TOP 10 BEST Restaurants in Cicero - Updated November 2024

Carmelita's Mexican Restaurant

91/100 (349 ratings)

Restaurants

Mexican

Vegetarian Friendly

Dinner

Lunch

Los Mejores Nachos

Quesadilla

Agua de Horchata

Rice and beans

Birria Tacos

Margarita Flight

Mexican Soda

8 Aust & Geros a La Americana Tacos

Azteca Chicken Enchiladas with Salsa Verde

Cucumber Vodka Drink

Guerra's Favorite Guacamole

Cheese Dip

Wet Burrito

Chips and Salsa

Chilaquiles

Mexican

Reservations

Seating

Table Service

Wheelchair Accessible

Takeout

Dinner

Lunch

Mid-range

"If you're looking for authentic Mexican food this is the place to go. Today was our first visit and we are so happy we made the drive from Camillus...."

Kim Hinds Brennan

"We had a fabulous meal, all suggested by the owner and our wonderful waitress! You can taste every single flavor...not one overpowers the other,..."

Amber Lyn Hubbard Woodworth

"Finally, some authentic Mexican food with some heat to it!!! I have been waiting for a place like this. I lived in TX for 8 years and grew to love..."

Kara Vrooman

"Just discovered this little gem and so glad we did!! We had delicious Mana's nachos and the homemade corn tortilla chips were amazing crunchy and..."

Sharon Doyle Ianzito

"If you’re looking for gluten free delicious food this is the place to go! Everything was so fresh and flavorful. They even have delicious gluten..."

Chris Marullo Vandewalker

"Excelente!! Wonderful ambiance, food, and service! We had a great time and enjoyed every last bite. So cozy and the most friendly staff! TIP: the..."

Matteo Chazaq Culli

"From the moment we walked in we knew we'd hit the jackpot. It appeared the only available table was next to the door. The gal that welcomed us..."

Tobey Ames Fischer

"I had such a wonderful time at dinner�the service was great and the staff made me feel like they have known me for years. The place is super clean!..."

Cecelia Jennifer

"Soon as we walked in the door we were treated like family. We went with a 3yr old 4 yr old an 5 yr old. The owner an wait staff gave them attention..."

Kevin Anderton

"The food is amazing and authentic Mexican cuisine! It's the first good Mexican food we've had since coming from Arizona. The tortillas and tortilla..."

Julie Bocanegra

"We had the chicken quesadilla, chicken burrito, and desserts. Everything was outstanding. I highly recommend eating..."

Audrey Dreier-Morrison

"Very tasty! The food was wonderful. The owner/chef even came out to personally check on us. So many gluten free..."

Kris Shea

"Tried this wonderful place based on the fact that she makes tortillas from scratch! That is KEY!!! So very glad we did! FANTASTICAL FOOD!!! Very..."

Brenda DeThomas Konop

"Ate lunch with my family here yesterday. We started with the Tinga nachos which were delicious. The home made beans were amazing. I had Brooke’s..."

Lauren VanBenCoten

"I ordered the nacho flight, enchiladas with salsa verde, and horchata, all of which were tasty! But the standout for me was the incredible customer..."

Michael Le

"I read the mix reviews, but still wanted to give it a try. I'm glad I did. I ordered the BYOB burrito which was enormus! Chili verde sauce covered...."

Jackie Richards

"Nacho flight and tacos on sale when we went. I am a big nachos person so I was really excited to do this. All of them were great and it was a nice..."

M

"Ordered food to go, pic included of the Brooks Favorite enchilada meal. Very good food and the staff was super friendly! Real authentic food like..."

Molly Starusnak

"Loved the ambiance, quick service, cultured food, fast service and the dessert was the most tasteful I’ve ever tasted. Highly recommended 👍 I..."

Fadi salam

"We stopped in yesterday. Everything was perfect! So good we're ordering to go tonight! Drinks, flavors, atmosphere..."

Nate Bator

"Excellent food, staff, and service!! Had a really great time! Ashamed I didn't find this place sooner. Definitely a hidden gem you won't be..."

Nathan

"I just got back from a fantastic Mexican dinner. The chicken enchiladas were so fresh and the flavors were great. The margarita was one of the best..."

d clark

"Lovely little "hole in the wall". Friendly service. Nice flavors. Got the guacamole appetizer, obviously homemade chips, on the thick side (which I..."

Kae Harrison

"Wow! There's is so many ways to describe the delicious food I ate! But all I can come up with right now is WOW 😍 we will definitely be..."

Adam Dumas

"I'm so glad we finally made it to Carmelita's! The food is fresh, the staff is incredibly kind and friendly, and the Skinny Margarita was light and..."

Susie Ippolito

"Hands down the most delicious spicy margarita I have had! I was seriously blown away by the layers of flavor and heat. The food was fresh and tasty...."

Amelia Ringhisen

"Love it. It is a great place to eat. Huge menu. Get Maria's nachos as an appetizer or meal. Cant go..."

Cindy Lusk

"The food here was yummy and gluten free. I thought there would be more dishes with rice and options but that’s my liking. My tostadas were good,..."

Colleen H

"The food is always amazing every time I go!! Absolutely..."

T Blanchard

"It was nice there, but something about the spices just didn't taste good to either of us. Service was good, and it was..."

Reset

There are 2 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Cheese Dip in Cicero

Ranking

Sort A-Z

near you

Filters