This is a fantastic little restaurant, great atmosphere, friendly staff, excellent food, the portions are large almost couldn't finish the lasagna but i forced myself it was so good. The garlic bread was good as well. Prices where fair, clean restaurant and restrooms, lots of parking easy in and out. Definitely worth a stop when in the area.
I've only had delivery but the 1st time the cook actually stopped what he was doing and ran the food to me in no time flat! They had made a mistake on the credit card and immediately called me back, fixed it and brought the fixed receipt with them. I had a chef salad and wings which were wonderful! The chef salad is the cheapest in town and is the best you can get. They really give you a lot of the good stuff! The cheese pizza (I'm from the North so I'm picky) is FABULOUS and gigantic...the way it should be! The sauce is so dang good. I am so impressed with this business. Thank you for going above and beyond! John King Rd <3
NY-born & NJ-bred woman here. This is the closest to NY pizza I’ve had here in the panhandle. I wasn’t able to dine in, but the pizza tastes great. The garlic knots are good but doesn’t have that deep garlic flavor. If these guys sold pizza by the slice, I’d give them 5-stars. Great flavor though!
As first time customers we called ahead and picked up a couple of delicious pizzas on our way through FL and they did not disappoint! Conviently located right off the interstate this was some seriously good food. It was packed on a Sunday evening, the perfect sign of great food and service. And apparently they have a good customer with the same last name as me because they gave me "the usual discount" 😁 thanks again New York's Famous Pizza!
I really enjoy New York style pizza. Crust was a lil over cooked but still was good.
The pizzas are huge, they're made fresh and the taste is great! I proudly burnt my mouth on a ny special, one large can easily feed 4 people, probably more!
They are AWESOME!!! We got a Chicken Parmigiana pizza, ate 1 piece each and brought the rest home. Their portions are Huge! Oh and can't forget the AWESOME Cheesecake too. The Food was amazing.
The Sicilian is amazing! Crunchy outside, soft thick crust and enough melted cheese to satisfy all of you cheese lovers out there!
The service was great! The young man that waited on us was very nice and met all our needs before we needed them. The pizzas were huge! You may not need a large. Check the actual size before ordering. The pizza was a little doughy on the bottom. Just a little undercooked. The sauce and toppings were really good. It could’ve been a one time deal where ours was undercooked but who knows. We were visiting for a baseball tournament. I would definitely go again if I was in the area. Must try this place. They were pretty busy so the place must be good most of the time. Can’t be perfect every time.
The food here is always amazing, the pizza especially. It's always prepared and cooked as you want it. I have had some of the best pizza around the world, including Rome as well as in New York. The pizza here is as close as you will get to true authentic New York style pizza. The staff is also always nice and the atmosphere is very comfortable.
I have had pretty much all their food except for their subs and sandwiches. Perhaps I will order that next time and give it a review.
We were greeted quickly and warmly. It was our first visit and our server explained the menu and specials. We got the New York pizza and it was huge and loaded with fresh ingredients. The crust was perfect and delicious just by itself. Great pizza, fair price, good service. We’ll go back!
Pizza is soooooo delicious!!! Like the pizza we get up North in NY... will definitely be making this our new pizza place!
I have not had the pleasure of dining inside the restaurant yet, but back when they first opened I took a chance and ordered their baked lasagna and meatballs to be delivered. My wife is a New York Italian woman so it's darn hard for a restaurant to compete with HER gravy (sauce). I've had it countless times since then. It's a generous portion, and both the gravy and the meatballs are on point! The rest of my family calls it the best pizza we've had since moving here 20 years ago, I call it the best baked lasagna I've ever had at a restaurant.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes