Sluurpy > Restaurants in Crystal Lake > That's Amore Pizza

That's Amore Pizza - Crystal Lake - Photo album

Stoked I finally had the perfect excuse to order from That's Amore Pizza. Solid NYC style pizza. Simple, not greasy, fresh ingredients. Friendly service. Happy family.

Ordered the Mac and cheese pizza for a second time. First time there was only a handful of noodles and very little bacon but the pizza itself was pretty good. Ordered again tonight, lots of bacon, still not a lot of noodles, but they over cooked the pizza to where the cheese was way over cooked to a

I’m not sure why people are leaving poor reviews of a local business, especially this one. They recently had a kitchen fire but this is the best pizza in town. It’s my absolute favorite and I can’t wait for them to reopen. The employees are also incredibly nice as well.

This is New York style pizza, big slices that you fold in half, so is unique in this area. The pizza is excellent, the sauce is terrific, and I highly recommend this place.

Excellent NY style pizza. Staff has always been helpful and pleasant. Can't wait to order from them again.

Best real NY style pizza around. The sauce is nicely balanced, not too sweet, they use real mozzarella, and the crust is the perfect balance of crispy and chewy. PM

That's Amore Pizza is amazing! Not your typical crust. Light, fresh,awesome! Stopped by again last night for another amazing pizza! When we have business in Crystal Lake, we try to plan things so we can have That's Amore pizza for dinner. The staff is always friendly and ready to take your order

Classic NYC Pizza (I would know I was born and raised in NYC till age 21. Delicious! The garlic knots are nothing to write home about but they’re free so who cares!