This place is awsome worth the drive huge portions friendly staff great prices highly recommend
the best place ever , i have been to many ice cream spots and Frostys is by far the best . everytime i go to a new area i go where the locals say is the best and i have yet to find a place that even comes close . keep up the great work and keep doin what you are doin and you will never go wrong . and please whatever you do , don't ever close down shop you will so many sad ice cream lovers
Sylvia R Blackshire Barcomb
+5
The best ice cream around. I've tried other shops and this is by far the best of them all .
Huge ice creams for the price. Great owners who actually care about the community. Always fun and friendly. They also have the best selection and their Hours of operation are great. Always happy and leaving with a smile.
A must see in the area...love the icecream and Dave...don't miss this place...best ice cream, prices and people!!!!
Bobbe Schmelzer Lukasik
+5
Frosty’s has the best sundaes! Don’t know why they taste so good but they are awesome! Best in this area! Love the chunky chocolate chip ice cream! Price is right too!
Heather L Wilson-Brillhart
+5
My family absolutely loves Frosty's! By far their favorite ice cream place. There is always a great selection of flavors and my kids love to play on the wooden truck and bus. A true gem in the village of Lancaster!
Always a great experience! Wonderful family-owned business that never disappoints.
Thank you for making our ice cream cake for Mothers Day! Best ice cream cake we have ever had!!
A Lancaster-love of mine!! EVERYTHING is delicious, portions are indulgent and it's truly the best ice cream & atmosphere!
Best ice cream shop around!
So many choices!!! We love coming here and bringing the family...they even have a doggie sundae!
The absolute best! Creamy custard like no other! Delish!
My girls and doggy love it here! I work there when I was 15 and still a great village spot!
You were desperately looking for a last minute birthday cake, when we came across Frosty’s. They were able to make us a custom ice cream cake, and it its literally the best ice cream cake I’ve ever had. It is insanely delicious, and also very reasonably priced. The owners are super sweet and were very helpful. They did an amazing job on the artwork, and we couldn’t be happier. I highly recommend!!
Frosty’s has never let us down with one of their amazing and tasty cakes but this one really “takes the cake”. The owner really really outdid himself for my daughters second birthday cake. Wow. Just wow.
Little ice cream shack on a busy road. They have seating behind the building. It was a long line when we went but they worked it pretty quickly. We had three cones and enjoyed a quieter evening.
The first time we had visited there the parking lot was packed and the line was wrapped around so we had left.
This place is a no brainer 5 out of 5. Their menu is huge. Like if you can't find something you like, ice cream probably just isn't your thing. There is a ton of avors of dips, exotic sundaes, dole whip, a bunch of hard ice cream, the list goes on and on. I got the cannoli sundae and it was wicked good. Huge portion sizes too. Frostys is absolute gas 10/10
Visited a couple of times now, their menu is LARGE. I love all the different options though, and the different brands of ice cream plus Perry's flavors you wouldn't see outside of a scoop shop. Their portions are as large as their menu - this is a medium (3 scoops) in a dish. 4 stars because the employees seem very rushed and as a result tend to rush you, and when I tried asking questions about combining/changing menu items I was met with confusion. In order to get napkins or an extra dish, you have to basically cut someone off from receiving their order at the pickup window so someone will notice you. I felt terrible doing so. I have never been here pre-covid so I'm not sure if this is what it's like all the time, or if employees are just extra stressed right now.
Great ice cream place! There's a little play area in the back for little ones. Very cute! Will definitely go back next summer, wish they were open year round though due to their ice cream cakes.
Such a wonderful friendly place. They always have multiple yummy vegan options and all the staff are very accommodating on double checking ingredients and understanding what vegan is. Just remember they are cash only so bring some cash. They do have an ATM on site if needed.
I Love the Salted Pretzel Caramel Sundae!! Will be in weekly for one of them. Super friendly service. My favorite place to go in the summer.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes