TOP 10 BEST Restaurants in Custer - Updated November 2024

Sage Creek Grille

77/100 (1595 ratings)

Restaurants

Vegan Options

Asian

Vegetarian Friendly

American

Gluten Free Options

Vegan Options

Vegetarian Friendly

Gluten Free Options

Lunch

Hamburgers

Beef Bolognese

Bacon Lettuce & Tomato

BLT

Barbacoa Tacos

Bolognese

Limoncello Mascarpone Cake

Daily Homemade Soup

Carrot Cake

Noodle

Almond & Panko Crusted Baked Walleye

Lettuce Wraps

Shrimp

Jamaican Fricassee Chicken Stew

Bruschette

Beef

Warm Beef Pot Roast Sandwich

Pesto

Thai Buffalo Lettuce Wraps

Fish

Pasta

Vegetable Angel Hair Pasta

Pork

Salad

Wild Alaskan Sockeye Salmon Melt

Panna Cotta

Chili

Bison Burger and blt

Risotto

Buffalo Burger with Swiss Cheese

Salmon with Risotto

Salmon

Field Greens with Goat Cheese

Sandwiches

Carrot Cake

Alaskan Melt

Burger

Crème Brûlée

Grilled cheese

Veggie Burger

Sit down

American

Wine and Beer

Parking Available

Free off-street parking

Highchairs Available

Accepts Credit Cards

Accepts Mastercard

Accepts Visa

Accepts American Express

Street Parking

Accepts Discover

Seating

Table Service

Wheelchair Accessible

Mid-range

"I have been a fan of Sage Creek Grille since it opened. Sage Creek is my go to place with friends, visitors, family. There is no other place like..."

Nancy Barker

"We have never been disappointed when we have eaten at Sage Creek Grill. We have eaten there for many years and the food has always been great. I have..."

Georgia Elley

"Had the best unexpected time. Had servers Jennifer and Walter whom are from both states we live in. Woot! The food was exceptional. Potatoes au..."

Rochelle Lanphear

"My friend and I stopped here after a long day of playing tourist. What a surprise! Meals are freshly cooked (no frozen), and each unique. I had the..."

Connie Castile-Tobin

"We went in for a light bite to eat and were very pleased with the food (buffalo lettuce wrap and salad) as well as the friendliness and atmosphere...."

Susan Montgomery Bukowski

"Had a great buffalo burger yesterday, so returned for the salad with mandarin oranges, goat cheese etc. topped with grilled chicken. All yummy! ..."

Linn Wenger Lyons

"Our waitress was super sweet. Food was excellent & both the desserts we tried were to die..."

Kellye Haughian-Thompson

"The service was impeccable. I had the chefs special steak. A 10 oz buffalo ribeye. Which was cooked perfectly the way I requested. Overall it was..."

Jody Schick

"We had an incredible experience at Sage Creek Grille. Our server, Jennifer was attentive, knowledgeable, and personable. The atmosphere is one of..."

Jenny Reddy-Theisen

"Outstanding food and excellent service. Our family of four enjoyed a lovely meal and will definitely be..."

Natalie Eisenberg

"Amazing! The Siracha carrot white bean hummus is a must! Great service, nice beer list, all..."

Beth Mriden Ormseth

"Edit: Had Lunch & went back for Dinner!!! Everything is good here. Walleye was super & the shrimp appetizer rocked! Delicious food & great vibe +..."

Michael Barndt

"Everything about this place is wonderful! The food- excellently conceived, prepared and executed- such a standout in a small town. The staff- warm,..."

Jessica Smith

"We are here for dinner while on vacation in the Black Hills area. The food was amazing, the staff were attentive and positive, and this was the best..."

Marie Nelson

"Eat here. You won't be disappointed. The menu isn't 12 pages deep, but they still offer an impressive array of exciting options. The difference..."

Daniel Johnston

"Fantastic! We were coming through town and picked this place randomly. We were pleasantly surprised -the food was fabulous. We had the “Jamaican..."

Torrey Baldwin

"Simply amazing! Staff is super friendly and work together wonderfully. The food was above and beyond our expectations. The house favorite is a..."

Mark Smith

"Great restaurant, great food and fabulous service. Everyone is so friendly starting with the cute hostess and continuing with our cute and bubbly..."

Linda

"Cute, small town bistro! I recommend the salmon, walleye and artichoke appetizer. Pasta left something to be desired. Very friendly and attentive..."

Reset

There is only one restaurant

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Noodle in Custer

Ranking

Sort A-Z

near you

Filters