Linda Dickman
Beautiful presentation, great food as always. We had a small Greek salad with chicken gyro meat on top.
Phil T B
Great food! The owner is a great person! Service is always fast.
Cristen Ryan
This is probably the best place to get Greek food in East Northport. But, I used to live in South Nassau, near the Queens border, and the Greek food in that area is much better. Their lamb gyro is good. Their salads are also good. Tzatziki sauce is too heavy on the dill. They don’t offer shaved meat.
Debbie Donahue
This is the best place in northport-east northport to get greek salad. The chicken was so tender not tuff or like bubble gum the salad was excellent even the tomatoes. We just happened to try it after a long time. So glad we did. This will be our new place for the best Greek food.
Mike Salvatore (Mike)
Hidden Greek Gem. Gyros the way I remember them from Astoria. The Gyros are the bomb, best I've ever had since the 1980s and their Yogurt sauce is not overwhelming and just perfect! I promise you will not be disappointed!
Tim Sullivan
BEST falafel and Greek salads on the Island, hands down!!!!! Good, quality FRESH food prepared quickly. Bonus since it's literally across the street from my job.
Rob
been going there 20 plus yrs. No one compares. My family loves gyro night!! Thanks Athens
Could use a new card reader machine! But still worth the wait
Lori Bockelken
I moved to Rocky Point almost three years ago and have not found a Greek place that compares to Athens Square! So tonight’s meal was amazing!! I wish there were duplicates of this tasty deliciousness out east!!
CPNY
I had takeout from there the other night and I enjoyed it. Fresh ingredients and friendly service. Price is average.
Ebony Washington
This restaurant is absolutely AMAZING!!! Our server John was so professional, great manners, and so down-to-earth. The prices are great and the quality of the food is truly off the hook! Please come visit my buddy John, (server)! Awesome job Athens Square Cafe!
liam kilroy
Very small dining area but the food is very good. Never had a bad meal here my family and I have been coming to the Athens square cafe for 15 years now. The owner is always in the back cooking food and is very passionate about his business but is never shy about coming out to say hello and great you. Throughout the years there have been good and bad waitresses but the owner and the food is what keeps us coming back he truly makes you feel like part of the family.
Lorrie Francis
Good food consistently for the last 15 years. Friendly owners, kind staff. Not sure where people complaining about prices are used to eating. $35 for dinner for 3 sounds pretty reasonable to me.
William Conway
Food is always good. We always take out. They never botch the order or forget something and the staff is always really friendly and appreciative. Definitely a business worth supporting.
Tomy
Amazing service to start with! Waitress Eva was super friendly with a great sense of humor!!
The food, I felt like I was eating in Greece again! Their yogurt sauce is second to none!!!
Heather Woods
I don't live locally anymore but any time I come around to visit, the first place I stop for food is Athens Square Café. This is the place that made me realize my love of gyros and even more importantly tatziki sauce. If I could marry this restaurant I would, that it how amazing it is. I've been around the Greek restaurant world a bit (live near Astoria now, Greek central) but my forever favorite will always be Athens Square Café 💞
Phil Dalton
Lived here for 13 years, and am very happy I just found this place. As a native of Chicago, I am a big gyro fan. I've beed sad that I can't get a good gyro here. Well, this place has, far and away, the finest gyros I've had in years. Athens Square, thank you for existing!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Erica Roy
The best!! If you're looking for delicious authentic Greek cuisine, this is the place to be!!
Effie M. Traitses
The food is delicious and you can tell it is prepared with care and authenticity. The owner is caring and very nice. Great atmosphere!
Tina DeLuca Tsourtsoulas
The gyros are fabulous!!!!!!! Everything served is prepared meticulously and fresh- with an authentic Greek flair!
Samantha Boutis
The most fantastic food!! Cooked with love from Greece!!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes