Besides the owners Gary and Robyn being some of the coolest people (even if they are Michigan fans lol) the pizza is absolutely amazing. The crust was perfectly crisp, the sauce is so good with a hint of sweet and spice, the old world pepperonis were my favorite. The Brownings will definitely be ordering again!
Love this pizza! BBQ Chicken pizza is amazing! Ordered 2 italian subs & chessy garlic bread. All of it was yummy delicious! So far nothing has disappointed us! Thanks Possum Hollar Pizza!
Rosemary McGrath Dotson
+5
I hadn't had Possum Holler pizza in years and was worried that it wouldn't be as good as it once was, but boy I was wrong. My hubby and I order the combo pizza every other week and it never disappoints. I am not one to like all them toppings (I do pick hot peppers off..lol), but I love them on the combo pizza..
This is the best pizza I have ever had. I've get great service whether I'm order carryout or delivery. I recommend this place to all of my friends and family!
Great food, no matter what I have ordered. From pizza to sub to gyros to fried goodies. All great!
Always enjoy a good XL Possum Holler Combo...perfect to ring in the new year....Possum Holler is not just good pizza but an experience... The toppings that fall off of the pizza isn't even as much as other places put on their pizza. In other words...you don't get jipped on the toppings... Happy New Year Possum Holler!!!
Friendly staff and pizza is great. We took 75% of our pizza home because it was so big and loaded with Lots of toppings. well worth the money.
Great food great service!!! First pizza I ordered when I moved back to Columbus, definitely wasn’t disappointed!!!
We tried possum holler pizza for the first time tonight! It was delicious! Both pizza's were loaded with toppings, cooked to perfection, the crust was even good but the cheese..oh that cheese...is definitely what set's this pizza apart from any other place around. We will eat here again soon!
Get pizza from here all the time. My family loves it!!!!
Drove from whitehall to try the pizza and sub, both were fantastic. The staff was so nice!!! Better than Anges in whitehall!
I used to live in the area and after being gone for 3 years stopped by for a pie since we were in town. I was absolutely amazed it tasted just as I remember!!! People in Tennessee do not know how to make a pizza, lol So if your ever able to ship let me know!!!!
We love the old world pep&ch pizza.there pepperoni is a little more spicey & more on it
Miranda Johnson Wheeler
+5
Was recommended this place while our week stay at Children's and it did not disappoint! Definitely one of the best pizzas we have had (and we have had a lot) The wings are a must try, they reminded me if the Roosters breading. I dont normally leave reviews unless it's either exceptionally great or terribly awful. Will definitely be going back when we are in the Columbus area!
Good Pizza!. I don't think anybody loads more toppings on then them! The pizza's are heavy! :) Great pizza, friendly people.
Don't let the look of this place fool you. They have some of the best pizza I've ever had. Sure they could use some new carpet and some paint, but the kitchen is clean and the staff is friendly and semi-professional. lol I WILL be going there again.
Awesome pizza! My husband and I were driving through and were craving pizza. decided to try this place based on urbanspoon reviews and they were right. The pizza crust was still a dough ball when we walked in. The cheese was so thick it was chewy (my favorite). The sauce was perfect and tons of toppings. If we lived In the are this pizza would be a weekly dinner. The building itself needs tons of help. The door frames are exposed, the carpet is 20+ years, the walls have tons of spackle on the red wall and the back has obvious water damage on the ceiling. Its a good thing the pizza. is delicious!
Best pizza on the south side of Columbus, OH.
I have had pizza from NY to Boston and Chicago. This pizza is so amazing!!!! Staff is great too.
Not a bad pie. Dont let the KKK rep scare you away. The topping and sauce are really good. The crust is on the dry side and they take longer than the quoted time but each pizza is hand made and cooked fresh
Good food. I really like the subs here, and the pizza is really good too. Not sure what sets it apart, but it's definitely better than the run of the mill chain pizza places.
THE BEST PIZZA!. The pizza was really outta this world...plenty of ingredients by far from most pizza places...the sauce really does have a nice twang and the crust was PERFECT.
Pizza was amazing. The owner Robyn check this out and she was extremely nice. The pizza was some of the best pizza I've had in a long long time. I know the old owners were jerks but the new owners obviously have done a lot to make this place and the product of the food amazing.
Great pizza. The Olde world pepperoni has just the right amount of spice and crisps up nice. Tried the veggie pie and it was excellent. Definitely worth the drive from Pickerington
Long time customer and absolutely love their pizza. Just recently ordered and the time to pick up was 10 minutes versus what usually is 30 minutes. I thought that was fantastic but when I got there, there was a new pizza oven. What they used to use was a deck style oven and now there is a conveyor style. Overall, the pizza was still very good but it seems like the quality went down a bit with the new style oven. can’t wait to order again and see if I’m wrong. Overall still very delicious but really liked the other style of cooking.
Great pizza. Friendly staff. Worth the visit to Obetz!
Best pizza in the area by far! Never have had a problem with service like I’ve seen in some reviews, the employees are always kind.
We have been a regular customer of Possum Holler over the years and it's still gotta be one of our favorite mom and pop shop pizzas! The pizza is occasionally overcooked or undercooked but it's usually right on the money! The real value is in the toppings to crust ratio! It's perfect!👌 the crust is slightly crunchy with a nice chew and the sauce has a solid flavor as well. The cheese is full flavored and the toppings never get skimped on! There are pies out there where you'll spend a lot more on a lot less...this is not that pie! Highly recommended 👌
Holy Columbus! That was DELICIOUS! Came from up North to shop and try a new pizza place, not sure how others will compare the next time we come down. This place is a MUST TRY!
I live all the way by Easton an travel for this pizza! Pizza never makes it home on drive back. Already eaten 😋
The possum combo is filled with delicious goodness gracious! They dont play possum here! Yaw better get a taste. Great job possum holler! Dropped the mic.
Best Pizza in town!!! I have been in Columbus for 9 year's and this pizza is amazing!!! Great prices and orders are made fresh!!!
The old world pepperoni is excellent! I got double cheese and double pep. Neither were necessary. You will wait a little longer to pick up one of these bad boys, but the quality of the ingredients is well worth the wait!
It’s a hole in the wall that serves the BEST pizza in the Columbus Metro Area
Holy cow! This pizza is AMAZING! Old World Pepperoni is the way to go. Make the trip, you won't be disappointed.
Great local independent Columbus style pizza shop. You haven't seen a pizza with a lot of toppings until you've seen a possum holler pizza. Good ingredients, very tasty sauce, best banana peppers you'll find in a restaurant, friendly staff.
If you're into local pizza, you have to try possum holler.
Best pizza in Columbus!!! We drive quite far to pick up, worth the drive!! Childhood favorite! Just a "classic" pizza from younger years!!! Love it!!!
Very good pizza and for the quality it is an unbeatable value.
The Best Pizza in Columbus!! If you're on a budget,you should probably go somewhere else because here at The Possum,You get what you pay for! Not for the faint of heart! Great food, Awesome Customer service.!!!!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes