Pizza Joe's - Cortland - Photo album

Was highly disappointed in my last visit here. We ordered 5 large pizzas to be picked up at 4:30 for a party that started at 5:00. I had my sister pick them up for me, she arrived on time (4:30) yet they had none of our pizzas even started. Everyone showed up at 5:00 expecting to eat but we didn't h

Went from amazing to horrible. It's impossible to even place an order now. The new phone policy has them ignoring phone calls half the time. Spent 20 minutes trying to call in an order and literally never got through to anyone. Either it was busy or when it did connect no one picked up in time for i

I like their pizza better than some of the bigger names. Lots of sauce and toppings. I get to go, takes about half an hour.

Always good food, great service, and a comfy dine in experience. One of my lunch stops to relax before work. They have a wide variety on their menu to choose from...

Ordered a small poor man’s pizza (white pizza) n a personal pepperoni. $15 n change. White pizza was horrible. I believe it was pizza crust n a few banana peppers. It’s always been my understanding that white pizza is cheese without red sauce n banana peppers and butter between crust n cheese and pe

Worst customer service ever. I was treated rudely from the second I called and when I had the nerve to ask her to read back my order, she hung up on me. I called back and spoke to a man who did the same thing. When I had my fiancée call, he was told they were too busy and then he hung up on him! How

This place has gone down hill. So sad. Ordered The 1/2 sheet Pepperoni Pile-Up which is a specialty pizza and got a regular pepperoni pizza. Also ordered a large order of wings and the wings were so small with hardly any meat on them yet paid full price. My parents ordered 2 philly subs and had hard

Cortland Oh. Wife went to pick up our order. She was told she already picked it up. Then they said they gave it to some other Randy Jarvis. They wouldn't give her money back. The manager said come back in 45 mins. I went there to get my money back. The manager was very rude. After 20 mins arguing s