Chorotes96
I did not rate the atmosphere since I only ordered delivery. The Hawaiian pizza is amazing probably the best one I have ever had. The margeritta pizza was also good. I'd give the shrimp Alfredo 4/5. Otherwise the food was amazing! I'll definitely order again.
CJ Blessing
Always consistently exactly what I need when I want it. It’s pretty quick delivery via door dash too.
Jacob Brosko
Ordered the Margherita Pizza for the first time tonight through Doordash. Was a little nervous about how the pizza would hold up through delivery however I was pleasantly surprised. The crust was a little softer and sweeter than many places in Columbus which was a pleasant surprise. Not greasy at all and tasted fresh which was another pleasant surprsise. All around a pleasant experience and I'm looking forward to being pleasantly surprised trying more of the menu.
Jevette 7
The Shrimp Alfredo Pizza was indeed vary tasty. Reasonable rime from placing order to receiving the pizza was spot on. Do not expect to sit down and eat as Castello Pizza not set up from dining in (only gave 2 stars for atmosphere because it was clean and provided a few chaos to sit while waiting for the pizza. The parking was in the back accessible via an alley way).
Jessica Huang
The guys there are so friendly and offered tissues when I sneezed. Love their pizza selection, super fun flavors and pretty unique. My Fav is the Greek Pizza. No space to sit inside and eat though
Malek Saber (Crazy Drone)
So delicious, this is the best pizza i have ever taste , specially cheese pizza you feel with real cheese and it is so delicious. Also calzone is really taste good ,when mixing shrimp with cheese make it awesome.
About the size: small pizza looks like medium and calzone is really big and enough for a meal.
Brent Rayburn
Solid every time. The pizza is a combination of NY style with a crispy, Ohio style crust. Service is always fast and courteous also. We love having this shop just around the corner from our house.
Hend Hassan
Great food and wonderful staff. We all tried different pizzas, and everything was amazing. The prices were a pleasant surprise. We will be back and there were other items we want to try. Highly recommended to all.
Hannah Scheppler
This is the most authentic Italian pizza in Columbus. It’s just exquisite. It’s not Brooklyn or Chicago pizza, just regular good old Ohio-like pizza. But it’s made with real ingredients and by someone who either was trained by an Italian or is Italian.
Sincerely,
Your neighborhood half Sicilian
Alisha Black
Everything was delicious!! Very cheesy, my Stromboli was spot on! We ordered a Hawaiian and a cheesesteak pizza. They were flavorful and the kids loved them! A++ from my picky eaters!! Thank you!!! Oh and definitely don't forget dessert, the oreo cake was creamy and well worth it! We will be ordering from here again!
Pauline Ro
Stopped by this place for a quick bite after touring St Peter's Basilica and was completely won over by the food and the service. THE STAFF IS SO FRIENDLY!!! Loved everyone who served us. Also food was wonderful- The capri was a GREAT starter. We ordered 3 pizzas (Diavola, Primavera, and Margherita) which was the perfect amount for 4 hungry people and they were all delicious. Afterwards we got homemade tiramisu, lemon gelato, and 4 limoncello(?) shots. Highly recommend everything we had!
Amr Emad
Everything is perfect, clean and delicious food, this is my best restaurant I ever tried in Columbus! If I can give them more than 5 stars I will do that!!!!!!
Dale Parker
I usually use DoorDash for delivery. But the food is excellent Shrimp Alfredo and other pasta dishes are excellent!! Haven’t trireme the pizza yet.
jacqueline taylor
Small pizza kitchen in Clintonville. This place should not be overlooked if you are looking for good pizza in Columbus. Also open until 2am, makes Mickeys Late Night Slice look like a pizza lunch-able.
Mike Schaub
What a great place I live close so I order here alot try it you won't be disappointed I promise nice staff and owners too
Dylan Huff
Good food, great Pizza. Didn’t try much but so far so good!
Marwan Tammam
It's best pizza in town, I don't care what anyone says. It tastes the same today as it did in different times I ordered before. Absolutely delicious. Do your self a favor and snag a pie from Costello's. You will NOT be disappointed.
farid Bachir
Great team and delicious food. It was my best pizza that I have never eaten before; specially Farid the chef cook is the best cook in the town, he is professional and perfectionist. He knows what he is doing. Thanks Chef Farid and for the whole team.
Steve Hopkins
Very delicious Pizza I would highly recommend anybody to try it out
Timmah Hinkle
Love the food from this place! The people are great too!
Savanna Sue Alawamleh
My pasta was amazing and so much food for $8.00 will definitely be back:)!
Lora Mitchell
Was really surprised by how very good the pizza was. :-)
Trainer Riad Ali
Best pizza I eat in my life . The cheese is amazing. The menu is too big and all items is delicious.
Dante Garcia
Great price. Great service. Great people. Great pizza!
Amanda Perry
Nice people! Good food! Quick service! Thanks! �
Yussef Mawadda
Best pizza in indinola ave Columbus. Ohio we had it since the business moved in.
Khalil Fares
Best Pizza Shop on Campus, definitely recommended it.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes