give this 6 stars if I could!! People were soooo friendly and helpful since it was our first (but not last) time there. You order/pay at..."

Adrienne Ludwig

"Food was great. Sauces were tasty. Seating area was small but accommodating. Will definately be..."

Scott Wilkerson

"I have had they food at a wedding once and it was good. I went in for a carry out. This place is very cool. The people are very friendly and want you..."

Stache 7h

"Stopped in on my way through and got a brisket sandwich and Mac n cheese, both were really good. Before I finished I placed an order to go so I could..."

Reset

There is only one restaurant

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Sauces in Cicero

Ranking

Sort A-Z

near you

Filters