Sluurpy
Reset

There are 6 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Calamari in Edgartown

There are 6 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
The Port Hunter
88/100 (1044 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Bar
Seafood
Vegan Options
American
Seafood
American
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Dinner
Late Night
Cakes
Calamares
Sandwiches
Vegan Risotto
Jalapeño Cilantro
Pesto
Burger
Halibut
Fish
French Fries
Burrata
Chowder
Shrimp
Cheeseburger
Red wine
Tapas
Kale Salad
tostada
Fish Taco
Curry Mussels
Tacos
Lobster
Tuna Special
Halibut
Pasta
Famous Chicken Sandwich
Curry
Salad
Buffalo Brussel Sprouts
Portside Spritz
Toasts
Clams
Fish Delish
Caprese Salad
Chicken Sandwich
Oyster
Elote
Key lime pie
Calamari
Fresh Oysters
Hanger steak
Mussels
Asparagus
Kale Salad
Tuna
Brussels Sprouts
Sit down
American
Seafood
Bar
Serves Alcohol
Full Bar
Outdoor Seating
Television
Live Music
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Late Night
Dinner
Mid-range
"This place is clearly very popular because there was a queue outside the restaurant before it opened for 5:30 p.m. dinner service on a very rainy..."
Jane Ma Nolan
"Nice ambience. Food was generally good. I got fish tacos which were underwhelming but other fish dishes, especially the specials, were fantastic...."
Fel Madi
"We stopped here for apps and it was great. We sat at the bar and the corn appetizer was incredible as was the Brussels sprouts. They have some..."
Andy McNeill
"Awesome food. The brussel sprouts appetizer ('buffalo brussels') was about the best thing I've ever had - flavor explosion. I also adored the salad..."
Lisa Murakami
"came on a wednesday evening. reservations were totally booked for a month but luckily the bar is first come first serve. we ordered an IPA and an..."
Rachel Con
"This is fine dining with superb food! However, you will never put a fork down without one of the empty plate hunters picking it up to move you..."
jeff hebert
"Fantastic dinning experience in Edgartown. We had the ceviche whoch was very wel excecuted. The kale amd fennel salad was very balanced with the..."
Juan Uribe
"I always love their cocktails and food. Creative menu that doesn’t break the bank. Great oysters too. Sit at the bar, it’s a perfect way to enjoy..."
Scott Matus
"I am not a foodie, but what I can tell you is my experience overall here was absolutely fantastic! From the moment we spoke to the hostess we were..."
Mark Alexander
"The food was amazing and drinks were just as good. Prices are a little higher than other places in the area, but worth it for the..."
Bryan Greene
"My favorite place in Edgartown! I’ve been coming here for years and always go several times when I am here. The food, drinks, service and..."
Dan Colucci
"The fish tacos are an ABSOLUTE must!! So fresh and not too heavy. Buffalo Brussel sprouts were also a must have. Inside is nice for a drink as well...."
Christan Nicklas
"We enjoyed our dinner here. It was a little busy so they said we could sit at the raw bar. We did, the guy running the raw bar was great. He was..."
Daniel Haughey
Atria
87/100 (927 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
American
American
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Dinner
Late Night
Calamares
Burger
Hamburgers
Cod
Shrimp
Swordfish
Beef
Halibut
Foie gras
Ribs
Lobster
Pasta
Bass
Salad
Prosciutto
Crab
Lamb
Scallops
Pesto
Duck
Fish
Calamari
Pork
Tuna
Sit down
American
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Full Bar
Outdoor Seating
Private Dining
Late Night
Dinner
Fine Dining
"Loved everything about it We were there for a wedding reception We were outside under the covered space which was just beautiful and had dinner out..."
Lloyd Chet Lewis
"My husband and I held our ceremony and reception outside on 6/22/18 and could not have had a better day! We started planning earlier in the year and..."
Jessica Knight
"Great food. Service was excellent. Drinks were out of this world. Highly recommend the wok fried lobster and the last day on earth..."
Robert DiPadova Jr
"The best dining experience you could get on the island. Excellent food, amazing wine selection from all over the world, beautiful bar with craft..."
Ralitsa Ivanova
"The best burgers to be found on the island!! I had the BBQ Brisket burger with truffle fries. Absolutley..."
David Robertson
"Every single dish I have ever had from Chef Christian Thornton is amazing. So much so that I find it impossible to eat any meal I have had from his..."
Clair Carroll Koroma
"Atria was the most spectacular venue to host a rehearsal dinner for my son and daughter-in-law. Everything about the evening was perfect. The food..."
Dawson Moore Greenland
"Spectacular! From the arrival greeting by Greer to the table greeting by Rock our superb waiter, on to reading the clever and informative menu, to..."
Tom Boerger
"Our favorite fine dining restaurant on all of Martha's Vineyard. Whatever we choose to eat off of the menu is delicious and absolutely..."
India Rose
"Greer and staff, I want to thank you for an amazing experience, my wedding was fabulously tended, you are the best there is, We couldn't have asked..."
Glenda Rose
"10 years ago my husband and I had our Rehearsal Dinner here. It was truly a memorable evening with family and friends. Last evening my husband and I..."
Jennifer Petty
"Delicious upscale cuisine and impeccable service upstairs. Perfect burger and truffle fries downstairs. Great anytime! But they also put on the best..."
Lisa Gilberto-Cunningham
"Always a great dining experience - elegant yet comfortable atmosphere, great service and scrumptious..."
Dina Salvatore BenDavid
"Great food! Great location! Burgers are amazing and the truffle fries are to die for! MV ❤️..."
Rose Walsh
"I can’t hardly wait to get back here every year. Burgers in basement seriously rock. Fast Eddie with jalapeños and gorgeous bottle of red...."
Sandi McBeth Ennor
"Our family has been eating here every summer for the past ten years and somehow they continue to blow us away. Tonight cocktails, apps, entrees,..."
Jeff Zilberfarb
"This is probably one of the best, if not THE best restaurant on the island. The attention to detail was incredibly impressive, from the choice of..."
Steven Pego
"I had the pleasure of dining at Atria in Martha's Vineyard with my wife yesterday and we were blown away by the experience. From the moment we..."
Joe Paul
"In the top two of our favorite dinners on the island, and also one of our most expensive meals as well (two cocktails were almost $50). For that..."
Natalie Caldwell
"Atria has an amazing atmosphere and incredible food and drink. We shared several appetizers and each was incredible in both presentation and taste...."
emily balog
"Conflicting feelings about Atria…. Let’s start with the good: atmosphere. The place is beautiful, and it’s got great vibes. The lobster /..."
Richard Levins
"Food and service was great. Cocktails were average $15, but they packed a punch. They have three sitting areas (main floor, patio, basement) but both..."
Alex Alapatt
"Atria is hands down our favorite restaurant on the island! We have been going for the past 5 years and it never disappoints. This year Greer hosted..."
Arika Vissers
"Exactly what comes to mind when envisioning a fine dining experience. Their Staff go the extra mile to be pleasant, from hostess station, table..."
Linda D. Gaines
"Best restaurant on the island! Whether you want a fancy special occasion dinner or (like me) just want to hang out at the cellar bar. Prices are high..."
Lisa Bruce
Wharf Pub & Restaurant
87/100 (1012 ratings)
Restaurants
Bar
Pub
Seafood
Seafood
American
Bar
Pub
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
American
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Late Night
Dinner
Lunch
Swordfish
Clam Chowder
Chowder Fries
Fish Sandwich
Chili
10oz NY Strip & Fries with Horseradish Cream
Sandwiches
Fish & chips
French Fries
Jambalaja
Burger
Hamburgers
Nachos
Scallops
Cobb Salad
Clams
Pesto
Oyster
Broccoli
Calamari
Potato Skins
Mussels
Shrimp
NY Strip Steak
Calamares
Salmon
Beef
Fishermans Platter
Fish
Mango Margarita
Paninis
Mozzarella Panini
Espresso
Cocktail
Fried Dill Pickle Chips
Crab Cake
Lobster
Fish & Chips
Fried calamari
Seared Wordfish with Asparagus and Potatoes
Fish & Chips
Pasta
Steak Frites
Washington Apple Martini
Lobster Roll
Salad
Lobster Roll
Friday Special Prime Rib and a Burger
Cod
Wings
Linguine & Clams
Sit down
American
Bar
Pub
Seafood
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Takeout
Television
Dinner
Late Night
Lunch
Mid-range
"I've been coming here for years and have never once been disappointed. The food is always on point, the portions are quite generous and the staff is..."
Ken McGahee
"Just had dinner there this week. The Mussels are the best I’ve had on the Island. The meatloaf was also excellent. My wife Had the vegetable..."
Samuel A Kistler
"This is a def go to place for great food and service, one of the..."
Mikey Waters
"The service was great. The prices were affordable for a large family. I had the clam chowder over French fries and it was the best thing I've eaten..."
Cristina Negrón Mitusina
"The food at The Wharf Pub is excellent! My companions and I stopped in for lunch (as well as the opportunity to meet Jeff Voorhees, manager, who..."
David Bigelow
"Best people, excellent food, friendly and just a great all around place to visit, have a snack, have a drink or a meal, it's all..."
Laurel Clontz Beaulieu
"Alex Kintner signed my Jaws book, told stories from filming, and took photos with us. That alone was worth the price of admission. The wonderful..."
Stephen Demmer
"I remember getting my honor roll gift certificate in the late 1980s and taking my parents to the Wharf. Finally got to bring my own. Thank you for..."
Erikas Aleksander
"Since we stayed right down the street, it was our "go to place". We traveled to different places on the Island but would return nightly and head for..."
Vinny Cruz
"Nice location in the center of Edgartown, Martha’s Vineyard cozy pub dining with a good variety and good..."
Jeanne Spillane Allard
"Excellent service!!! Great place to eat with family and friends👏One of our favorite places to eat!! The owners are wonderful!!! 5 stars all the..."
Tracy Ann Malowski
"Awesome awesome fish and chips calamari outstanding people the service is great excellent music you can never go wrong if you are at the vineyard..."
Joe Rehm
"We went to the Wharf after a dear friends mother's funeral. It was her mother's wishes after her service for all involved to go & get drunk. Well, we..."
Marc & Robin O'Donnell
"Excellent location and the food quality matches it. The chowder fries definitely stand out and are a must-try here. We ordered the pastrami with side..."
Swagat Mishra
"Ended up here 3 times on a work trip. Ordered steak frites all 3 times…the 2 orders I had at night were amazing, cooked perfectly, had the perfect..."
kevin Sivanthong
"A little confusing at first but once someone greeted us we were seated immediately. Food was pretty good. Drinks were okay. Service was marginal but..."
Blake Thomas
"We left Oak Bluffs due to a power outage and went to Edgartown by bus. We looked for a well-rated place that wasn’t on the main drag and found the..."
Dana Smith
"We had a great family meal out at the Wharf. Eddie our waiter was incredible. He was very kind to our son and even let him pet a lobster. Food was..."
Nicole Kopaczewski
"This place is a gem!! Jack, our waiter was absolutely amazing, food could not have been better, 5 stars all the way! If I could give 10 stars I..."
sharon Meyer
"Good food, small simple menu that is seafood based. There is a handful of vegetarian options that worked well for my wife. Portions were large and..."
Cyril Moore
"The food was good. It's a bit pricey. The waitress seemed..."
T S
"This is a great place to go if you’re looking for picky foods with a casual & chill experience. The customer service was great and all of the food..."
Shauna Lynch
"Casual atmosphere, good food and friendly staff. Interesting house drinks and an impressive selection of..."
Martin Schwartz
Atlantic Fish & Chop House
78/100 (1663 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegan Options
Seafood
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
American
Seafood
Vegan Options
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Late Night
Dinner
Lunch
Chocolate cake
Peach Liquor
French Fries
Crab
Lobster Arugula Salad
Crab cakes
Clams
Atlantic Clam Chowder
Sandwiches
osso bucco
Oyster
Lobster Croissant
Burger
Grilled cheese
Octopus
Calamari
BLT
Mussels
Carrot Cake
Tuna
Shrimp
Calamares
Beef
Skirt Steak
Salmon
Octopus
Filet Mignon
Ceviche
Crab Cake
Lobster
Kale Salad
Kobe Beef
Chowder
Pasta
Truffle French Fries
Cakes
Lamb
Snow Crab Guacamole
Lobster Roll
Salad
Ahí Tuna Sashimi
Pesto
Broiled King Crab Legs
Cod
Clam Chowder
Char-Broiled Oysters
Fish
Pistachios Baklava
Swordfish
Mac and cheese
Black Truffle Lobster Mac & Cheese
Pork
Sautéed Pei Mussels
Halibut
Grilled Bacon
Sit down
Seafood
American
Live Music
Waterfront
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Television
Dinner
Late Night
Lunch
Fine Dining
"A great spot! We came for a snack between lunch and dinner. The drinks were AMAZING especially La Rose De Paris - absolutely the best cocktail I’ve..."
Samantha Knight
"Food was good not memorable. Shisito peppers had too much cheese. The fries and bacon was good. Lobster salad was decent, too many craisins and..."
NY chinchilla
"Perfect lunch spot for the whole family! This was our first time in Martha’s Vineyard and The Atlantic Restaurant was a great star. We sat outside..."
Joseph Adelantar
"My wife and I had a very nice dinner here, with a partial view of the marina. Don’t worry if you see a long line outside, because what appears to..."
Jeff F
"We had a party of 10 including an 18 month old. They accommodated us no problem. The server recommended several dishes so we ordered a few and our..."
John Lake
"Food and scenery is picture perfect! We sat outside, right near the docks, which made for a great backdrop as the sun began to set. If you're looking..."
Antonio Caban
"Amazing! Great food and service! Delicious!!! I had lamb shawarma which was perfect! We also ordered large $200 appetizer set (get it! Worth every..."
Slava B
"Fresh and excellent foods and drink. The server was really nice. I dont know what ppl talked about in these reviews, but sometimes you could miss..."
P S.
"A tale of two experiences. First, the good: the food. The chef is absolutely not afraid of flavor, and I found myself being taken on an absolute TRIP..."
Richard Levins
"Great setting by the water. Went for lunch with wife and two kids (10 & 7). No kids menu but the kids got a burger and lobster Mac & cheese. No..."
Sean Middleton
"The Atlantic has such a great view and if it's your first time on island, I always recommend this for lunch. For the seafood lovers - order the..."
Marnely Murray
"Part of what makes a trip to Martha's Vineyard soo great. Wonderful dining experience. Forrest was an extremely attentive waiter and very well versed..."
Derek Bart
"This may be our favorite restaurant on the island, especially when you can get a seat outside overlooking Edgartown Harbor. Food is always excellent..."
Bill Yelenak
The Seafood Shanty
77/100 (4347 ratings)
Restaurants
Bar
Vegan Options
Sushi
Sushi
Vegetarian Friendly
Seafood
Gluten Free Options
American
Seafood
American
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Lunch
Chocolate Cake for Two
Swordfish
Oyster
Surf & Turf
Sandwiches
Vegan Avocado Roll
Fish Sandwich
Calamari
Fish Sandwich
Burger
Chocolate Layer Cake for Two
French Fries
Mussels
Flourless Chocolate Torte
Tuna
Calamares
Shrimp
Fish & chips
Chicken Sandwich
Salmon
Lobster
Mudslide
Crab Cake
Chowder
Pasta
Shrimp Scampi
Cakes
Fish & Chips
Salad
Dark and Stormy
Pesto
Lobster Roll
Clam Chowder
Shrimp Cocktail
Fish
caesar salad
Fried Whole Belly Clams
Tapas
New England Clam Chowder
Oysters
Hot Buttered Lobster Roll with French Fries
Fish Taco
Crab
Fish & Chips
Mussels Shanty Style
Tacos
Scallops
Salmon Salad
Fish Tacos with Pineapple Mango Salsa
Fried Clams
Clams
Fried Shrimp
Sit down
Seafood
American
Bar
Sushi
Television
Reservations
Waterfront
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Our first time at Seafood Shanty and we were quite pleased. The restaurant was a bit empty on Thursday in October, which I feel may have made the..."
Patrick
"Great service! Amazing food. Our server Kosal S was so attentive. I just had the best pan seared tuna sandwich ever! We also had the Shanty's..."
Yamilet Gonzalez
"I love this place. If it’s nice outside this is the go to place in Edgartown to dine and drink and enjoy views of the water. The food was so good...."
Adam Kotzman
"On a glorious sunny day in late September we sat out on the deck and enjoyed the views of the harbor. The portions were more than adequate, and the..."
Robert Golenbock
"Having read multiple reviews and having looked at a number of menus while walking around Edgartown, we decided on the Seafood Shanty for..."
Steve in NEPA
"Really loved this place! The service was top notch. I got the cold lobster roll and a few pieces were pretty fishy. It was a really good size though...."
Samantha Mackowitz
"Fantastic view! Get there when they open at 11 AM - people were already lining up. We tried the oysters, 1/2 lb lobster, fish tacos, and tuna steak..."
Emma Johns
"This place was incredible!! The warm lobster roll with butter is the best I've ever had. A MUST on the..."
Lovesexxee Love
"Fast service. Kind staff. Good food. Ninety minutes for a table, but you didn’t even need that long with how quickly the food came out. The Bloody..."
Natalie Caldwell
"Fried calamari and lobster roll were large and delicious. The fish taco was overcooked. Service was friendly and super fast. Make sure you dine..."
Ruibing Wang
"First up, Louis the manager is good man and made everyone that walked in feel welcomed and at home. He takes tremendous pride in his restaurant and..."
Gene Waxman
"What a great place, fantastic views, great service and really good pub grub. The calamari starter with a tangy side sauce was fantastic. Our waiter..."
B MORENO
"Fresh, delicious, and fun place!! Loved getting to watch the boats in the marina while eating outside. The food was..."
Michelle Carmeli
"Amazing experience. Excellent view of the boats moving in and out. Wife and I ordered way too much, but lived it all. Drinks were delicious and..."
Wilson Good
"Absolutely a must visit! We came in October, and noticed the hours the restaurant was open weren't dinner friendly (11am-5pm) so we stopped in for a..."
Katie Boudreau
"Always a go to during the summer. The only sand beach bar on island. Great menu for all including the kids. From fine lobster rolls to the food to..."
Brian “Bmanpitt” Pitcher
"Favorite lunch spot on the vineyard! Amazing views, great cocktails and fabulous food! I ordered the hot lobster roll and my husband ordered the fish..."
Taylor Coombs
The Newes From America
74/100 (1204 ratings)
Restaurants
Bar
Pub
Bar
Pub
Soups
Vegetarian Friendly
American
Soups
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Late Night
Brunch
Dinner
Lunch
Clam Chowder
Mac and cheese
Burger
Crab
Hamburgers
Calamari
Calamares
Fish & Chips
Lobster Roll
Shrimp
Haddock
Beef
Ribs
Fish & chips
French Fries
Bangers And Mash
Lobster
Chicken Sandwich
Veggie Burger
Pasta
Cakes
Salad
Fish
Wings
Sit down
Bar
American
Pub
Soups
Free Wifi
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Television
Seating
Live Music
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Brunch
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Mid-range
"The food was excellent and worth the wait. Even in the off season it was busy for lunch (always a good sign) and food took a bit longer than..."
Patti Wakefield
"Best lobstah roll on the island, no comparison. A regular stop when I'm in..."
Jim Jingozian
"We had the Bangers and a Reubrn. Great meal. We've been fans since day one, never a..."
Larry Nuesch
"My experience at the Kelley House was the absolute perfect end to our stay on island. Very rarely would I say that I would plan a trip around a..."
Renee Hirschberg
"Worth the 360 mile drive! Great food and great..."
Nick Persons
"Loved the food and atmosphere! Had the fish and chips and husband had the pasta bolognaaise. It was a chilly rainy day so this was a great..."
Leslie Frye
"We love being greeted by Ester! Service was great food..."
Heidi Matthews Cantin
"I loved our waitress and the hostess Esther has such a great personality, she makes you want to go back just to say hello. She makes all customers..."
Sandy Mcnamee Bruscino
"Have loved The Newes for years and years. Love seeing Esther too....took a selfie with this amazing woman too. Keep being Great! Be back..."
Greg H. Goodman
"Great place for a spot of luncheon during our day on the Island during our trip from London to Boston and Cape..."
David Hastings
"Always a favorite spot. Doug is a great bar tender! ..."
Meghan Gravander Lavetsky
"Consistantly delicious food and service! Love the French Dip and Beer..."
Lauren Giglio
"Love the News! The food, atmosphere and the wait staff. So glad they are back open for..."
Janet Scott
"Great cozy decor and vibe. Very attentive service and adorable waiters. Fish and chips were yum but pass on the overpriced tomato bisque and wedge..."
Dominique Callimanopulos
"Great service. The food was good, but the salad tasted like water, no salad dressing on it. The atmosphere was good. It just needs better lighting...."
Amanda Bettencourt
"Amazing food! I had the best fish and chips on the island! The staff was..."
Emma Bainbridge
"Great spot to have dinner. The Maple ale was great too. I had the fish and chips and it was great. We had about 10 people with us and they..."
J. Jackson
"Open year round, the Newes is just such a cozy spot, with a fireplace for those cold, snowy days. And the perfect meal? A bowl of their French Onion..."
Marnely Murray
"Sat outside on a warm summer day. Beer selection was excellent and typical but delicious pub food. Highly..."
Alison Moon
"A classic for Martha's vineyard not to be missed. It is one of the few reasonably priced restaurants on the..."
Michael Teiger
"We stopped here for lunch and my wife and I both had excellent salads. the garden salad was good but very basic while to the Caesar salad with..."
Rich Hardie
"We are so passionate about every costumer service. We always love to see smiles on their faces when every they come in to eat for lunch or..."
cassandra edwards
"I love the atmosphere. You feel like you are in an English pub. The food is Fab. Truffle fries outstanding. Lobster Mac and cheese decadent and..."
Mary McDaniel
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use