Bought a 14" sausage and pepperoni pizza, 20 wings and cheese bread. The pizza was good but a little too saucy. The wings were very good but really small. The cheese bread was excellent.
New location tastes just as good as the old one that unfortunately burned down. I ordered a medium pepperoni and mushroom. Got the spicy sauce on it. Was delicious! The service was super friendly, didn't take more than 15 min to cook, and I was a walk in order. Highly recommend!
Pizza is excellent, best pizza we have had since moving here several years ago. Our search is over. If the pizza remains as it is we will be customers for years. Very reasonably priced too.
I don’t get the reviews that complain about the toppings under the cheese. Other then pepperoni, it’s the only way I have ever seen pizza made. Who puts toppings on top of the cheese? Such a weird thing to complain about.
Great pizza and team. The prices were very reasonable. We both shared a 12" pizza and were filled.
Had no idea they moved after the fire in Sunset. I’m SO HAPPY my favorite pizza in the world is back! And same goes with their unique salad! I’m giddy
Please go and support this yummy place! I'm so glad they are open again. Everything tasted like it did in the previous location. Yummy pizza and salad!!!
Same pizza as ever! Original owner's grandchildren running it. Glad to see the Business survived the fire, like a Phoenix out of the ashes!!
I used to work at the Sunset Smiths by the original location if Circle Inn Pizzeria and we’d order pizza all the time from there. I was sad when I heard the news of it burning down. Their new location is just blocks from my house now and we tried it the other day with my family. Happy to announce that they are still providing great quality pizzas at their new location. The pizza was very good and we’ll definitely be back again soon. Thanks Garret!
Been looking for a really good pizza place and I have found one. Excellent pizza with quality tasting toppings and really good Mozzarella. Selection of beer is good as well as sizes of beer. Me, 32 ounce all the way!
Great local place! Pizza was good and hot, staff was friendly and the Halloween decorations were fun. We will be back!
The pizza wasn't bad, but it wasn't special either.
However, the crispy buffalo wings were AWESOME!
Garrets is the best, a humble, hard-working, all-American cooking fool. His pizza is by far some of the best and the service no matter how busy and if you've been there they sell a lot of pizza and food. But I'll tell it's ALWAYS worth the wait
Had a great time playing pool. A great place for bar games, pizza and a nice cold beer or two....wait make it a pitcher please. The service was very slow and only one girl working and she was pregnant.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes