Best pizzeria on the Island imho, especially if you're a specialty pizza nut, like myself. The stuffed slices are enormous... plan on sharing ;) The variety of slices immediately available, is mind-boggling! Try stuffed mac n cheese. We went late on a Sunday night recently and everything we wanted was right there. Their prices are very reasonable, everything is delicious, and we always end up with leftovers. I no longer live in the area, but whenever I am, I make sure I stop at Paradise Pizza!
Best Eggplant Parm and Lasagna around. Always polite and friendly service in person or on the phone and quick delivery. Sauce tastes just like my Grandmas so it really takes me back.
It is the best pizza place I have ever been to. I love the pasta too. It is amazing. I would rank Johnny's Paradise pizza number 1.
Bjorn lienemann (Vikings Computer Repair)
+4
Awesome prices. I go there for times a week. Never got a free slice yet lol. If I did I'd give a five star.
I come all the way from Commack to eat this food. It is the best around! And the staff is friendly and helpful and generous!
Try the baked ziti, it is terrific!
Best pizza around! Super friendly staff and they get your pizza ready very quick!
Fantastic pizza. Ziti and chicken parmesan trays are great for family gatherings. Great service as well.
This is where we get our pizza. Great selection and awesome food
Great food and the service is great I recommend every one come here
The customer service is constantly prompt, lovely mood, very kind staff. I will come back again when I arrive in the area.
This place changed hands a couple years back went through a remodel ,but just couldn't make it . The original owner came back in and put the business back to the way it was with the great food and service too.
Been coming here for over 15 years, or as long as I can remember. Hands down the best around.
Best pizza in town , glad they're back
Vodka slices!!!.. and pretty much everything else.
Best pizza in town by far
Johnny's is the best on long Island
The BEST eggplant parmesan!!!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes