Sluurpy
Reset

There are 5 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Duck in Edgartown

There are 5 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
The Covington
93/100 (209 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegan Options
American
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Tequila Strawberry
Cannellini Bean Hummus
Ceviche
Three Sisters Salad
Tuna Salad
Lamb
Squash
Pesto
Garden Salad
Fish
Pickled Cucumbers
Pork
Parmesan Basil
Mushroom Ragu
Tagliatelle
Pasta
Spicy Cold Cucumber Salad
Honey Pie
Salad
Smoked Beets
Serrano Pepper
Scallops
Walnut Pesto Ricotta Gnocchi
MVM Kale Salad
Duck
Sweet Potato Rolls with Herb Butter
The Grey Barn Eidolon Cheese
Nova Scotia Halibut
MVM Mushroom Ragù
American
Outdoor Seating
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Full Bar
Dinner
Fine Dining
"I now have a new favorite restaurant! Covington has exceptional staff, amazing flavors and combinations, top notch freshness, and is an all-around..."
Tara Clapper
"Knock my socks off! Wait, we don’t wear socks on Martha’s Vineyard. No matter. This restaurant welcomed us without a reservation and treated us..."
Susan McConnell
"Came here for dinner. We didn’t have reservations on a Saturday night but there was a space at a counter for two of us. We started with the kale..."
NY chinchilla
"Wow! The food is amazing! Hard to believe but the artisan sourdough bread with the spread was indescribably delicious! The smoked beets appetizer was..."
Dan Colucci
"What a good find! The food is the best I've tried on the island. Above and beyond with flavors and variety of ingredients. I had the seafood homemade..."
Bill R
"Great restaurant and service. Highlights were the clam and chorizo and chocolate..."
Sam Jones
"What a wonderful dinner that we stumbled upon. Outside on the side patio we started off with the cold spicy cucumber appetizer and the cheeseboard. A..."
M W
"The food was beyond exceptional, the flavor profile hit all the right notes… our server was Summer who was a breath of fresh air being so..."
Elias Janetis
"My wife and I were visiting MV for our anniversary. We stumbled upon this place to grab a drink and a snack. What a fabulous experience. The staff is..."
Joe Coppola
"Our second time dining at The Covington and it didn’t disappoint. We split the spicy cucumbers which were once again excellent and also the clams..."
Jon Wayman
Atria
87/100 (927 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegan Options
American
American
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Late Night
Lobster
Pasta
Bass
Salad
Prosciutto
Crab
Lamb
Scallops
Pesto
Duck
Fish
Calamari
Pork
Tuna
Burger
Calamares
Hamburgers
Cod
Swordfish
Shrimp
Halibut
Beef
Foie gras
Ribs
Sit down
American
Reservations
Parking Available
Full Bar
Seating
Table Service
Outdoor Seating
Serves Alcohol
Private Dining
Late Night
Dinner
Fine Dining
"Loved everything about it We were there for a wedding reception We were outside under the covered space which was just beautiful and had dinner out..."
Lloyd Chet Lewis
"My husband and I held our ceremony and reception outside on 6/22/18 and could not have had a better day! We started planning earlier in the year and..."
Jessica Knight
"Great food. Service was excellent. Drinks were out of this world. Highly recommend the wok fried lobster and the last day on earth..."
Robert DiPadova Jr
"The best dining experience you could get on the island. Excellent food, amazing wine selection from all over the world, beautiful bar with craft..."
Ralitsa Ivanova
"The best burgers to be found on the island!! I had the BBQ Brisket burger with truffle fries. Absolutley..."
David Robertson
"Every single dish I have ever had from Chef Christian Thornton is amazing. So much so that I find it impossible to eat any meal I have had from his..."
Clair Carroll Koroma
"Atria was the most spectacular venue to host a rehearsal dinner for my son and daughter-in-law. Everything about the evening was perfect. The food..."
Dawson Moore Greenland
"Spectacular! From the arrival greeting by Greer to the table greeting by Rock our superb waiter, on to reading the clever and informative menu, to..."
Tom Boerger
"Our favorite fine dining restaurant on all of Martha's Vineyard. Whatever we choose to eat off of the menu is delicious and absolutely..."
India Rose
"Greer and staff, I want to thank you for an amazing experience, my wedding was fabulously tended, you are the best there is, We couldn't have asked..."
Glenda Rose
"10 years ago my husband and I had our Rehearsal Dinner here. It was truly a memorable evening with family and friends. Last evening my husband and I..."
Jennifer Petty
"Delicious upscale cuisine and impeccable service upstairs. Perfect burger and truffle fries downstairs. Great anytime! But they also put on the best..."
Lisa Gilberto-Cunningham
"Always a great dining experience - elegant yet comfortable atmosphere, great service and scrumptious..."
Dina Salvatore BenDavid
"Great food! Great location! Burgers are amazing and the truffle fries are to die for! MV ❤️..."
Rose Walsh
"I can’t hardly wait to get back here every year. Burgers in basement seriously rock. Fast Eddie with jalapeños and gorgeous bottle of red...."
Sandi McBeth Ennor
"Our family has been eating here every summer for the past ten years and somehow they continue to blow us away. Tonight cocktails, apps, entrees,..."
Jeff Zilberfarb
"This is probably one of the best, if not THE best restaurant on the island. The attention to detail was incredibly impressive, from the choice of..."
Steven Pego
"I had the pleasure of dining at Atria in Martha's Vineyard with my wife yesterday and we were blown away by the experience. From the moment we..."
Joe Paul
"In the top two of our favorite dinners on the island, and also one of our most expensive meals as well (two cocktails were almost $50). For that..."
Natalie Caldwell
"Atria has an amazing atmosphere and incredible food and drink. We shared several appetizers and each was incredible in both presentation and taste...."
emily balog
"Conflicting feelings about Atria…. Let’s start with the good: atmosphere. The place is beautiful, and it’s got great vibes. The lobster /..."
Richard Levins
"Food and service was great. Cocktails were average $15, but they packed a punch. They have three sitting areas (main floor, patio, basement) but both..."
Alex Alapatt
"Atria is hands down our favorite restaurant on the island! We have been going for the past 5 years and it never disappoints. This year Greer hosted..."
Arika Vissers
"Exactly what comes to mind when envisioning a fine dining experience. Their Staff go the extra mile to be pleasant, from hostess station, table..."
Linda D. Gaines
"Best restaurant on the island! Whether you want a fancy special occasion dinner or (like me) just want to hang out at the cellar bar. Prices are high..."
Lisa Bruce
Detente Restaurant And Wine Bar
84/100 (937 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Contemporary
American
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Contemporary
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Dinner
Late Night
Drinks
Bolognese
Bread Pudding Dessert
Pasta
Bread Pudding
Bay Scallops
Salad
Lamb
The Pinger
Scallops
Pesto
Tuna Tartare Starter
Duck
Fish
Halibut Main
Risotto
Pork
Fried Cornbread Panzanella
Tuna
Chicken
Grilled octopus
Seared Tuna
Sea Bass
Cod
Pinot Grigio
mozzarella sticks
Swordfish
Ricotta
Beef
cheese board
Halibut
Lobster Risotto
Steak Trio
Ribs
Scallop Appetizer
Beef
Lobster
Bass
Pasta
Octopus
Polenta
Sit down
American
Contemporary
Outdoor Seating
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Reservations
Serves Alcohol
Full Bar
Late Night
Dinner
Drinks
Fine Dining
"A charming restaurant tucked away in the heart of Edgartown in Martha Vineyard. The food was prepared wonderfully, friendly service and comfortable..."
Joseph Adelantar
"My friend and I had the most wonderful dinner. It was ‘opening for the season night’ at Detente, and they hit it right off the bat. The food was..."
Susanna Herlitz-Ferguson
"Established Martha’s Vineyard eatery. We sat at the bar where we enjoyed excellent service, delicious eats and relaxed yet elegant vibes. The..."
Loretta Lambright Redrick
"Détente Restaurant was one of the places recommended by the Inn we were staying at. While walking around town, we found this restaurant hidden on a..."
Hilary Levitt
"Absolutely amazing restaurant! First off the service is the absolute best. We came here this past Tues for dinner. We had made a reservation online..."
jennifer subnarine
"Excellent meal shared with family! Everything was cooked perfectly. We had grilled octopus, burrata salad, scallops, lamb, venison and bass. For..."
Donna D
"Probably my favorite restaurant on the entire island, we've been going to Detente for years now and their consistency and creativity is incredible!..."
Marnely Murray
"Tonight was an incredible dinner and the best restaurant on the island ! Our waitress was outstanding and so sweet with our baby. The food and drinks..."
Mam Z
"Proper foodie place. Everything well thought out and the service was top..."
Sam Jones
"Food was pretty good here! Nice ambience outside but there was some mosquitos. Just bring your bug spray if you sit outside! They bring bread to the..."
Amrit Mattu
"Best meal we had in Edgartown though we had many excellent dining experiences.. We loved this place. The food was just excellent and the service was..."
Bill McLeod
"Enjoyed our wedding anniversary at Detente. The best pork chop and chicken we ever had. The chef is a..."
Richard Wolschlager
"I've been twice now and could not be more impressed with this place. The food has been phenomenal: both creative and perfectly executed. They also..."
Scott Matus
"Highly recommend you visit Detente on your visit to Martha’s Vineyard. Our server was charming and very attentive (I forget his name he had a bit..."
Lauren McLaughlin
"Excellent food. Comfortable seating upstairs. Wait staff couldn't have been more..."
Laura & Matt L
"A favorite of ours for years. Consistently imaginative and flavorful cooking. Fine wine list. Truly professional..."
Tim Delaney
"Excellent meal! Terrific bartender as well. We started with the beet salad, delicious. Then we had the Bolognese with homemade pasta, perfectly..."
L M
Alchemy Bistro & Bar
79/100 (2205 ratings)
Restaurants
European
American
American
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Brunch
Dinner
Cod
Swordfish
Pasta
Halibut
Salad
Crab
Confit
Scallops
Cobb Salad
Clams
Roast Chicken
Duck
Burger
Lamb
Oyster
Hamburgers
Pesto
Risotto
Fish
Tuna
Pork
Salmon
Shrimp
Ragu
Beef
Tapas
Tacos
Filet Mignon
Lobster
Sit down
American
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Television
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Private Dining
Accepts American Express
Accepts Discover
Seating
Table Service
Serves Alcohol
Reservations
Gift Cards Available
Full Bar
Dinner
Fine Dining
"I’ve dined there 4 times this spring. Every meal and drink on..."
Ned Casey
"Go-to spot in Edgartown to indulge + imbibe. I literally dream about their Espresso..."
Alyssa Stevens
"Absolutely stunning in every regard! The restaurant itself is an architectural gem, a feast for the eyes. We sat on the second floor looking over an..."
Allen Greenman
"I was in the area for one night and my friend insisted we go there for dinner.. it didn't disappoint!!! The Halibut was amazing and I loved the..."
Amy Heilweil Ribacoff
"I was overly impressed with the menu and experience we had here. I will definitely be..."
Katelyn O'Sullivan
"Amazing service, atmosphere and food. Great recommendation of wine to go with our..."
Theresa Bassett
"Awesome place, best cosmos ever! The food and decor are amazing, I want to go back..."
Erin Dugan
"Delicious food with lovely presentations! Great service and very inviting..."
Alenda Gardner
"Amazing food and service!!! Been coming here for years and never had anything but the best..."
Mj Sansouci
"Exquisite service, wonderfully prepared food! It's as good as, if not better than, the former Oyster Bar in Oak..."
Paul Logan
"The new menu is amazing! Cocktails..."
Lindsay Rotondi
"Excellent meal and cocktails. The service was fast and..."
John Coppola
"Pretty good tasting food and drinks. Had the halibut with the crab & corn risotto. The risotto was great! The halibut was slightly overcooked. The..."
Michael Peterson
"My favorite restaurant in the whole world. Tonight we sat on the balcony outside and it was magic. Our server was kind and patient. The food always,..."
Susan McConnell
"My fiance and I have eaten all over the world, including most recently Italy. We ordered the pork chop special, surf and turf, and steam buns and..."
Steffani Pouliot
"If you want to be in the center of town and hear laughters and cheers, then this is the place for you. We ordered the king crab as a starter along..."
Joseph Adelantar
"Elegant restaurant to enjoy while on vacation! Friendly staff and beautiful upstairs dining room. Ordered the crispy oysters for an app and the..."
Charmaine Pequeno
"Very good place in general but very expensive. Top notch menu. Attentive service. Our food arrived only luke warm but I assume that was a..."
Nils Krahnstoever
"Great for an evening out of leisure dinner or cocktails. There is a large bar scene at this two story restaurant. If you want to come for dinner,..."
Natalie Caldwell
"The food here is excellent! Favorite dishes : Hand-Cut Yellowfin Tuna Tartare and Surf &..."
Jasna Acharya
"My daughters and I were seated upstairs in the back room next to the fireplace. It was a fun spot to sit; we could look out across the rooms and..."
Kristine Fitts
"Alchemy is a great restaurant during the season and off season as well as they are open most of the winter. Perfect people watching spot! The food is..."
Marnely Murray
"Loved this place. The bartender did not have orange bitters, but other than that, the food was amazing. We went earlier so we had no wait and we..."
Jason Plattenberger
"The food was excellent and the service, while very good, fell slightly short on a couple occasions. I hate to nit pick, but to get a five star in my..."
Jason Kiesel
"Chic atmosphere, great food, and a secret bar upstairs. One of my go-to nice restaurants on the..."
Lauren Wadsworth
"Food ambiance and device was all above par. Excellent attention to detail. Great cocktails. Def would go here again next time I’m in..."
Vinu Kurian
"One of the best meals we've ever had. Everything was perfectly cooked and amazing flavors. Some of the most delicious drinks as..."
Nicole Bates
"We had our anniversary dinner here on 5/1. Upon sitting at the bar, we were given a glass of excellent champagne. Stewie was a great bartender,..."
Paul Millar
"Had dinner here, food and drinks were excellent! Great customer service and ambiance. Highly..."
Marissa L Tilley
L'etoile Restaurant
72/100 (1402 ratings)
Restaurants
French
Contemporary
French
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Contemporary
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Late Night
Drinks
Lamb chops
Filet Mignon
Pasta
Polenta
Lobster Fra Diavolo
Salad
Surf And Turf
Crispy Spanish Octopus
Mac and cheese
Octopus
Startini
Crab
Crepes
Surf and Turf with Flat Iron Steak
Scallops
Lamb
Braised Boneless Short Ribs
Duck
Pesto
Burger
Fish
Oyster
Panna Cotta
Shellfish
Oysters
Salmon
Shrimp
Greek salad
Martini
Juice
Filet Mignon
Crumble
Halibut
Cheesecake
Lobster
Foie gras
Ceviche
Ribs
Lamb Chops
Sit down
Contemporary
French
Gift Cards Available
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Private Dining
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Late Night
Dinner
Drinks
Fine Dining
"love sitting in the bar here to have dinner (they serve full menu). The octopus is the most tender and flavorful that I've had on the island. The..."
Melissa Sliwkowski
"Started with the Foie Gras, my wife didnt know what it was... it was outstanding. 5/5 Secondly we had the cheese plate. All four cheeses we..."
Damian Grammont
"The lobster pappardelle was out of this world! Best food, best..."
Jaime Martinez Scholz
"We dined here during the Winefest weekend in May. Some reviews had been iffy but we decided to try it any way. We were not disappointed in any way...."
Terre Bird
"Superb meal....food, service, presentation...all top..."
Charlie Kernick
"Ah-mazing dinner. Get the lobster. Service, food & setting were..."
Felicia Wilson
"Best meal we had during our stay in MV. Surf and turf was excellent as was the sweet pea and asparagus..."
Beth Zaneto
"Hands down it'll be the best food you'll ever..."
Jeannine Brisson Dugas
"The number one fine dinning restaurant! This place is not only a fine dinning restaurant where the food is amazing! It's a place of making lifetime..."
Tatiana Tonalezzi
"Amazing from start to finish! We were totally taken with it all! Ambiance, cocktails, food and service were..."
Bill Gannon
"Food and service are..."
Nicole Marie Lynch
"What a beautiful Resturant ,staff ,Michael our meals were simply superb.We were so happy to bring the parents they can't stop talking about you and..."
Donna Holden Pirtle
"One of the best restaurants on the island, enjoyed our 27th anniversary dinner..."
Jeff Wyrich
"For fine dining on Martha's Vineyard, it's L'etoile. Home of the best bite on earth: Michael Brisson's Fois..."
Terrell Sandefur
"Culinary heaven on earth! Thank you for taking great care of my family and friends summer after..."
Alfred B. Glover
"Best Restaurant on the Vineyard Eat there every year the short ribs are fantastic..the starlini martini also the..."
Lee Catalano Maciel
"Beautiful atmosphere. The food is excellent and..."
Sophia Cousins
"So many memories and unbelievable food! Thank you for always being the biggest STAR ever. My love also to..."
Suzee Lynn
"This was a great experience. Good food and cocktails, also amazing service. Loved the Australian influence, especially the lamb and the pavlova...."
Mel B
"My husband and I had dinner at l'etoile for our wedding anniversary and we're impressed by the restaurant's ambience, food, and level of..."
Jane Ma Nolan
"My Wife and I had an amazing dining experience at L'Etoile from the moment we arrived to good bye! We ate out in the front yard which made all the..."
Dave Gordon
"I have stopped by here a couple of times. The first time we just had a couple glasses of wine outside on the lawn in the adirondack chairs. It feels..."
Shauna Walker
"Enjoyed almost everything about our dining experience. Good cocktails and we both had the lamb which was perfect. The greeter and our waitress both..."
Brendan T
"Very good on all fronts. Great food and service - one of the best meals I've had on the island. Everything we ordered was delicious and the lamb..."
John Hickey
"The perfect spot for a special date night or celebration. Must order: short ribs, the surf & turf with the best house made pasta ever, and any of the..."
Marnely Murray
"Great service, amazing oysters! The octopus was cooked to perfection with the most amazing sauce! My husband had the surf and turf which was..."
Kiran Panjwani
"One of my favorite French restaurants. Food is superb. Highly..."
Lisa M C
"Enjoyed the experience of the private event at L'Etoile after the opening night for the MVAAFF. The atmosphere was nice, with both indoor and outdoor..."
Janelle Jones
"Do yourself a favor and visit this lovely restaurant! The service is unmatched. The staff truly cares about your experience. The food is absolutely..."
Katerina Ivannikova
"With the recommendation from our concierge, we recently chose to dine here on the eve of our special anniversary. We could not have anticipated a..."
S. Clark
"Favorite restaurant anywhere. Chef owner Michael has been doing it right for 40 years. Every dish is elevated. Do not miss the lobster. Or the lamb...."
Andrew Aliberti
"Everything we ordered was delicious and exceeded our expectations. It surpassed Boston standards. This restaurant would undoubtedly survive in..."
Nadia Daly
"Absolutely amazing! Each course kept getting better and better, even with dishes I wouldn't regularly order. I was a bit skeptical that I would like..."
Jonathan Healy
"Loved our anniversary dinner here. The duck was..."
Bill McLeod
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use