Chris Barnes
It's been years since I've been to Thatcher's. Don't know why I waited so long. It was great. Service was fast and friendly. Corned beef and cabbage was delicious and a huge portion. Definitely will be back soon.
Jennifer Pickett
Love the goat cheese salad. Nice Irish pub. With tons of food options. The do trivia and they have the lottery tickets, it’s a local restaurant in denville that everyone frequents. Servers are friendly and quick. I’ve had the Buffalo chicken wrap and the
Ryan Fischlein
Went to Thatcher McGhee’s for dinner on a Wednesday night with my family. There were a decent amount of people in the “dining room” and the bar looked pretty full. It he services was great and our food came out fast dispute the number of people there.
The taste of Ireland was delicious. They give you a good portion of shepherds pie, chicken pot pie, Guinness stew and bangers with a scone on top. (See picture in clock wise order) All of the food came out piping hot and stayed hot while we were eating, no one like a cold dish.
Everyone else I was with also liked their dishes. Definitely a good place if your feeling something Irish or for a good hearty meal!
Tanya Salemme
Absolutely loved the interior, decor, and atmosphere. We had appetizers for our meal that we shared. We tried a sampler that had wings, tator tots, chicken fingers, and a pretzel. We also had the fries that came with cheese and caramelized onions and a side of gravy. Everything was hot and fresh. I don't know that I would get the fries again, as a personal preference it felt like there were too many large onions, but the gravy and cheese were delicious. I'm eager to try actual meals here soon!
Min Park
Overall not too bad of a spot. Nice large bar and multiple rooms to dine in. Food was pretty good but I think the service is lacking a bit which might be because they are understaffed. It might be too much for the server and I know they are working hard. If you done here, factor in time because it is bit on the slow side.
Cheyanna Dinkel
I recently went here for lunch, and the food that we ordered off of the "Traditional Irish" menu was phenomenal! The server we had, Michael, was so friendly and welcoming, greeting us with a big smile! He was super attentive and friendly through our entire lunch visit! The food came out fast, hot, and delicious! The prices are reasonable for the quality and quantity of food that you get, for sure! If you haven't been here yet, try it!
Ralph Colotti
Thatcher McGhee's is always consistent, food is very good, especially their monthly specials, and reasonably priced. I had the special Chicken Murphy with Shiner's Holiday Cheer on draft (my favorite holiday beer), wife had her usual corned beef sandwich, substituting a fresh salad for the French fries which normally come with the meal. We are always pleased with the food and especially the service.
Cory Colligan
I stopped in to pick up food and the place was jumping. I’ll definitely come back for some drinks, and I also ordered the Irish curry. I wouldn’t have expected those two words in the same sentence, but I stand corrected. It was delicious. Solid work 👍🏼
ML Berg
Great food. The atmosphere is up to the person, lol 😆. Old school 🏫 feel.
Dean Taylor
If you're in the mood for an authentic Irish experience and a mouthwatering Reuben sandwich, look no further than Thatcher McGhee's! This charming Irish bar and restaurant has left a lasting impression on me with its warm ambiance, friendly staff, and, of course, their delicious Reuben sandwich.
From the moment I walked through the door, I was greeted with a lively atmosphere that instantly transported me to the heart of Ireland. The rustic decor, cozy seating, and the lively chatter of patrons all contributed to an authentic Irish pub experience. Thatcher McGhee's offers a comfortable and inviting space to unwind and enjoy good company.
Now, let's talk about the star of the show - their Reuben sandwich. Always a personal favorite - this delectable creation is a true masterpiece. Not only is the Reuben top-notch, but the menu also boasts a variety of other Irish and American classics. From hearty stews to savory pies, there's something for every palate.
The service at Thatcher McGhee's is exceptional. The staff is not only friendly and attentive but also well-versed in the menu, offering recommendations and making sure your experience is nothing short of outstanding.
To complement the food, their drink selection is impressive, featuring a wide range of Irish beers, whiskey, and classic cocktails. You can pair your Reuben with the perfect beverage to elevate your dining experience.
So, if you're in search of an Irish bar that excels in both atmosphere and food quality, Thatcher McGhee's is the place to be. They have been a long time favorite location of mine and hope have many more years with them. Sláinte!
Michelle Rennert
The waitress initially was sullen and disinterested. However, with some mild redirection, she rose to the occasion and the experience immediately became first- rate. The corned beef egg rolls were delicious and gargantuan. The fish and chips portions were very generous and were sizzling and full of flavor.
Definitely a 5
Lori Vaughn-Mauro
What an amazing time we had! There were 18 of us and our server Catherine was the BEST! Everything went smooth, our food was delicious, we all had a variety of items and it all was the best! Timing was superb on the kitchen staff, well done! Thank you for a wonderful afternoon!
Barbara Rosato Delaney
Whenever we go no matter what the day or season the service and the food are excellent. Great for small and large groups… For table and bar table eating. Highly recommended.
Michael Halpin
we had high hopes! The staff was friendly and very accommodating to our 2 small children. Loved the decor and atmosphere, but we were disappointed in the authentic Irish food. My wife got the shepherds pie( all meat, very little potatoes and very oily) and i ordered the Irish breakfast( tasted stale). Maybe we'll give it one more try.
Annette Vitale Mullan
Service was great. Our server was very attentive. She was always coming over to check on us. The food was great.
Lydia Regelski
We always have a fabulous time at thatchers in Denville we get great service and always go back for more👍👍👍👍😊😊😊😊. The best tanquerary n tonic
Vinny Catanzaro
Great food, great waitress and good company. I love the goat cheese salad.
Tray Barmore
This is my favorite restaurant. I love the potato cakes and Irish meatloaf. Their chili is great and I've heard great things about their Ruben and Rachel. I recommend their shepherds pie, their Taste of Ireland is excellent. Their French onion soup is an excellent start. 🍀🍀🍀🍀🍀
Melody Mulcahey
Great Place! Was in town for a business conference and had a blast. Food was delicious and the bartenders and staff were top notch
Rona Olechnowich
Best place ever! Never had a bad meal here I love this place
Robert Sendner
Had the Sheppards pie and enjoyed it the atmosphere was nice just a little cramped in but i liked it would definitely recommend a visit to friends
Michael Avallone
Went on Mothers Day around 4:30 party of 5.
Bang no wait!! And to my surprise prices were not jacked up for Mothers Day. Service was excellent food was very good. When we left people were waiting for tables but they never made us feel rushed. Great place check it out.
Michelle Rybeck
They had Magners, that was my first clue that this establishment was legit. Atmosphere was great, you definitely feel like you're in a pub. I ordered fish and chips and it was clearly house made, just delicious. Great place, I just wish I lived closer so I could visit more often.
Daniela Kocoska Loncar
Great food, awesome decor, excellent service! Can't wait to go back and try another dish!
Jill Nagurka Perez
My first time there. Very nice place. Food was good and our waitress was awesome. Great atmosphere. Looking forward to going again.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes