Heinnie's is at the top of my list as a favorite place to eat. They have the best prime rib ever, and the staff is awesome!!!
Amazing steaks and great food! Quaint and friendly staff. Troy and Bill, the owners, take great pride in this place!
What an awesome place to eat. Very friendly people and some of the best food in town I have been going there for years an I've always enjoyed the fast service and great drinks
Awesome food.. Great staff... Great atmosphere.. would recommend it to everyone...
Located right behind the shop that I run in Elkhart, I try to hit this place a couple times a month. Great food, great staff!
Diane Kuliczkowski Lewis
+5
Food was amazing, very personable staff and quick service! Not a huge sign out front, but the place was packed!! Prime rib was really good!!
Had the Tuesday night special - barbeque brisket. Generous portion size, sauce was good & know we will be back soon. Delicious!
Food is always excellent! Casual dining and very friendly staff! Just love this place and have for decades!
Food was so good I took a whole meal home for later.. will always return for some of the best food around!!!
Fantastic steak! A little pricey but well worth it. Big portions and super friendly environment!
Best streak and prime rib ever!!!!! My fiancé got the prime rib and I got the ribeye and we shared. Needless to say we left STUFFED !!!! That place is definitely one of our new favorites.
Outstanding! We ordered the 32 ounce sirloin for two- two sides each. OMG-delicious! The baked potato was huge, as were the side salads. Texas toast was wonderful and the steak? The steak was perfection! We’ll be returning next time we’re in town from Ohio!
We are from out of town and was looking for a good local restaurant. When we arrived the parking lot was packed and was told it would be an hour wait, we waited and noticed people willing to wait up to 2 hours to eat here. Moral to the story when we were finally able to be seated service was great, staff was very friendly and attentive. The food was fantastic! I would highly recommend this place! We will for sure be back the next time we are in the area!
Excellent food and service! The atmosphere isn't classy or cozy, but is rustic and a great place for just having a good time. The waitress was efficient and kind. As for the food, the burger that I got was absolutely massive. I actually had to eat half of it at a time because it was so big.
Hidden gem. Took the wife here for a date night. Prime rib while it lasts, get it and get it char'd. Wife had it and I wanted to steal it. Lucky it was a Valentine date and I didn't want to end in the dog how. I ordered a New York strip. It was good but didn't stand a chance to the prime. Portions here are very generous as well so come hungry.
The food is good, but make sure you are very specific with your order. I ordered a "create your own burger", and told them what condiments I wanted on it. I did not say anything about having cheese on it. When asked if that was all I wanted on it, I said "yes: I did not order any cheese because I don't like cheese on my burgers. When I got my carry-out home, I found cheese on my burger that I had to scrape off.
First time there and the food was amazing!
The food there is so good, I get the same thing all the time smothered chicken. The staff if great
I generally use a rubric when scoring restaurants- Service, Food (quality, taste, cooked to order), Atmosphere, etc.
I would officially give Heinnies a 4.9. The only area we gave less than 5 stars was atmosphere.
The food was amazing - prime rib cooked perfectly to medium rare! Baked Potato was delicious as well and comes as loaded as you would like. We tried the pretzle bites as an app, they were quite soft and tasty.
Service was friendly and fast. They had exhausted their supply of a menu item we ordered and our server went out of her way to offer a solution.
Our drinks, both water and mixed, were delivered quickly and well made (mixed).
Definitely try Heinnies if you're looking for a well established (45+ years), local, establishment!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes