Our favorite pizza place so far! The big slices are perfect size to fill you up, especially if you get some garlic knots too. And the knots come with queso, omg it's incredible.
We eat outside with our doggo too. Great environment, and even greater food!!
Who goes to a pizza restaurant and orders a burger? I guess I do, I didn’t know ok. That being said the burger was damn phenomenal. However the fries were rock hard and pretty trash. Still got 4 stars though Bc that burger will knock your crocs off.
Staff sat our party of 11 really quick. We sat on the nice patio benches for dinner. The pizza was huge!! We went with half pepperoni and the other half with cheese. They double cut it for us so that our kids could hold it easier and it really helped. Our fave were the buffalo wings, you buy these by the pound and it was approximately 10 wings. No pics of wings because we gobbled them up as soon as they hit the table!
The pizza here is excellent! I love thin pizza especially when the slices are big enough to fold so you can dip it in extra sauce. So yummy! The sauce was perfect in taste with all the right rich spices, the cheese was very flavorful, and the crust was perfect with the outer ends being crunchy. You can’t go wrong. Also ordered the fettuccine done perfectly as well.. this was a take out order.
Great place for great groceries
The best pizza I have eaten in the Springs! I’ve traveled all over a can say this pizza is right there New York/Boston pizzas!!! The garlic knots with marinara sauce are like Wow! The lady behind the counter taking the order was really friendly and courteous, this go a long way.
If your visiting from the east coast I highly recommend the pizza spot!!
Giant slice of pizza, build your own.....it was like a full pizza! Not only was it delicious, it was only like $4! I love this place. Also, the peach beer was amazing.
Updated edit review: I will be giving them another try management seems to care about customers and reached out to me, this time we will stop by after 5 so we can try the wings and knots looking forward to it.
Pizza was a bit burnt but points for how big it was. Weird you can't get wings or nachos until 4pm we wanted to try the garlic knots. No need to return still on the search for amazing pizza in the Springs
Unique drinks, interesting make your own pizza and food selections, and a nice modern atmosphere made for a great evening stop. Really enjoyed the thin crust pepperoni 26 inch pizza.
Delicious Pizza, excellent service. The garlic knots with mozzarella dipping sauce...Oh My!
Our server was very friendly and attentive. Though I usually like a pizza with thicker crust, the slice I got had good flavor. The waffle fries were cooked well too. And yes, some places can actually screw up waffle fries, so this was a good meal to end my weekend.
THIS IS THE SPOT!! 26" Pepperoni Pizza and 2 lbs hot wings...DELICIOUSNESS!! Our waiter wasn't great but it was still greeat experience overall!
![5]( "Recensione")
After a hard day of work and barely eating at all. We had to make sure we ate dinner. Being on the south side of town we opted to go with Fat Sully’s as it’s always a solid option.
We went and sat down and ordered the 28 in. Pizza. - 1/2 cheese & 1/2 pepperoni
Now I will say that the restaurant was pretty clean even for a busy weekend night!
My stomach was growling and I ate all 4 of my slices while the wife took most of hers home.
The New York style pizza leans towards focusing on the grease which I enjoy. It’s not overly greasy but it’s definitely present which helps solidify the pizza’s authenticity.
The cheese was nice and thin. Their marinara sauce is more tomato forward than most. I definitely recommend utilizing the red hot pepper flakes to compliment the sauce.
The pepperoni was nicely dispersed among 1/2 the pizza as requested.
The crispy crust was a staple that couldn’t go wrong.
Fat Sully’s will always be a solid pizza option in Colorado Springs. It’s consistent & tasty which are the two most important aspects of a New York pizza place.
I love this place and their pizza is delicious! Every slice is basically a full meal. If you ar3 looking for a fun and delicious pizza place - this is it!
Best pizza, beer drinks, atmosphere, etc! Our first stop whenever I’m in the Springs and their slices and pies never disappoint. A MUST try, you’ll be hooked for life.
Pizza here is pretty basic, but with a good number of topping options. Being able to order by the slice is great. The wings are really good too, we normally order extra crispy and love them. Good selection of beer and PBR on top is a plus. Being open late is even better
Very cool place, all the staff are friendly and seem to enjoy there positions. I had to try there pizza slice an house salad, an got pepperoni an sausage on my slice and ranch for the salad. The slice was bigger than the plate foldable and took me back to NY every inch was perfect. I ate the whole crust an my picky, I usually share when I'm at a new place but not today! I dipped my crust in the ranch and almost bit my fingers! My son ordered a smash burger when it came to the table I asked could I cut a lil piece an he couldn't wait for me to finish chewing before half of it was gone! Had no clue this place would bring out this side of us. We're definitely going again, and I'm gonna tell the cook you are mine NOW! 😘Hope you like my review
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes