Amazing homemade pizza and other Italian food at very reasonable prices. Friendly comfortable atmosphere. Helpful, knowledgeable staff and fast service. If you have never tried Mario's Pizza do yourself a favor and try it. You won't regret it!
Dr. Robert Kassoff (Dr. Bob Kassoff)
+5
This was for pick up of a pie half meatball and half mushroom. Pie was well baked adequate amounts of cheese and sauce. Generous toppings of meatballs and mushroom. I would buy there again.
I have enjoyed this pizza on many occasions . They make a quality pie . My favorite is the veggie slices . they hold up to the weight and are crispy and delicious
I had the balsamic pizza slice ...was delicious...staff friendly.. ..nice clean family pizzeria...I also took home a regular whole pie too...
Love it!! Everyone is so friendly
Wish you were on too good too go!!
I chose eggplant parmisian and a Cesar salad. The eggplant was thinly sliced, tender and cooked perfectly. The sauce was sweet but not overly sweet. The Cesar salad was the best I have had in a long, long time, with many shaved pieces of delicious cheese.
This was a delivery by Mario's. The food came earlier than advised and was piping hot and the salad was chilled.
It is no wonder we changed from their competitors.
Great local place to get a slice or a whole meal. Generous portions!
I love Mario’s pizzeria! I’m always greeted with a smile. The staff is very nice and attentive. Matt the manager is awesome as well and always courteous and and always looks out for you. Oh and of course the pizza is amazing. My favorites are their grandma ala vodka and buffalo chicken slice. I’ve been to every pizzeria in east northport and some have good pizza but none have the level of service and great food you get at Mario’s. Sometimes that means more than anything else.
pretty good. they have great discounts on their website and sometimes even offer deals on apps like doordash, though they have a great ordering system on their website as well where you can earn rewards and such and even get something for free when it’s your birthday. overall, great local pizza shop to go to!
One of my favorite pizzerias in this area. Never a long wait and always perfect ratios of cheese to sauce to toppings. Each slice tastes like nostalgia, and is enough to satisfy an average person as a meal. Garlic knots are pretty mediocre, but that doesn’t mean they’re bad, they’re just nothing special if that’s what you’re looking for.
My biggest complaint is the prices. I would give three stars if the pizza wasn’t as tasty as it is (although I probably am a bit biased being that I grew up on this food) they’re just way too much. Never good deals or anything. There really isn’t a good reason for the prices. But most in this area have quite a few bucks to spare so it shouldn’t be too much of an issue.
I tried them for my first time over the weekend and it was excellent! I had a sicilian Mario's special and a regular pie. I've had sicilian pies with meat before but they become too soggy. This one was perfect, I will definitely be ordering again. In fact I think I will be a regular ;)
Established in 69, the tradition was still there. Great sauce. The crust was cooked on the money and all the flavors came together. Not bad at all for a long island pizza joint! Clean and up to date. Not that old school is not great but you can tell it was well kept, the passion was there!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes