Sluurpy > Restaurants in East Aurora > Mr. Pot Pie

Review Mr. Pot Pie - East Aurora

Amanda S
We normally go in for their short bread, it's to die for. They recently started offering fudge which is very good too. I love their macaroni and cheese to have in my freezer for a quick dinner. Their pot pies from what I hear from family are delicious (I am biased as I don't like pot pie). I highly recommend giving them a try!
Joan Williams
I ordered the chicken pot pie for a birthday luncheon for my husband. I ordered three of them. The serving size was four substantial slices per pie. Everyone raved about how delicious it was. I also ordered the Italian Bread and served both with a Caprese Salad. Absolutely wonderful. Mr. Pot Pie will be my "go to" place for informal entertaining. Cannot wait to try some of the other selections.
M C
Had the regular chicken pot pie and it was fantastic. We also tried the cheeseburger soup and seafood bisque soup. The cheeseburger soup was great as well as the bisque. Bisque was tasty, but could've use a little more meats. Still very good though. The girl working the counter was super friendly. We will be back to try more deliciousness!
Paige Rubach
Always amazing! The soup is so good! I love their pepper soup when they have it, but its seasonal. Great almond ring and caramel walnut coffee! So sad that the samples are not offered due to covid, but when they are, they are very generous. 😋
John Spooner
Outstanding chicken pot pies. Big chunks of chicken, flaky crust and low sodium. All the pies fall into the top of “wow” factor. Great soups - the seafood is my favorite. All the baked goods are top quality and most important yummy!
Joshua Gala
This place is great! The pastries, the soups, the pot pie, and the employees! Megan (not sure of spelling) is always so nice and goes above and beyond to help enjoy the visit! The only thing that would make this place perfect is having sandwiches, but the location probably wouldn't accommodate it. Great place!
Darlene Suba
Went to the one in EA. Staff was super friendly. Bought a chicken pot pie & it was so good! The crust is divine, flaky & buttery. I'll be going back to try other pies.
Donna Veit Polanski
They have about 8 different types of homemade fudge now! The soups are delicious.
A La Carte- Double Tacos Bagel Bagel Breakfast Sandwich Ham Swiss Cheese Fried Egg Everything Bagel Bagels Baguette Baked Chicken Special Bass Beef Beef on Weck Beef Sandwich Beer Battered Fish Beer Cheese Burger Birthday cake Black and Blue Cheese Burger Breakfast Sandwich Broiled Fish Fry in Panko Breading Broiled Garlic Butter Fish Burger Burnt Beef Tip Mac and Cheese with Fizzled Onions Burrito Burrito and Enchiladas Burrito Bamba Burrito California Buttermilk Chicken Sandwich Cajun Fish Fry with Sweet Potato Fries Cakes Captain Morgan and Coke Caramel Apple Pie Carne Asada with Shrimp Carnitas En Salsa Verde Champagne Cheesecake Cheesecakes Chicken and Waffles Chicken Parmesan Chicken Salad Platter Chicken Wings Chimichangas Chips and Salsa Corned Beef Hash Crab Crab Cake Crab cakes Crepes Cupcakes Depot Burger and Fries Dirt Sundae Duck E T Mocha Easter Egg Eggplant Eggs Any Style Eggs Benedict El Fogon Burrito Enchiladas Supremas Fajitas del Fogon Fajitas Texanas Filet Mignon Fish Fish and Chips Fish Sandwich Fish Taco Foamer French Onion Soup Focaccia French Fries French Onion Soup French Toast French Toast with Fresh Strawberries Fried Ice Cream Fried Onions Galleta De Zarzamora Gardeners Grilled Cheese Garlic Parmesan Chicken Fingers and Fries Great Flan Greek Omlette Grilled Cheese with Tomato Hamburger Hot Fudge Hubbard in the Cupboard Hummus Ice Cream Ice Cream Cake Ice Cream Cone IPA Hayburner Key Lime Sorbet Liver and Onions with Baked Sweet Potato Lobster Lobster Cakes Lobster Roll Lobster Roll Luncho Combo 1 Mac and cheese Macarons Macaroons Margaritas Margherita Meatloaf Meringue Mocha-Tini Molcajete Mussels Nachos Omelette Pancakes Pasta Peanut Butter Cup Peanut Butter Pie Peanut Butter Sundae Pierogies Pork Tenderloin Pretzel Quesadilla Quiche Red Snapper with Blueberry Reduction Ribs Risotto Roast Beef S'mores Salad Salad bar Salmon Salmon Entree Sandwiches Scallops Sea Salt Caramel Coffee Seattle Mocha Latte Sheet Cake Shrimp Spaghetti with Meatballs Spinach Tomato Feta Omelet Zucchini Home Fries Sprinkles Sunrise Benedict Tacos Tapas Taste's Breakfast Sandwich The Chicken Pesto Panini Three Soft Shell Tacos Tiramisu French Toast Toasts Tortillas Tuna Melt Waffle Waffle Fries Waffles Waffles & Crepes West Coast Toast Wings
Share on WhastApp
Share on Facebook
Browse the menu
Add review
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use