Sluurpy
Reset

There are 5 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Ice Cream in Edgartown

There are 5 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
The Right Fork Diner
84/100 (749 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
American
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Diner
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Brunch
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Corned Beef
Ice Cream
Salad
Cobb Salad
Crab
Lobster Roll
Ribs
Burger
Burrito
French Toast
Breakfast Burrito
Toasts
Lobster
Omelette
Pancakes
"This place is not only great for lunch, but if you have the chance to stop in for breakfast, do it! Get the fried chicken eggs Benedict over polenta..."
Marnely Murray
"We love this place, especially for breakfast! Great place to take children and fun to watch the planes take off and..."
Carol Martin
"Always awesome! The first place we head to when we get off of the..."
Joanne Trotta
"The food is awesome, the staff kind and knowledgeable- this place is amazing.... My fav on the..."
Mj Sansouci
"Had the corned beef hash, which was amazing, and sat out on the deck. Great spot to fly in, grab some really good food and enjoy the airport. I'll..."
Chris Adams
"Amazing food. Had the eggs bennidict and hash browns, which were nicely seasoned and fresh from the kitchen. The coffee was even good, and if you..."
Megan Milo
"For a diner they have an amazing menu. The food is and has been delicious. Keep up the great..."
Jane Erris Kuttner
"Charming, delightful and most of all, delicious. Had the Lobster hash one day and came back the next for Lobster Benedict on polenta with th a side..."
Nancy Natow Cassidy
"Great food and great amusement when the planes are flying. Our grandson enjoyed both the blueberry pancakes and the little planes. As usual, we..."
Terry O Martinson
"Fantastic!! Service , generous portions !! Yikes you could split..."
Paula DeStefano
"Absolutely amazing food, top 2 or 3 breakfast spot I’ve been anywhere in the world, hands down...and you get the cool little grass airfield with..."
Pete Carrillo
"Great food and fast service! We tried the Lobster Benedict, French toast brioche and corned beef hash. All were fantastic. Cool place to eat..."
IVY POHL
"Great food with even better location! Situated on Katama Airfield, this diner offers more than most restaurants could, with front row seats to..."
Gregory Goodrich
"Great spot. Amazing food, beautiful location and incredible staff. Well worth the wait, enjoy a cocktail while waiting on your..."
Justin Cecil
"The Right Fork Diner is a great spot for either breakfast, lunch, or dinner. You just might have to wait in a..."
Christopher Guerin
"Very delicious lobster roll plus you are entertained by the vintage..."
Jennie Wobeter
"Great breakfast with cool planes to look at. Highly..."
Craig Rowlings
"Their fried chicken Benedict is to die for! Highly recommend stopping by this place if you’re in Martha’s..."
Maya Menefee
"Good eats, great & interesting location, efficient staff/service...oooh, but do the Bi-plane ride BEFORE your flight...!!!..."
David S Nolan
"Breakfast is fabulous. You will probably have to wait, but they text your phone when your table is ready. Worth it, and you can watch the airport..."
Richard Hamilton
"I had the Spiced Chickpea Stew. It was delicious! The quality and variety of ingredients used were great, and the portion size was bigger than I..."
Ben Henry
"This past season of 2019 was just fine. It's fun to sit and watch small airplanes come in and out of the grass strip Airport. The only problem is..."
Michael Teiger
"Great little place. Awesome to be able to watch the planes take off from the airfield. Definitely a decent wait on weekend/holiday mornings. Our..."
Ariella Fishkin
"Food was solid but many choices were not available. Was never asked what type of sauce I wanted on my BBQ. It was the first night of summer menu so I..."
Eric Ragot
"Fantastic location, great food. Lots of innovative new items on the menu for the 2016 season with some great vegetarian options. I had the grilled..."
E Hazen
"RFD is a great place for family food gatherings. There is parking for both cars and bikes. It is right beside Katama Airfield which means there is..."
Stella graceU
"Cute setting at the air field. Food was really good. Staff was nice. Fun watching the planes take off and land. Smoothies are fresh and delicious. I..."
Cheryl Kozlosky
"Great food! Wonderful pancakes - just like Mom (or Dad) used to make. Sit on the back deck, eat your delicious breakfast and watch the take-offs and..."
Richard C. Laskey
"Locally grown fresh ingredients. Airfield adjacent to diner which added to the ambiance. Attentive..."
Warren Mitchell
Dairy Queen (treat)
81/100 (1160 ratings)
Quick Bites
Dessert
Fast food
American
Fast Food
Drumstick with Peanuts
Ice Cream
Sit down
Fast food
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Cheap Eats
"Fast service delicious ice cream! Try it you'll like..."
Liz Ackerman
"Best ice cream place ever!! LOVE AJ he is the kindest, sweetest, most patient guy..."
Kristen Marie
"Opening for the season, a tiny bit of newness, but all good. The soft serve is by far the best around. Fast service, friendly staff and plenty of..."
Lou Dimovich
"Only the best in Edgartown hands down !!! Please check it and be sure to tip the awesome staff..."
Junior Griffiths
"I was pleasantly surprised with my experience at Dairy Queen!! I have been to other Dairy Queen’s before and this location definitely ranks as the..."
Alisha Gandhi
"Always a must stop! Closest fast food on the island. It’s hard to beat the vanilla cone dipped in chocolate. They offer take away frozen cakes at a..."
Sarah Caledonia
"Love this place ice cream is delicious Service is great had a wonderful time I'll be back next..."
Shelley Foster
"If you're accustomed to going to DQ off-island be prepared to be stunned! This cute little DQ is a walk-in/walk-out location that only offers hotdog..."
Jillian G.
"As of March 23, 2021 the location flag posted by Google is incorrect. It shows the Dairy Queen in Vineyard Haven near the Vineyard Haven Library. ..."
Stephen Warriner
"It's a Dairy Queen ! it's always been neat and clean and well-run in my experience and if you can deal with the traffic to get there or hop on your..."
Elly Bananas
"My friend had her first DQ experience here. Didn’t..."
L. B.
"One of the only non island based chains on the island. I highly recommend the DQ to anyone in the area that just wants a little ice cream or a..."
Zack
"Blizzards are great. They had the shop setup for covid spacing. In and out, swift..."
O M
"Clean and quick service. Can't go wrong with a blizzard...."
Jade Zeller
"Classic selections for a..."
John DeChristopher
"They give out the best ice cream you'll ever see, something you can't just from a..."
Hannah Landers
"It’s effing Dairy..."
Wesley Villano
"Awesome soft serve vanilla with cherry dipped on a hot day nothing like..."
David Stevens
"Great service. Great ice cream choices and..."
Jerome Neidigh
The Scoop Shack
80/100 (238 ratings)
Dessert
American
Ice Cream
Ice Cream
Brown Sugar Banana
Sit down
American
Takeout
Cheap Eats
"Delicious homemade ice cream, best on the island! Today, I had the lemon lavender and coconut macaroon -..."
Beth Zaneto
"Seriously amazing ice-cream and adorable spot! There was a great variety of flavors and I wanted to try all of them! Super creamy and delicious...the..."
Linda Romanchok
"Delicious! My daughter had the cotton candy cone and it tasted so..."
Elizabeth Kader
"Absolutely the best coffee and cookie dough ice cream I've ever had. I wish I could try other flavors but these two are just soooo good! A must stop..."
Cortni Herod
"Fabulous little ice cream & candy shop! Ice cream is made on site and is delicious. Lots of candy options for those who are dairy free (no dairy-free..."
Karyn Martin
"Massive line but totally worth the wait. This is not your stereotypical ice shop with regular flavors so do be mindful of that. However, this is the..."
Natalie Caldwell
"Amazing ice cream. I’m very picky and a bit of a self proclaimed ice cream connoisseur and this place has unique flavors, but the ice cream..."
Kt K
"During our day trip to Martha’s Vineyard, we looked for an ice cream shop in Edgartown. They had a few to choose from, and we tried Scoop..."
Foodlover Girl
"Kids loved this place with plenty of choices for everyone. The homemade waffle cones were fresh and yummy! Also had other candy options if ice cream..."
Michael Hartwell
"I am so late writing my review but I was at the Scoop Shack last month and had the best ice cream. It was delicious and the ladies who were working..."
Brandi Sutton
"Went here with the family and enjoyed the experience. They had a number of flavors and we actually got to meet the guy responsible for making the ice..."
DJ Shirley
"Nice little ice cream and candy shop. They have all kinds of great candy and classic little toys and tokens. Store has a cool style. Lots of ice..."
Peter
"Best ice cream on MV, and that’s saying something on an island known for it. If I had to recommend one flavor, it would be peanut butter. I’ve..."
Jeremy Greenfield
"Best ice cream on the island! Love the texture, taste and creative flavors! Excellent customer service. Visited..."
Blake
"Best Ice Cream in town by far. These two 1-star reviews are really funny because 1 - they are complaining about a totally different venue as it is..."
Colin Wuerthele
"Insanely good ice cream but the cone did not taste that great so can't give 5 stars. Go here but just don't get a sugar..."
Blathers
"You can't go wrong with the sea salt caramel truffle and Heath bar mix. The scoops are enormous so you'll likely be fine with 1 scoop (even split..."
Troy Shepley
"Really good homemade..."
Austin c
"Best ice cream of all time! They also have 32 flavors, a candy shop and anything you can..."
Gabriel Rzezwicki
"Hands down the best ice cream on the island. Super friendly staff and a wonderful candy section while you..."
Kerry Gallivan
"Easily the best ice cream on Martha’s Vineyard - yes, we tried them all. Ben and Bill’s is a very close..."
Dave Cowing
"I’m only giving them 5 stars because I cannot give them 9. The ice cream is delicious and there are many amazing..."
Phil
Mad Martha's
78/100 (537 ratings)
Dessert
American
American
Ice Cream
Café
American
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Cheap Eats
"Delish. � Coconut. Stop in for my fix every time on..."
Deirdre Glynn Pew
"Best ice cream I have ever tried!!! I miss it so much!..."
Tamuna Gachechiladze
"Yummy. Serious flavor! Kids working at Edgartown wete so polite. Grab an icecream after Vineyard Vines next door. Time then for grown ups to enjoy...."
Lanski Crew
"I anxiously await the re-opening each year! It is the best ice cream on the Vineyard and the Edgartown store gets my business each time we are..."
Rebecca Robertson
"Just go get the Mocha..."
Jaime Michelle Kennedy
"These Californians ABSOLUTELY enjoyed our ice cream..."
Cristine Pia Rschnab
"Best m&m ice cream there is. My first stop off the..."
Scott Keays
"Awesome ice cream! You go to the vineyard, you go to MAD..."
Kathleen Bloomstein
"Best ice cream ever. It's sooo good...."
Tricia Fuller
"It's simply the..."
Ryan Edward Cabral
"Ice cream is the best..."
Valerie Cowell Kamerer
"Top notch Blueberry Ice..."
James Ferenzi
"Best ice cream on MV by far! The snickers cream and butter crunch are fantastic. Been here 4 times in 2 weeks with my family and we love..."
BigDaddy
"Of course you need ice cream. If you find yourself lucky enough to be strolling down Main Street in Edgartown, then you should stop for a cone...."
Meg Lewellyn
"My wife and I stopped in at their Oak Bluffs location and it is definitely worth the stop. They had tons of flavors and snickers one was delicious...."
Mike Gallagher
"My spouse and I stopped in for two single scoops of the mudslide ice cream. Including a tip, it was $15. Thought it was a little pricey. The ice..."
Rebecca Leser
"If you’re craving good ole ice cream, then Mad Martha’s is a place to go. The offerings are also kid friendly and generous servings. The staff is..."
Joseph Adelantar
"It was fine. Exactly what you would expect. If you want one scoop, no you cannot get a half scoop of two flavors. One note - if you have a food..."
Natalie Caldwell
"The people who work there are friendly and helpful. They have a lot of different flavors of ice cream that I haven't tried tried before so luckily..."
Danny
"Ice cream was amazing and my brother just asked for a small waffle cone with whipped cream and they made it for him with no..."
Sam Vieira
"Vivid variety of uncommon ice cream combos, floats, brownies sundaes..."
Siddhi Kulkarni
"Very creamy and delicious. Also very crowded, so you will need to plan to eat it while you walk around Main St. Lots of flavors that you never see..."
Melene Hatcher
"The “sizes” are actually number of scoops. At least as far as I can tell. A small is one scoop, medium two, etc. Would be nice to mix flavors in..."
Thomas Lynn
"Excellent ice cream spot in..."
Christopher Guerin
"Excellent ice cream, good service, cold air conditioning, and average prices for the island $$$. And don't bring your dog in there unless they really..."
T
"Great Ice Cream. I had a 2 scoop cone with Blueberry and Peppermint flavors. A refreshing combination. It is possible to order as many as 3 scoops in..."
Cory Sacharoff
"This ice cream is what brings me to Martha’s..."
Jaclyn Scott
Vineyard Scoops
76/100 (232 ratings)
Dessert
Ice Cream
Café
Takeout
Cheap Eats
"I stopped by for ice cream twice last week with my husband and want to shout out the nice young lady who was working both evenings we visited! She..."
Jane Ma Nolan
"Sorbet ice cream ( wildberry and lemonade) both are good , they accept cash only and there is ATM inside their store. They have a variety of flavors..."
Muneerh M.
"Favorite ice cream spot on the island. Some of your standard flavors with TONS of others to try out. For those vegan or diary intolerant, THEY GOT..."
Natalie Caldwell
"Both my wife and my ice cream was very, very good (she had chocolate and I had black raspberry). I just docked one star because the waffle cones..."
Jeff F
"My favorite ice cream in Edgartown. It has that homemade taste made with love & experience. Look for the owner,depicted in paintings through the..."
Ryan Meo
"Yummy ice cream. Their homemade waffle cones are so..."
Jasna Acharya
"Best ice cream on the island- cones are made (on site) to perfection. If you want the salted caramel, come..."
John Hobby
"Popped in here on a warm day and got some absolutely fantastic ice cream! I went for the salted caramel - perfection. Wife grabbed the sugar free..."
Dave Dotson
"Love this shop! The ice cream is great and they have expanded the menu this summer to include smoothies, milkshakes and health add ins for your..."
Erica Milkovich-Padilla
"Excellent ice cream & excellent service. The homemade waffle cone is the..."
Robyn Chung
"I patrolled this establishment twice. The first time, I ordered a maple walnut waffle cone. Today, I ordered a butter pecan and strawberry waffle..."
El El-Maadway
"visited summer 2021 This place is like all the other ice cream places that are on the island for some reason. The staff was great, the products are..."
Keith Jackson
"Super yummy ice cream and very friendly. Don't go anywhere else on the island and you will be happy. Fresh real tasting ingredients. If you ask for..."
Avi Smith-Rapaport
"Delicious flavors and top notch waffle cones. Only improvement would be if they could either plug up the bottom of the waffle cone or provide a..."
Scott Parker
"Sea salt caramel truffle was rich, creamy, and absolutely delicious..."
Vicki Barber
"I have a son who has a nut and egg allergy, and I have to say, the ice cream was very good. The staff was very helpful and the price is very good. My..."
Paddy Srinivasan
"Great place, great Ice Cream, great location, great Staff. Everything was clean and well sorted, the flavors made me return for more. Smiling staff..."
RJ Dune
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use