This place is just comfortable, like an old shoe. Even if it's your first time, you feel like you've been here before. The Rusty Bucket is a classic neighborhood tavern concept that has worked very well in Upper Arlington.
I usually go to Rusty Bucket in another state. Same quality food, same very good environment. At this one, I had the Caesar salad and the buffalo chicken sandwich. Food arrived fast, tasted great. I’ll be returning for sure.
Drinks were delicious and served quick :)) happy with the bar. It wasn't super busy and food came out slow and a lil dry for fish, i was not overly impressed. But over all was a pretty good experience.
Service was absolutely OUTSTANDING! Sorry that we didn't get the server's name, but he was simply awesome. Food as always was excellent. I had raspberry ice tea and bacon burger. Dish! Everyone's meal was perfect. My grandchildren love this place and we will certainly be back!
Had seen reviews of this place online and gave it a try. The wait staff had been a bit on the slow moving side, so ordering and receiving my food took a while. I ordered a Club Sandwich and Mac and Cheese with Chicken tenders with a side of fries. That Mac and Cheese was probably the best part of the meal, even if it was a small serving. A bit on the pricey side for the serving sizes, but the food was good so I had no legitimate complaints.
Our waiter, Mitch, provided excellent service, not just to my husband and I, but to others around us. He was so positive, knew the menu well, and was able to talk in detail about soups, salad dressings, etc. It was obvious that he was well trained and takes his job seriously. He was proud to be serving us the food we ordered. People like this makes going out to eat a pleasure.
Went for lunch with 2 friends. I almost always order the Double Nickel salad with blackened chicken. Today was no exception. As always, it was delicious. The salad dressing is great. Our waiter was very friendly and efficient.
Love the food. Inflation prices seem higher than comparable fast casual restaurants. Understandable as I love many of the food, the double nickel is one of the best salads I get, the club is delicious and slightly warm. Kettle chips are tasty and fresh. Due to rising costs I won't eat here as often as I have. Location is convenient
In Columbus just for a weekend getaway with my boyfriend and our 4 kids. Visited the Rusty Bucket and was absolutely blown away by the service and quality of food!!! Madison was our waitress and she went above and beyond the whole time. Super nice. Super knowledgeable. The food was also delicious. Would recommend. 10/10 for service and food quality!! Thank you Madison for making our lunch just phenomenal!!
Surprisingly good food for a "tavern". All the food had a lot of flavor and menu has tons of options. The poke bowl was actually spicy and super fresh. Side of street corn was delicious as well. Others got the mushroom pizza and Buffalo chicken sandwich, nothing bad to say about anything!
Pub atmosphere and food. Went at a busy time so service was a bit slow. My fish sandwich and cole slaw were great. My friend's Cubano sandwich was very good.
Quick, friendly service and delicious food. I cleared my plate it was so good! Best buffalo chicken sandwich!
Upscale location for a local chain of restaurants. The food is reliably good, the drinks are well poured, the prices are fair considering the area of town.
A large square bar is surrounded by tables and a patio. The servers are polite and attentive.
This location is part of an affluent shopping mall so parking is rarely a problem. It's a good place to window shop after dinner.
The serve non-alcoholic beer for the D.D.
The food and service are pretty good. Some places you can really tell people don't care, that's definitely not thus establishment. Great place
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes