I travel all over the country, and surprisingly, this may just as well be the best slice of Pizza Ive had yet!! It was a fluke i stopped by, but I'm glad I did. Mine was a slice with a sausage and pepperoni. Sausage was a meal in itself. Bravo!!!
The pizza is delicious here as is everything else on the menu. I love the sausage, peppers & onions, absolutely out of this world. Whenever I’m in Eastchester I just have to visit the store.
My one wish is that they would open a store in White Plains.
Love these guys, they really are the nicest people you’ll ever meet, and as for the pizza, I believe it’s the best around. Totally recommended.
As a regular customer to Louie & Ernie’s I had to stop by Cosimo & Johnny’s. The pizza is everything I had expected. Sausage slice is the way to go. Brought home Sicilian and a regular Pie. New location is very nice. Service with a smile.
Whether it's white pizza or red...you win.
Delicious 😋.
I really enjoyed my stay here, people are very polite, very relaxing environment that allows you to eat in peace with no outside noise & they even had the basketball game on the tv. Very cool. Definitely recommend the food!
I bought one pie, and I kept coming back, even though it was out of my way for 15 minutes. The family feeling of the store was welcoming, the food delicious, and the vibe warm and pleasant.
Some of the most delicious pizza around! Perfect thin crust, just the right amount of sauce and cheese. And top it with some of the most delicious sausage and garlic for a delicious slice!
This is by FAR the best pizza in the eastchester/tuckahoe area.
It might be one of the best in Westchester county.
Great pizza. They need to add grilled chicken salads to their menu. TIGHT Parking, small restaurant.
Excellent pizza in an area with a lot of competition. The crust is perfect the sauce is awesome.
Everyone seems to have covered the Pizza but don’t sleep on their Calzones. Traditional Calzone is deep fried not baked…..excellent and the Broccoli Rabe Calzone is in a class by itself!!!!!!
Thanx to Cosmo and family for bringing old school Louie and Ernie’s quality to Westchester.
Favorite pizza in Westchester. I grew up in Mount Vernon and was introduced at an early age to the authentic, delicious pizza in Fleetwood. A high bar was set. I then spent my adult years living in NYC and having access to Little Italy's best pizzeria's, among others. A higher bar was set. All that said, at Cosimo and Johnny's, everything is perfectly focused on quality and taste - sauce and crust especially. The owner and staff are so accommodating and pizza-positive. One time I was late picking up my pizza - they close at 8:30 and waited for me until 8:40. Another time I was given a free pizza at the end of the night b/c someone didn't pick up their pizza. Now that is going above and beyond. I love the way they are old-school, and only focus on Pizza and Calzone's - nothing to distract them from making exceptional local Pizza. Keep up the great pizza-making. (Oh - and just a side-note: the bathrooms are super clean which I always appreciate; extremely rare for a pizza place).
Always great pizza. The Sicilian and regular pies have great crust and cheese. Love the tomato slice and the calzones are a must try.
Delicious pizza service is great and very friendly atmosphere
Great vibe in this neighborhood, family pizza parlor. Super friendly service. Great indoor and outdoor seating. Clean and happy place. Decent slice. Love their ham and cheese calzone. Closes early.
Storage clean and well maintained they have a nice variety of pizzas that are fresh and tasty. It is a pizza shop that I stop by often and look forward to the experience of having a great pizza. In other sorted types of sandwiches. All things that I have tried taste pretty good I would tell anyone in the neighborhood to stop by you'll enjoy this pizzeria.
We eat a lot of pizza in my house. This is very good pizza!! What I think of when I think of NY Pizzeria. I would say it probably the Best Pizzeria in Eastchester! Slices were served fresh – not bready but crisp. And we were very well attended to. No leftovers - to take home, clean plates.
I’ve had pizza up and down the east coast this is true example of classical ny pizza!!
So happy this place is here, Same owners of Louie and Ernie’s in the Bronx. Excellent thin crust , tasty sauce, sausage is good too. We always order half cheese, half sausage.
We used to drive to the Bronx just for pizza but found Gino’s which is great too but Cosimo and Johnnys is our #1 spot. They’re now on UberEats which is great. Not sure if it’s still cash only in store.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes